2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Wall Street & Banking

The 2010 Dodd-Frank Act and Its 2018 Rollback

Period covered: July 21, 2010 · 4 sources

Summary

On July 21, 2010 the president signed the 848 page Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act and said there would be no more tax funded bailouts, period. The law created a consumer bureau, a council to watch the largest firms, and a way to wind one down. It did not break up the banks, its rules were written under lobbying, and in 2018 Congress raised the threshold for close oversight from $50 billion to $250 billion.

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, H.R. 4173 of the 111th Congress, is named for Senator Christopher Dodd of Connecticut, who chaired the Banking Committee, and Congressman Barney Frank of Massachusetts, who chaired Financial Services. The House passed the final bill 237 to 192 on June 30, 2010, the Senate passed it 60 to 39 on July 15, and President Obama signed it on July 21. It was the largest change to financial law since the 1930s.

Key Provisions

The law created the Financial Stability Oversight Council, chaired by the Treasury secretary, to identify firms whose failure could threaten the system and put them under stricter Federal Reserve supervision. It gave the government an orderly liquidation authority, a legal way to take over and wind down a failing financial company, which had not existed for Lehman Brothers or AIG. It required most standard derivatives to be traded on exchanges and cleared through clearinghouses, with reporting of the trades. It created the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, funded through the Federal Reserve instead of through the annual appropriations in Congress, to write and enforce rules on mortgages, credit cards, and other consumer lending. It included the Volcker rule, meant to bar banks that hold insured deposits from trading for their own account. It added an Office of Financial Research, new rules for credit rating agencies, and a requirement that firms selling mortgage securities keep a share of the risk.

Exemptions and Lobbying

The proposals to break up the largest banks were kept out of the bill. Interviewees in FRONTLINE's series describe armies of lobbyists working the details, and one member of the administration said the bill left so much to be decided in rule writing that the important decisions were being made out of public view, where the lobbyists could reach them. The Volcker rule was ten pages when proposed and nearly 300 pages of exemptions when written. The rules for swaps were meant to apply to any bank trading more than $100 million a year, and the threshold was raised to $8 billion. The Financial Stability Oversight Council identified BlackRock, the largest asset manager, as a firm large enough to threaten the system, and BlackRock's lobbying campaign kept the designation off. By 2012 the five largest banks were larger than they had been in 2007, holding assets equal to 56 percent of the economy.

The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, which Congress created to establish the causes of the crisis, reported in January 2011 that the crisis was avoidable, that it was the result of human action and inaction, and that the regulators at the Federal Reserve and the other agencies had ignored the evidence in front of them.

After

In May 2018 Congress passed the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act, which raised the size at which a bank comes under the closest supervision from $50 billion in assets to $250 billion. Banks between those sizes, including the ones that failed in 2023, were released from the annual stress tests and the stricter capital rules. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has been the target of repeated efforts to defund or close it.

The president's words at the signing were that because of the law the American people would never again be asked to foot the bill for Wall Street's mistakes. The witnesses at the end of the FRONTLINE series said that too big to fail had been made permanent, that the three things that had to be fixed, too big to fail, risky investments, and derivatives, were not fixed, and that the crisis never ended.

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (4)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2011
Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, GovInfo. The official report on the causes of the crisis.
2012
FRONTLINE (PBS). Bonuses, derivatives sold to towns and countries, Jefferson County, Greece, and the lobbying on the rules.
2012
FRONTLINE (PBS). The 2009 transition, the stress tests, and Dodd-Frank.

Documented Records (10)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2008
December 5, 2008
On this day the banks had $1.2 trillion in Federal Reserve loans outstanding, including $107 billion at Morgan Stanley, $99 billion at Citigroup, and $91 billion at Bank of America. In total the Fed made $7.7 trillion available. None of this was public until Bloomberg won a lawsuit at the Supreme Court.
“The biggest banks in the United States borrowed a heck of a lot more money than anybody had imagined.”
Federal Reserve. Violates: The public's right to know how public money is used. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Three, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2009
March 2009
The president met with thirteen bank chief executives, told them his administration was standing between them and public anger, and asked for no commitments. No conditions were set and no executives were removed.
“He had a room full of very frightened CEOs. He was in a position then to make demands, and he didn't.”
President Obama. Violates: Accountability for the people responsible. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Three, FRONTLINE (PBS)
May 7, 2009
The Treasury's stress tests found the 19 largest banks to be fundamentally sound. Critics inside and outside the administration said the tests were designed to produce that result.
“It's not that hard to cook a stress test and make it look like you're in much better shape than you are.”
Treasury Secretary Geithner. Violates: The government's duty to tell the public the truth. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Three, FRONTLINE (PBS)
September 2009
One year after the Lehman bankruptcy the president gave a speech on Wall Street calling for reform. The heads of the major banks, including Jamie Dimon and Lloyd Blankfein, did not attend.
“They don't even show up to the speech. They just had better things to do that day.”
Wall Street chief executives. Violates: Accountability for the people responsible. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Three, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2010
July 21, 2010
The Dodd-Frank Act was signed with a promise that there would be no more taxpayer bailouts. Proposals to break up the largest banks had been removed from the bill by lobbyists. The industry then spent more than $320 million lobbying on the rules, and the Volcker Rule grew from 10 pages to nearly 300, most of them exemptions.
“The banks have thrown every weapon they have on Washington. It's like one loophole after another.”
Congress, the banking lobby. Violates: Consent of the governed. Source: Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, H.R.4173, 111th Congress (2010), Congress.gov
2011
2011
The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission found that regulators at the Federal Reserve, the SEC, and other agencies had ignored evidence of the risks building in the financial system.
“They had deliberately turned a blind eye to those problems.”
Federal Reserve, SEC. Violates: Regulators' duty to act on warnings. Source: The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report (2011), Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, GovInfo
2002 to 2011
JP Morgan sold Jefferson County, Alabama, interest rate swaps on $3 billion of sewer debt, with payments to a local adviser that federal prosecutors treated as bribes. When rates moved in 2008 the county owed hundreds of millions of dollars. JP Morgan settled with the SEC for $25 million and forgave $697 million in fees. In November 2011 the county filed the largest municipal bankruptcy in U.S. history. Across the country, similar swaps have cost taxpayers about $20 billion.
“They came down here like sharks to raw meat in the water.”
JP Morgan, Charles LeCroy, Larry Langford. Violates: The duty not to deceive public bodies. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Four, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2008 to 2011
Since the crash, New York banks have paid more than $80 billion in bonuses. In 2011, a year in which their share prices fell, they set aside $20 billion.
“It's Christmastime on Wall Street.”
Wall Street banks. Violates: None. Listed to show where the public money went.. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Four, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2012
2012
The five largest banks in America are larger than before the crisis, with assets equal to 56 percent of the economy. After lobbying, the threshold for oversight of swap dealers was raised from $100 million to $8 billion in annual trades, which left 85 percent of derivative dealers outside regulation.
“We now somehow believe that finance sort of drives everything.”
The banking lobby, federal regulators. Violates: Equal application of the law to the financial industry. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Four, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2012
Three years after the bailouts, the FRONTLINE series on the crisis closed with the people who took part in it saying that too big to fail had been made permanent, that risky investments and derivatives had not been fixed, and that the crisis had not ended.
“In many respects, the financial crisis never ended. It never ended.”
The financial system as rebuilt after 2008. Violates: None in law. Listed for what it means going forward.. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Three, FRONTLINE (PBS)

Timeline Events (1)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

July 21, 2010
Dodd-Frank signed with a promise of no more taxpayer bailouts
Proposals to break up the largest banks had been removed from the bill. The financial industry then spent more than $320 million lobbying on the rules, and the Volcker Rule grew from 10 pages to nearly 300.
The 2010 Dodd-Frank Act and Its 2018 Rollback | Spirit of '76