2020 to today · Wall Street & Banking

How BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street Vote Your 401(k) Shares

Period covered: 1945 to 2024 · 1 source

Summary

BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street hold a stake in nearly every listed company, paid for with pension and 401(k) money. The people whose money it is sign away their votes, the asset managers almost always vote with management, and the managers decide for themselves whether they count as passive investors.

BlackRock manages about $10.6 trillion, more than half the annual output of the United States. It holds stock in about 95 percent of Fortune 500 companies and has been hired by governments around the world to manage financial crises. More Perfect Union looked at what the firm actually does, with help from Benjamin Braun, a professor of political economy at the London School of Economics who studies asset managers. The short version is that the money is not BlackRock's, and the power over it is.

What an asset manager is

An asset manager takes a customer's money and invests it. BlackRock's main products are index funds and exchange traded funds, which buy a little of every company in an index instead of betting on a few. They are cheaper to run than funds that pick stocks, because nobody has to be paid to place bets all day, and the studies show the stock pickers are not good at it anyway. Once the fund owns its slice of every company it holds the shares more or less forever. This is called passive investing.

Most of the money comes from institutions: pension funds, insurance companies, nonprofits, and university endowments. Most of that, in turn, comes from ordinary people, through public and private pensions, 401(k) accounts, college savings, and insurance premiums. The asset manager does not make its money from the returns on those investments. It makes its money from fees, and the fees go up when the value of the assets under management goes up. So the way to grow is to win more clients and get the existing ones to hand over more money. When you have $10 trillion to place, Braun said, you have to put it somewhere, and eventually somewhere becomes everywhere.

Universal ownership

The result is what Braun calls universal ownership. The three largest asset managers, BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street, hold a stake in every company on the stock market. BlackRock alone holds 3 to 10 percent of nearly all of them. That sounds small. It is not. When shareholding is dispersed, a 5 percent stake usually makes a fund the single largest shareholder in the company, which is why academic studies treat 5 percent as the threshold for control. The three firms together often hold around 25 percent. In Amazon they hold 16 percent. Jeff Bezos holds 9 percent.

Shares carry votes. When a person puts money into a pension fund, they sign their voting rights over to the pension fund manager. When the pension fund puts its money with an asset manager, it signs those votes over again. A 2017 study found that asset managers almost always vote the way company management recommends. Part of the reason goes back to the 1980s, when investors began paying executives in stock options so that their pay would rise and fall with shareholder returns. Management and the big shareholders now want the same thing, and the surest short term way to raise returns is to spend less on workers.

Braun described a second effect. BlackRock holds large stakes in Nike, Adidas, Lululemon, and Under Armour. If one outperforms the others it makes no difference to the fund. If they began cutting prices to compete with each other, the fund would lose money. The same is true of the airlines and the major banks, which all have the same large shareholders. The film calls it a monopoly without the merger. From 2014 to 2015 BlackRock held more than 1,500 private meetings with companies in its portfolio, and it has said that meetings behind closed doors can go further than votes against management.

Whose stock it is

In 1945 households owned 94 percent of stocks. Today households own about 40 percent, and half of that belongs to the top 10 percent. The top 1 percent own 50 percent of corporate equity and mutual fund shares. The top 10 percent own 86 percent. The bottom half of Americans own almost none. The argument that what is good for shareholders is good for everyone, because everyone's retirement is in the market, does not hold for half the country, and the decisions asset managers vote for affect all of it.

How the oversight went

After 2008 Congress created the Financial Stability Oversight Council to watch institutions that control large amounts of money but are not banks. The council pointed to BlackRock as a firm so large that its failure could cause another collapse and moved to put it under additional oversight. BlackRock doubled its lobbying spending, ran a targeted advertising campaign on the Washington Metro, and avoided the oversight that the large banks got. The firm is still not designated systemically important.

The rules that do apply depend on BlackRock being a passive investor, and the way that is decided is that BlackRock and the other asset managers submit an annual letter certifying that they have complied with the terms of passive investment. The film's comparison is being allowed to write whatever you want on your taxes and then audit yourself. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the FDIC have been working to regulate asset managers that own large pieces of banks the way banks are regulated, and the asset managers are lobbying against it.

Since 2004 BlackRock has hired at least 84 former government officials, regulators, and central bankers. Larry Fink sits on the board of the World Economic Forum. The biggest investors in BlackRock are Vanguard and State Street. The biggest investors in Vanguard are BlackRock and State Street. The biggest investors in State Street are BlackRock and Vanguard.

In practice, BlackRock does not own everything. It owns shares in everything, which gives it an outsized amount of control, and it gets paid by teachers' retirement funds to do it. The film's summary is that the old system of shareholder democracy is gone and what has replaced it is closer to a shareholder oligarchy.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (1)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

More Perfect Union. Includes an interview with Benjamin Braun, professor of political economy, on asset managers and universal ownership.

Documented Records (4)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2010
2010 onward
The Financial Stability Oversight Council, created by Dodd-Frank, identified BlackRock as large enough that its failure could cause another collapse and moved to put it under additional oversight. BlackRock doubled its lobbying spending, ran an advertising campaign on the Washington Metro, and its chief executive met with President Obama. The firm has not been designated systemically important.
BlackRock, Financial Stability Oversight Council. Violates: Equal application of the law to the financial industry. Source: BlackRock: The Conspiracies You Don't Know, More Perfect Union
Ongoing
Asset managers that hold large stakes in companies are exempt from some rules if they are classified as passive investors. The classification is made by the asset manager itself, in an annual letter certifying its own compliance.
“That's like being allowed to write whatever you want on your taxes and then audit yourself.”
BlackRock, federal regulators. Violates: Regulation that relies on the regulated firm's own report. Source: BlackRock: The Conspiracies You Don't Know, More Perfect Union
2024
2024
The three largest asset managers together hold about 16 percent of Amazon, compared with 9 percent held by its founder. According to Benjamin Braun, a 5 percent stake usually makes a fund the largest shareholder in a company, and the three firms together hold around 25 percent of many large companies. A 2017 study found asset managers almost always vote with company management.
BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street. Violates: None in law. Listed for who controls the votes.. Source: BlackRock: The Conspiracies You Don't Know, More Perfect Union
1945 to 2024
In 1945 households owned 94 percent of stocks. Households now own about 40 percent, and half of that is held by the top 10 percent. The top 1 percent own about 50 percent of corporate equity and mutual fund shares, the top 10 percent own 86 percent, and the bottom half of Americans own almost none. Pension and 401(k) holders sign their voting rights over to the fund manager, who signs them over to the asset manager.
The financial system as it stands. Violates: None in law. Listed for who the system works for.. Source: BlackRock: The Conspiracies You Don't Know, More Perfect Union
How BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street Vote Your 401(k) Shares | Spirit of '76