2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Wall Street & Banking
The 2011 GAO Audit of the Federal Reserve: $16.1 Trillion in Rollover Loans to Wall Street and Foreign Banks
Period covered: 2007 to 2015 · 10 sources
Summary
In 2010 Congress ordered the first outside audit of the emergency lending the Federal Reserve did during the 2008 crisis. The Government Accountability Office reported in July 2011 that the loans across the broad programs added up to $16.1 trillion, and the office explained in the same report that this number sums a loan every time it was rolled over, so an overnight loan renewed for a month counts thirty times; adjusted for how long the money was actually out, the figure was $1.14 trillion. The largest users were the biggest banks, and more than half the money in two programs went to the American arms of foreign banks. The public learned the borrowers' names only after a news agency won a Freedom of Information Act suit and a new law forced the release of 21,000 transactions. A second audit found that the chairman of the New York Fed sat on its board while he held and bought stock in Goldman Sachs as it became a bank the Fed regulates. The Fed says it lost nothing and earned about $20 billion on the programs.
The Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 ordered the Government Accountability Office to conduct "a one-time audit of all loans and other financial assistance" the Federal Reserve provided during the crisis. The office reported on July 21, 2011, in a report called Federal Reserve System: Opportunities Exist to Strengthen Policies and Processes for Managing Emergency Assistance. One number from it traveled widely. A table in the report totals the transactions across the broad-based emergency programs at $16,115 billion, about $16.1 trillion.
The report explains, in the same pages, what that number is and is not. It "aggregates total dollar transaction amounts by adding the total dollar amount of all loans but does not adjust these amounts to reflect differences across programs in the term over which loans were outstanding." Its own example: "an overnight PDCF loan of $10 billion that was renewed daily at the same level for 30 business days would result in an aggregate amount borrowed of $300 billion although the institution, in effect, borrowed only $10 billion over 30 days." When the office instead multiplied each loan by the days it was out and divided by the year, the total for the top twenty borrowers came to $1,139 billion, about $1.14 trillion. Both numbers are the government's own, and both belong next to each other. Senator Bernie Sanders, whose office posted the audit, described it to the public as "more than $16 trillion in total financial assistance." The report is where the figure comes from, and the report is also where the explanation of it is.
Who used it
The largest users were the largest firms. The report's table of aggregate borrowing, in billions, lists Citigroup at $2,513, Morgan Stanley at $2,041, Merrill Lynch at $1,949, Bank of America at $1,344, Barclays at $868, Bear Stearns at $853, and Goldman Sachs at $814. On the term-adjusted measure the order shifts, with Bank of America first at $67 billion, then Citigroup and the Royal Bank of Scotland at $58 billion each. A large share went abroad. The report found that "U.S. branches and agencies of foreign banks and U.S. subsidiaries of foreign institutions received over half of the total dollar amount of TAF and CPFF loans made," and that under one program "approximately 65 percent of the loans were made to U.S. branches, agencies, and subsidiaries of foreign institutions." A separate set of dollar swap lines with foreign central banks peaked, by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York's own account, at "more than $580 billion" in December 2008.
How the public found out
For two years the borrowers' names were secret. The news agency Bloomberg filed a Freedom of Information Act request, was refused, and sued. A federal judge in Manhattan ordered the data released in August 2009, the Second Circuit affirmed in March 2010, and on March 21, 2011 the Supreme Court denied the banks' petition to keep the records sealed. Separately, the Dodd-Frank Act required the Federal Reserve to publish the transactions itself. On December 1, 2010 it "posted detailed information on its public website about more than 21,000 individual credit and other transactions." In its release the Board said it "followed sound risk-management practices in administering all of these programs, incurred no credit losses on programs that have been wound down, and expects to incur no credit losses on the few remaining programs." Bloomberg, examining the released data, reported the Fed "had committed $7.77 trillion to rescuing the financial system," a figure its reporter described as "the absolute limit that the Federal Reserve committed," against "$1.2 trillion" that was "the actual number of loans that went out the door" on the single peak day of December 5, 2008.
The conflicts
A companion audit, published October 19, 2011, looked at who sat on the boards of the Federal Reserve banks while the lending was going on. It found "at least 18 former and current" directors "from 9 Reserve Banks who were affiliated with institutions that used at least one emergency program." It described one case in detail without naming the man: the chairman of the New York Fed's board, "former chairman and a current board member and shareholder of the Goldman Sachs Group," who under Fed rules became ineligible to keep his seat when Goldman "applied for and was approved by the Federal Reserve Board to become a bank holding company" in September 2008. The Fed granted a waiver to let him stay, but "was unaware that the then-FRBNY chairman had purchased additional shares in Goldman Sachs," and "the then-FRBNY chair resigned in May 2009." Sanders's office identified the chairman as Stephen Friedman. The first audit had separately found that on September 19, 2008, three days after the Federal Reserve authorized help for the insurer AIG, the New York Fed's president "granted, under authority delegated by the FRBNY Board of Directors, a waiver to a senior management official with financial interests in AIG and GE who was involved in decision making related to these two companies." Sanders's office identified that official as William Dudley, who later became the bank's president.
The Fed also hired the firms it was rescuing to run the programs. The report found "103 contracts worth $659.4 million," most of them "awarded noncompetitively," and it listed the vendors and their fees for one program: Wellington at $26.5 million, JPMorgan Chase at $16.2 million, BlackRock at $11.2 million, Goldman Sachs at $11.2 million, and PIMCO at $11.2 million.
What it cost, and what changed
The Federal Reserve's position is that the programs made money. It reported earning "$19.9 billion in revenue from the broad-based programs" and said it "did not incur losses on any of the programs that have closed." Congress narrowed the authority going forward. Section 1101 of the Dodd-Frank Act required that emergency lending be "for the purpose of providing liquidity to the financial system, and not to aid a failing financial company," and barred programs "structured to remove assets from the balance sheet of a single and specific company." In December 2015 the Federal Reserve adopted a rule to carry that out, defining a permitted program as one open to "at least five entities."
Primary Sources (10)
Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.
Documented Records (1)
Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.
Timeline Events (4)
Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.
More in Wall Street & Banking
View all stories in Wall Street & Banking → · Topic overview →
- 2013 to 2026Why European Central Banks Are Pulling Their Gold Reserves Out of the New York FedOn September 2, 2026 the Dutch central bank said it had moved about 86 tonnes of its gold out of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the Bank of Canada to London between March and August, in view of increasing geopolitical unrest, so that the gold could be sold quickly in a crisis. France's central bank had already sold the last 129 tonnes it kept in New York and bought replacement bars in Europe. Germany, which keeps 1,236 tonnes in New York, is being pressed by its own economists and politicians to bring it home. The New York vault held over 12,000 tonnes of other countries' gold in 1973 and 6,331 tonnes in 2024. The countries that kept their gold in Manhattan because they trusted the United States are, one by one, deciding they would rather have it somewhere else.Wall Street & Banking
- February 2025 to July 2026The 2025–2026 Emergency Tariffs: $160 Billion Collected Before the Supreme Court Struck Them DownIn 2025 the president imposed tariffs on nearly every country under a 1977 emergency law that does not mention tariffs. By October the average tariff rate on what Americans buy from abroad was 17.9 percent, the highest since 1934, and the Budget Lab at Yale put the cost at $1,800 a household. Customs duties paid at the border rose 153 percent to $195 billion in fiscal 2025. On February 20, 2026 the Supreme Court held 6 to 3 that the law gave the president no such power. About $160 billion had been collected by then. Four days later a 10 percent tariff on everyone went on under a different law; a trade court struck that one in May; when it expired in July it was replaced under a third law, at 10 to 12.5 percent, on 60 countries.Wall Street & Banking
- 1945 to 2024How BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street Vote Your 401(k) SharesBlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street hold a stake in nearly every listed company, paid for with pension and 401(k) money. The people whose money it is sign away their votes, the asset managers almost always vote with management, and the managers decide for themselves whether they count as passive investors.Wall Street & Banking
- 2020 to 2024Federal Reserve Bank Presidents Trading Millions in Stocks and Bonds During the 2020 BailoutsIn 2020 the Federal Reserve decided what the markets would do, and two of the twelve regional bank presidents who sat in on those decisions were trading in the markets. The president of the Dallas Fed traded stocks and options in positions worth millions. The president of the Boston Fed bought into mortgage funds in the months the Fed was buying mortgage bonds. Both announced their departures in September 2021. The Fed's inspector general found in January 2024 that neither had broken the rules in force, that the rules did not sufficiently support public confidence, and that both had created the appearance of a conflict of interest. In September 2024 he found the Atlanta Fed president had broken the trading rules and created the appearance of acting on confidential information. He stayed in office.Wall Street & Banking
- 2018 to 2026The 2023 Silicon Valley Bank Bailout and the $3 Trillion Unregulated Private Credit MarketIn March 2023 Silicon Valley Bank lost $40 billion of deposits in a day and expected $100 billion more the next morning. The government invoked an emergency exception to guarantee every deposit, including the $231 billion at two banks that the law did not insure, at a cost of $16.7 billion charged to 110 other banks. The Federal Reserve's own review found that the 2018 law rolling back the rules for banks of that size had reduced the standards, increased complexity, and promoted a less assertive supervisory approach. Since then the lending that used to be done by regulated banks has moved to private credit funds, now about $3 trillion, where two large borrowers collapsed in 2025 after hiding their debts and the funds began capping withdrawals.Wall Street & Banking