2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Police, Courts & Prisons

The Trial Penalty: How Threatening Longer Sentences Forces 98% of Federal Defendants to Plead Guilty

Period covered: 1963 to 2026 · 9 sources

Summary

The Constitution promises a trial by jury, and almost no one gets one. In 2025, 97.7 percent of people convicted in federal court pleaded guilty; in state courts the figure is about 94 percent. The Supreme Court has said plainly that plea bargaining "is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system; it is the criminal justice system." It works because the government can make the price of a trial ruinous: in the case that made this legal, a man was offered five years for a forged check worth $88.30 and, when he turned it down, was sentenced to life. Defense lawyers found that people who go to trial can receive sentences three to eight times longer than those who plead. Innocent people sign too. About one in seven people later proved innocent had pleaded guilty, and most defendants held in jail before trial cannot make bail, which is its own pressure to take the deal and go home.

In fiscal year 2025 the United States Sentencing Commission counted 66,662 people convicted in federal court. Of them, 65,099, or 97.7 percent, pleaded guilty. Only 1,563, or 2.3 percent, went to trial. In state courts the share is a little lower and just as settled. The Bureau of Justice Statistics found that of felony offenders sentenced in state courts in 2006, "most (94%) felony offenders sentenced in 2006 pleaded guilty."

The Supreme Court has described this in its own words. In Missouri v. Frye, decided in 2012, Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote that "ninety-seven percent of federal convictions and ninety-four percent of state convictions are the result of guilty pleas," and quoted a line the Court adopted as its own: plea bargaining "is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system; it is the criminal justice system." In a companion case decided the same day, Lafler v. Cooper, he wrote that "criminal justice today is for the most part a system of pleas, not a system of trials."

Mandatory Minimums and Sentencing Disparities

A plea is a choice, and the government sets the terms of the choice. The case that made those terms lawful was Bordenkircher v. Hayes, decided in 1978. Paul Lewis Hayes was indicted in Kentucky for writing a forged check worth $88.30, an offense that carried two to ten years. The prosecutor offered to recommend five years if Hayes pleaded guilty, and told him that if he did not, the prosecutor would reindict him under the state's habitual-offender law, which carried a mandatory life sentence because Hayes had two prior convictions. Hayes refused. The prosecutor got the new indictment, and Hayes was sentenced to life in prison. The Supreme Court held that this was permissible. It wrote that confronting a defendant with the risk of a much heavier sentence for going to trial is "an inevitable, and permissible, attribute of any legitimate system which tolerates and encourages the negotiation of pleas."

Defense lawyers put numbers on the size of that risk. The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, in a 2018 report called The Trial Penalty, examined the Sentencing Commission's own data and found that "in 2015, the average sentence for fraud was three times as high for defendants who went to trial versus those who pled guilty. And for burglary/breaking and entering and embezzlement it was nearly eight times as high." The report's conclusion was that "there is ample evidence that federal criminal defendants are being coerced to plead guilty because the penalty for exercising their constitutional rights is simply too high to risk." The trial itself, the report said, now happens in "less than 3% of state and federal criminal cases."

The jail before the trial

For many defendants the pressure begins before any offer, in a cell. The Bureau of Justice Statistics found that at the middle of 2023, "70% (467,600) of the jail population was unconvicted, either awaiting court action on a current charge or held in jail for other reasons." Most of them were there because they could not post bail. A person sitting in jail, who may lose a job or the custody of children while waiting months for trial, is offered a plea that lets them walk out the same day with time served. Taking it can be the rational choice whether or not the person is guilty.

The innocent who plead guilty

Because a plea is supposed to be an admission of guilt, it is treated as strong proof of guilt, which makes it very hard to undo. The National Registry of Exonerations found that "about 95% of felony convictions in the United States are obtained by guilty pleas," but "only 15% of known exonerees pled guilty." It also found that "an exoneree who falsely confessed is more than three times more likely to plead guilty to a crime she didn't commit than an exoneree who did not confess." The Innocence Project describes the mechanism directly: prosecutors "use the threat of the trial penalty, the difference in length and severity of sentence between that offered in a plea deal prior to a trial and that given if a person chooses to go to trial and is convicted after trial, to coerce people into accepting a plea despite their innocence." The result, it wrote, is that people "admit to a crime they did not commit and waive other fundamental rights that are critical to a fair criminal legal process."

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (9)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

1978
Supreme Court of the United States (U.S. Reports, via govinfo). Paul Hayes, offered five years for an $88.30 forged check, was reindicted under the habitual-offender law and sentenced to life after refusing; the Court held the threat a permissible attribute of a system that encourages pleas.
2009
Bureau of Justice Statistics. Most, 94 percent, of felony offenders sentenced in state courts in 2006 pleaded guilty; the figure the Supreme Court cites for state courts.
2012
Supreme Court of the United States (U.S. Reports, via govinfo). Criminal justice today is for the most part a system of pleas, not a system of trials.
2012
Supreme Court of the United States (U.S. Reports, via govinfo). Ninety-seven percent of federal convictions and ninety-four percent of state convictions are the result of guilty pleas; plea bargaining is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system, it is the criminal justice system.
2015
National Registry of Exonerations. About 95 percent of felony convictions are obtained by guilty pleas, but only 15 percent of known exonerees pled guilty; an exoneree who falsely confessed is more than three times more likely to plead guilty to a crime she did not commit.
2018
National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. Trial happens in less than 3 percent of criminal cases; in 2015 the average sentence for fraud was three times as high after trial as after a plea, and for burglary and embezzlement nearly eight times; defendants are being coerced to plead guilty.
2025
Bureau of Justice Statistics. At midyear 2023, 70 percent, or 467,600, of the jail population was unconvicted, awaiting court action or held for other reasons.
2026
United States Sentencing Commission. Fiscal year 2025: of 66,662 people convicted in federal court, 65,099, or 97.7 percent, pleaded guilty; 1,563, or 2.3 percent, went to trial.
2026
Innocence Project. Prosecutors use the threat of the trial penalty to coerce people into accepting a plea despite their innocence, encouraging them to admit to a crime they did not commit and waive other fundamental rights.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2012
1963 to 2026
The Constitution promises a trial by jury, and in 2025, 97.7 percent of people convicted in federal court and about 94 percent in state courts pleaded guilty instead. The Supreme Court has held that a prosecutor may threaten a much heavier sentence to make a defendant give up a trial: in the case that settled it, a man offered five years for an $88.30 forged check was sentenced to life after he refused. Defense lawyers found sentences after trial running three to eight times longer than after a plea. About one in seven people later proved innocent had pleaded guilty, and 70 percent of the jail population is held before trial, unable to make bail.
“It is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system; it is the criminal justice system.”
The prosecutors who set the charge and the offer; the system that made the trial too costly to use. Violates: The right to a trial by jury, promised in the body of the Constitution and again in the Sixth Amendment.. Source: Missouri v. Frye, 566 U.S. 134 (2012), Supreme Court of the United States (U.S. Reports, via govinfo)

Timeline Events (4)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

Fiscal year 2025
97.7 percent of people convicted in federal court in 2025 pleaded guilty
1,563 of 66,662 went to trial.
July 10, 2018
Defense bar: sentences after trial can run three to eight times longer than after a plea
Trial now happens in fewer than 3 percent of criminal cases.
March 21, 2012
Supreme Court: plea bargaining is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system, it is the criminal justice system
97 percent of federal convictions and 94 percent of state convictions are guilty pleas.
January 18, 1978
Supreme Court: a prosecutor may threaten a life sentence to make a defendant take a plea
Paul Hayes turned down five years for an $88.30 check and got life.
The Trial Penalty: How Threatening Longer Sentences Forces 98% of Federal Defendants to Plead Guilty | Spirit of '76