1975 to 2000: Investigations and deregulation · Police, Courts & Prisons

The 1989 Texas Execution of Carlos DeLuna After Police Ignored the Real Killer

Period covered: 1983 to 1989 · 10 sources

Summary

Carlos DeLuna was executed by Texas on December 7, 1989 for the stabbing of a gas station clerk, Wanda Lopez, in Corpus Christi. He said from the start that another man did it, a man named Carlos Hernandez, and prosecutors told the jury that Hernandez was a "phantom" who might not even exist. Hernandez was real, was known to the same police, had a record of knife attacks, and told people for years that he was the one who killed Wanda Lopez and that his namesake had taken the blame. A team at Columbia Law School spent years reconstructing the case and concluded DeLuna was innocent: the conviction rested on a single nighttime eyewitness who later said he was only partly sure, there was no physical evidence tying DeLuna to the bloody scene, and the crime scene was washed down within two hours. DeLuna was never exonerated. He had already been executed.

On the night of February 4, 1983, Wanda Lopez, a 24-year-old clerk, was stabbed to death during a robbery at a Sigmor gas station in Corpus Christi, Texas, while she was on the phone with a police dispatcher. Officers found Carlos DeLuna about half an hour later, hiding under a parked pickup truck nearby, and arrested him. He was tried in Nueces County in July 1983, convicted of capital murder, and sentenced to death. He was executed by lethal injection at the Huntsville Unit on December 7, 1989. His last statement, recorded by the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, was: "I want to say I hold no grudges. I hate no one. I love my family. Tell everyone on death row to keep the faith and don't give up."

The other Carlos

From the beginning DeLuna said the killer was another man, Carlos Hernandez. At trial the prosecution told the jury there was no such person, that Hernandez was a "phantom." He was not a phantom. Carlos Hernandez lived in the same part of Corpus Christi, resembled DeLuna closely enough that their own families are said to have mixed up their photographs, and had a long record of attacking people with knives. After DeLuna was executed, investigators found that Hernandez had "spent years bragging around Corpus Christi that he, not his tocayo Carlos DeLuna, committed the murder," using the Spanish word for a person who shares your name. Hernandez was known to the police and prosecutors at the time of the trial as a man with a history of crimes like the one DeLuna was tried for.

The Columbia investigation

Beginning in the 2000s, a Columbia Law School professor, James Liebman, and a team of his students spent years reconstructing the case, tracking down witnesses and records. Their study, "Los Tocayos Carlos: An Anatomy of a Wrongful Execution," ran to hundreds of pages in the Columbia Human Rights Law Review in 2012 and became a book, "The Wrong Carlos," in 2014. Its conclusion was that Texas had executed an innocent man. Liebman told an interviewer, "I'm convinced that no jury could possibly have convicted Carlos DeLuna beyond a reasonable doubt on the evidence here. That's absolutely clear." The Equal Justice Initiative summarized the study's finding this way: "everything that could go wrong in a death penalty case did go wrong for DeLuna. Sadly, DeLuna's story is not unique."

The evidence that was not there

The case that sent DeLuna to death was thin. The identification came from a single eyewitness, Kevan Baker, a car salesman who saw a man struggle with Lopez and was shown DeLuna as DeLuna sat in the back of a police car at the scene, a procedure that steers a witness toward the person the police have already caught. Years later Baker told the Columbia team he had been only "70 percent sure DeLuna was the killer," and that without the police having DeLuna in hand he "would have only been 50% sure." There was no physical evidence linking DeLuna to the crime. He had no blood on him, though the store was covered in it, and there was a bloody footprint the police never measured and fingerprints the police could not use. The scene itself did not survive: officers finished on site within about two hours and returned the store to its owner, who washed it down, and by the time the Columbia investigators went looking for the physical evidence, including the knife, it "was nowhere to be found."

What the courts saw

The appeals never reached the question of whether the right man had been convicted. On direct appeal, decided in 1986, the Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the conviction and death sentence on the grounds DeLuna raised, which did not include a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence or the Hernandez claim. On his final federal habeas petition, decided by the Fifth Circuit in 1989 days before the execution, DeLuna raised three legal claims about jury instructions and self-representation, and the court denied them, noting he "was seen and identified by witnesses before, during, and after the offense." Neither opinion took up the question of Carlos Hernandez. The court records, as later reviewers found, were about the trial's procedure, not about whether the person executed had killed Wanda Lopez.

← 1975 to 2000

Primary Sources (10)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

1986
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (Justia). The direct-appeal opinion affirming the conviction and death sentence; the grounds raised did not include the Carlos Hernandez claim or the sufficiency of the evidence.
1989
United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit (Justia). The final federal habeas ruling days before the execution; denied on jury-instruction and self-representation grounds; the court did not take up the Hernandez claim.
1989
Texas Department of Criminal Justice. The official record of the execution date and last statement: I want to say I hold no grudges. I hate no one. I love my family.
2012
Columbia Law School. Los Tocayos Carlos: Carlos Hernandez spent years bragging around Corpus Christi that he, not his tocayo Carlos DeLuna, committed the murder, and was known to police and prosecutors at the time of trial.
2012
The Texas Tribune. Liebman: I'm convinced that no jury could possibly have convicted Carlos DeLuna beyond a reasonable doubt on the evidence here.
2012
Equal Justice Initiative. Everything that could go wrong in a death penalty case did go wrong for DeLuna; a single cross-ethnic eyewitness identification at night, no corroborating forensics, a sloppy crime scene investigation, grossly inadequate representation.
2012
Boston Review. Prosecutors dismissed Hernandez as a phantom; DeLuna had no blood on him despite the bloody store, and the police concluded their on-site investigation within two hours and turned the store over to its owner, who washed it down.
2021
Innocence Project. The murder of Wanda Lopez on February 4, 1983 at a Sigmor gas station; DeLuna found hiding under a truck; tried July 1983.
2021
Texas Monthly. The single eyewitness Kevan Baker later said he was 70 percent sure and identified DeLuna in the back of a squad car; the crime scene was washed down and the physical evidence, including the knife, was nowhere to be found.
2026
Death Penalty Information Center. Lists cases with strong evidence of innocence among the executed, including Carlos DeLuna (Texas, convicted 1983, executed 1989) and Cameron Todd Willingham (Texas, convicted 1992, executed 2004).

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

1989
1983 to 1989
Texas executed Carlos DeLuna on December 7, 1989 for the stabbing of a gas station clerk, after telling the jury that the other man DeLuna named, Carlos Hernandez, was a phantom who might not exist. Hernandez was real, was known to the same police, had a record of knife attacks, and told people for years that he was the killer and his namesake took the blame. A Columbia Law School study concluded DeLuna was innocent: the conviction rested on one uncertain nighttime eyewitness, there was no physical evidence, and the crime scene was washed down within two hours. He was never exonerated, because he was already dead.
“Spent years bragging around Corpus Christi that he, not his tocayo Carlos DeLuna, committed the murder.”
The State of Texas; the prosecutors who called a real man a phantom. Violates: A life taken on a single uncertain identification, with the real suspect known to the police.. Source: Columbia Law School Investigation Uncovers New Evidence Suggesting Texas Executed Innocent Man, Columbia Law School

Timeline Events (2)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

May 15, 2012
Columbia Law School reconstructs the DeLuna case and concludes Texas executed an innocent man
One uncertain eyewitness, no physical evidence, the scene washed away.
December 7, 1989
Texas executes Carlos DeLuna for a murder another man kept confessing to
Prosecutors had called that man a phantom; the police knew he was real.
The 1989 Texas Execution of Carlos DeLuna After Police Ignored the Real Killer | Spirit of '76