2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Police, Courts & Prisons

Mass Exonerations After Police Framing Scandals in Chicago, Los Angeles, Baltimore, and Tulia, Texas

Period covered: 1972 to 2022 · 11 sources

Summary

Official misconduct is the second most common thread in wrongful convictions, present in about 61 percent of them and higher in murder cases. Sometimes it is one officer or one unit, and when the pattern is finally exposed the convictions fall in bunches. In Chicago, a police commander named Jon Burge oversaw the torture of more than 100 Black men to get confessions; he was fired, later convicted in federal court of lying about it, and the city paid reparations. A Chicago sergeant, Ronald Watts, ran an extortion ring and planted drugs on people who would not pay, and 188 of them have had their convictions thrown out. The Los Angeles Police Department's Rampart scandal produced about 170 exonerations. A Baltimore police unit was convicted of robbing residents and planting evidence, and nearly 800 cases were dropped. In Tulia, Texas, one undercover officer's word put dozens of people in prison until the governor pardoned them.

From the early 1970s into the early 1990s, a Chicago police commander named Jon Burge oversaw the torture of criminal suspects, most of them Black men, on the city's South Side. The methods, established in later court proceedings, included electric shock, suffocation with plastic bags, mock executions, and beatings, used to force confessions. The City of Chicago's own resolution states that "more than 100 African-Americans who were detained by the Chicago Police Department between 1972 and 1991 have accused Burge or police officers working under his command of engaging in acts of torture and physical abuse." Burge was fired by the Chicago Police Board in 1993. A special prosecutor's report in 2006 concluded there was evidence that would prove some of the torture beyond a reasonable doubt, but that the statute of limitations barred any prosecution for it.

Burge was eventually convicted for lying about it. In 2010 a federal jury found him guilty of perjury and obstruction of justice for denying under oath, in a civil case, that he and officers under him had abused suspects. The Justice Department said he "abused his power and betrayed the public trust by abusing suspects in his custody, and then by lying under oath to cover up what he and other officers had done." He was sentenced on January 21, 2011 to four and a half years in prison. In 2015 the Chicago City Council voted to create a $5.5 million reparations fund for his victims, along with a formal apology "for these horrific and inexcusable acts," counseling services, a memorial, and a requirement that the city's public schools teach the history of the case to eighth and tenth graders.

Ronald Watts, Chicago

Between 2002 and 2009, a Chicago police sergeant named Ronald Watts and officers under him ran an extortion ring around the Ida B. Wells public housing project. People who paid were left alone; people who refused were arrested with drugs the officers planted on them. The National Registry of Exonerations describes it plainly: "dozens of people were falsely arrested and then wrongfully convicted, mostly for drug crimes," and "to date, 188 of these defendants have had their convictions vacated and charges dismissed." An FBI report quoted by the Registry states that "Watts receives weekly payments from drug dealers. These payments are typically in the amount of $5,000." Watts was arrested in 2012, pleaded guilty in 2013 to a federal charge, and was sentenced to 22 months. The convictions he and his squad produced have been falling ever since.

Rampart, Los Angeles

In the late 1990s an anti-gang unit in the Los Angeles Police Department's Rampart division, known as CRASH, was found to have planted evidence and given false testimony. The National Registry of Exonerations records that "wide-ranging misconduct by officers in Los Angeles Police Department's Rampart division led to approximately 170 exonerations," that "five officers were convicted in state and federal courts for their misconduct," and that "the city of Los Angeles has paid approximately $125 million to settle claims." The scandal broke open after one officer, caught stealing cocaine from an evidence room, gave thousands of pages of testimony about what the unit had done. It ended with the department placed under a federal consent decree in 2001.

The Gun Trace Task Force, Baltimore

On March 1, 2017 the Justice Department charged seven Baltimore officers on a plainclothes gun unit with federal racketeering. The unit had robbed residents of amounts from $200 to $200,000, written false search-warrant affidavits and police reports, and claimed fraudulent overtime. The United States Attorney, Rod Rosenstein, said, "this is not about aggressive policing, it is about a criminal conspiracy." The unit's sergeant was later sentenced to 25 years in federal prison. Because the officers' word could no longer be trusted in any case they had touched, the National Registry of Exonerations reports that "nearly 800 defendants in Baltimore, Maryland, had their convictions vacated and charges dismissed after eight police officers on a weapons task force were arrested in 2017."

Tulia, Texas

On July 23, 1999, a regional drug task force raided homes across the small town of Tulia, Texas, on the word of a single undercover officer, Tom Coleman. The National Registry of Exonerations records that the officers "arrested 47 people, charging most with delivery of cocaine," that "the officers arrived with arrest warrants, but seized no cocaine, weapons or cash during any of the arrests," and that "forty-one of the defendants were black, and they comprised approximately 10 percent of Tulia's black population." A judge who reviewed the cases called Coleman "the most devious non-responsive law enforcement officer this court has seen." On August 22, 2003, Governor Rick Perry pardoned 35 of the Tulia defendants. Coleman was later convicted of perjury.

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (11)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2003
CNN. Governor Rick Perry pardoned 35 Tulia defendants; a retired judge had called Coleman the most devious non-responsive law enforcement officer this court has seen; Coleman was later convicted of perjury.
2010
Federal Bureau of Investigation, Chicago. The June 28, 2010 jury conviction; trial evidence of suffocation with bags, electric shocks, threats with firearms, and burning suspects on radiators.
2011
U.S. Department of Justice. Burge sentenced to 4.5 years for perjury and obstruction for denying under oath that he and officers under him abused suspects; he abused his power and betrayed the public trust.
2015
NPR. The City Council's unanimous May 6, 2015 vote on the $5.5 million reparations package.
2015
City of Chicago. More than 100 African-Americans detained between 1972 and 1991 accused Burge or officers under his command of torture and abuse; a $5.5 million fund, an apology, counseling, a memorial, and a lesson taught in the public schools.
2017
U.S. Department of Justice, District of Maryland. Federal racketeering charges for robbery, fabricated warrants, false reports, and overtime fraud; U.S. Attorney Rod Rosenstein: this is not about aggressive policing, it is about a criminal conspiracy.
2020
National Registry of Exonerations. Official misconduct contributed to the false convictions of 54 percent of defendants who were later exonerated; the rate runs from 72 percent in murder cases to 32 percent for most non-violent crimes.
2026
National Registry of Exonerations. Nearly 800 defendants in Baltimore had their convictions vacated and charges dismissed after eight officers on a weapons task force were arrested in 2017.
2026
National Registry of Exonerations. Misconduct by officers in the LAPD Rampart division led to approximately 170 exonerations; five officers were convicted; the city paid approximately $125 million to settle claims.
2026
National Registry of Exonerations. Between 2002 and 2009 dozens were falsely arrested and wrongfully convicted, mostly for drug crimes near the Ida B. Wells project; 188 have had convictions vacated; an FBI report: Watts receives weekly payments from drug dealers, typically $5,000.
2026
National Registry of Exonerations. On July 23, 1999 officers arrested 47 people on undercover officer Tom Coleman's word, seizing no cocaine, weapons, or cash; 41 of the defendants were black, about 10 percent of Tulia's black population.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2011
1972 to 2022
When a police officer lies, plants evidence, or beats out a confession, the officer can convict many people, and official misconduct is present in about 61 percent of all exonerations and 72 percent of murder cases. Chicago commander Jon Burge oversaw the torture of more than 100 Black men and was later convicted of lying about it; the city paid reparations. Sergeant Ronald Watts ran an extortion ring, and 188 of his drug convictions were thrown out. The Los Angeles Rampart scandal produced about 170 exonerations, and a Baltimore police unit's racketeering led to nearly 800 dropped cases. In Tulia, Texas, one officer's word imprisoned dozens until the governor pardoned them.
“Official misconduct contributed to the false convictions of 54% of defendants who were later exonerated.”
The officers named on this page and the departments that kept them. Violates: The trust the courts extend to a badge, used to convict the innocent by the dozen.. Source: Government Misconduct and Convicting the Innocent: The Role of Prosecutors, Police and Other Law Enforcement, National Registry of Exonerations

Timeline Events (5)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

March 1, 2017
Seven Baltimore officers charged with racketeering; nearly 800 cases later dropped
The prosecutor called it a criminal conspiracy, not aggressive policing.
May 6, 2015
Chicago creates a $5.5 million reparations fund for Burge's torture victims
With an apology and a lesson taught in the public schools.
2013
188 Chicago drug convictions thrown out after a sergeant's extortion ring is exposed
Ronald Watts planted drugs on people who would not pay.
January 21, 2011
Chicago police commander Jon Burge sentenced for lying about torturing suspects
More than 100 Black men said he or his officers tortured them.
August 22, 2003
Texas pardons 35 people convicted in Tulia on one undercover officer's word
No drugs, weapons, or cash were seized in any of the arrests.
Mass Exonerations After Police Framing Scandals in Chicago, Los Angeles, Baltimore, and Tulia, Texas | Spirit of '76