2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Police, Courts & Prisons

The 2004 Execution of Cameron Todd Willingham in Texas on Junk Arson Science

Period covered: 1991 to 2014 · 10 sources

Summary

Cameron Todd Willingham was executed by Texas on February 17, 2004 for setting the 1991 fire that killed his three young daughters. The case for arson was a list of "indicators" that two fire investigators read off the burned house, and a jailhouse informant who said Willingham confessed. Before the execution, a fire scientist told the state the arson findings had no scientific basis, and the state executed him anyway. A later report commissioned by the Texas Forensic Science Commission found the original investigation was "hardly consistent with a scientific mind-set and is more characteristic of mystics or psychics." Two days before the commission was to hear that report in 2009, the governor replaced three of its members and the hearing was canceled. The informant later recanted. The same year Willingham was executed, another Texas man was freed from death row after the same kind of fire science was discredited. No court or governor has ever cleared Willingham.

On December 23, 1991 a fire broke out at the house at 1213 West Eleventh Avenue in Corsicana, Texas, where Cameron Todd Willingham lived with his three daughters, two-year-old Amber and one-year-old twins Karmon and Kameron. All three girls died. Willingham got out. He was arrested on January 8, 1992, tried in Navarro County, and convicted of capital murder; the Court of Criminal Appeals record gives the date of his conviction and sentence as August 21, 1992. He was executed by lethal injection at the Huntsville Unit on February 17, 2004. His last statement began, "the only statement I want to make is that I am an innocent man, convicted of a crime I did not commit. I have been persecuted for 12 years for something I did not do."

The arson case

The state's case that the fire was set rested on the testimony of two men, the Corsicana assistant fire chief Douglas Fogg and the deputy state fire marshal Manuel Vasquez. Vasquez told the jury he had found "more than twenty indicators" of arson, and described his method in words that were quoted for years afterward: "the fire does not lie. It tells me the truth." The indicators were features of the burned house that the investigators read as proof of an accelerant: three separate points of origin, "puddle configurations" and "pour patterns" on the floor, deep charring, burning under an aluminum door threshold, and "crazed glass," a spiderweb pattern of cracks they said meant the fire had burned unusually hot and fast. The appeals court that affirmed the conviction recorded the theory in its opinion: the floors, threshold, and porch were burned in a way "which only occurs when an accelerant has been used."

The science that undid it

None of it held up. In 2004, before the execution, the fire scientist Gerald Hurst reviewed the case for Willingham's clemency petition and reported that there was no scientific basis for calling the fire arson, that the burn patterns were consistent with an ordinary accidental fire that reached the stage called flashover, and that the "crazed glass" theory was an old belief with no support. The report reached the governor's office and the Board of Pardons and Paroles; the board denied clemency and Governor Rick Perry denied a stay.

After the execution the findings were confirmed at length. In 2006 a committee of fire experts assembled by the Innocence Project, chaired by John Lentini, examined the evidence and concluded that "neither the fire that killed the three Willingham children nor the fire that killed Elizabeth Grace Belue and Gail Joe Allison," the deaths in a separate Texas case built on the same methods, "were incendiary fires." The committee explained that pour patterns and puddle shapes "are the kind of artifacts routinely created by accidental fires that progress beyond flashover," that "V" patterns show only that something burned, and that crazed glass forms when hot glass is cooled quickly, as by a firefighter's hose, not as proof of an accelerant. In 2009 a report commissioned by the Texas Forensic Science Commission from the fire expert Craig Beyler found the original investigation's methodology was "hardly consistent with a scientific mind-set and is more characteristic of mystics or psychics."

The informant

The other pillar of the case was Johnny Webb, a jailhouse informant who testified that Willingham had confessed the arson to him. Webb later recanted. He told an interviewer, "it's very possible I misunderstood what he said," and asked, "the statute of limitations has run out on perjury, hasn't it?" The Marshall Project, reviewing documents from the case, reported that the prosecutor, John Jackson, had a judgment against Webb reduced from aggravated robbery to robbery, sought early parole for him, and moved him to a county jail, and that Webb received money from a local rancher he said "was promised to him as part of his agreement with Jackson." Webb told the Marshall Project that Jackson had "coerced him to lie."

The panel and the politics

The Forensic Science Commission was set to take up the Beyler report at a hearing on October 2, 2009. Two days before, on September 30, Governor Perry replaced three members of the Commission, including its chairman, Sam Bassett, and named a new chairman, the district attorney John Bradley. Barry Scheck of the Innocence Project called it "like the Saturday night massacre," comparing it to President Nixon's firing of the Watergate prosecutor. Bradley canceled the hearing on taking office, saying, "there wasn't going to be enough time for me to learn about the case before the hearing." When the Commission finally issued its report in 2011, it declined to reach the question of fault, writing that it "declines to issue any finding regarding negligence or professional misconduct pending the issuance of an Attorney General opinion," and that opinion, issued later in 2011, held the Commission could not consider evidence tested before September 2005, which closed the inquiry into the original fire evidence.

The man they did free

The same year Texas executed Willingham, it released another man convicted of arson murder on the same kind of evidence. Ernest Ray Willis had spent seventeen years on death row for a 1986 fire that killed two women. After Gerald Hurst reviewed the physical evidence and found no basis for arson, the Pecos County district attorney, Ori White, dropped the charges, and Willis was freed on October 6, 2004. White said of Willis, "he simply did not do the crime. I'm sorry this man was on death row for so long and that there were so many lost years." The fire science that freed Willis was the fire science that had convicted Willingham.

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (10)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

1995
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (Justia). The direct-appeal opinion; date of conviction and sentence August 21, 1992; records the arson theory that the floors, threshold, and porch were burned in a way which only occurs when an accelerant has been used.
2004
Death Penalty Information Center. Ernest Ray Willis freed October 6, 2004 after 17 years on death row, on the same kind of fire science; prosecutor Ori White: he simply did not do the crime, I'm sorry this man was on death row for so long.
2006
Innocence Project (John Lentini and others). Neither the fire that killed the three Willingham children nor the fire in the Willis case were incendiary fires; pour patterns, V patterns, and crazed glass do not prove an accelerant; quotes Vasquez that the fire does not lie.
2009
Houston Chronicle. Craig Beyler's report for the Forensic Science Commission: the original investigation was hardly consistent with a scientific mind-set and is more characteristic of mystics or psychics.
2009
The New Yorker (David Grann). The definitive account of the Willingham case: the fire, the arson indicators, Gerald Hurst's pre-execution report, Johnny Webb, and that Hurst's report reached the governor's office and the parole board before the execution.
2009
The Texas Tribune. The new chairman John Bradley canceled the October 2 hearing: there wasn't going to be enough time for me to learn about the case before the hearing.
2009
Innocence Project. On September 30, 2009 Governor Perry replaced three commissioners including chairman Sam Bassett and named John Bradley chair, two days before the panel was to hear the Beyler report; Barry Scheck called it like the Saturday night massacre.
2011
Texas Forensic Science Commission. The commission declines to issue any finding regarding negligence or professional misconduct pending the issuance of an Attorney General opinion; reproduces the trial testimony about burn-pattern indicators.
2014
CBS News Texas. On April 7, 2014 the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles rejected the petition for a posthumous pardon; no court or governor has cleared Willingham.
2015
The Marshall Project. Johnny Webb said the prosecutor coerced him to lie; documents show his robbery judgment reduced, an attempt at early parole, a transfer to county jail, and money from a local rancher.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2004
1991 to 2014
Texas executed Cameron Todd Willingham on February 17, 2004 for setting the fire that killed his three daughters, on a list of arson indicators that fire scientists have since said prove nothing and a jailhouse informant who later recanted. A fire scientist warned the state before the execution that the findings had no scientific basis, and the state proceeded. A report for the Texas Forensic Science Commission called the original investigation more characteristic of mystics or psychics; two days before the commission could hear it, the governor replaced three of its members. The same year, Texas freed another man from death row on the same discredited science. No court or governor has cleared Willingham.
“Hardly consistent with a scientific mind-set and is more characteristic of mystics or psychics.”
The State of Texas; the fire investigators; the governor and the officials who set the report aside. Violates: The life the state took on evidence its own commission later found had no basis in science.. Source: Expert blasts fire investigation that led to Texas execution, Houston Chronicle

Timeline Events (4)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

April 7, 2014
Texas parole board denies a posthumous pardon for Willingham
No court or governor has ever cleared him.
September 30, 2009
Two days before it can hear the report, Texas replaces three members of the forensic panel
The Innocence Project called it the Saturday night massacre.
October 6, 2004
Texas frees Ernest Willis from death row the same year it executes Willingham
The same fire science; the prosecutor said he simply did not do the crime.
February 17, 2004
Texas executes Cameron Todd Willingham for an arson later shown to be no arson
He said he was an innocent man, convicted of a crime he did not commit.
The 2004 Execution of Cameron Todd Willingham in Texas on Junk Arson Science | Spirit of '76