2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Surveillance & Privacy

Stellar Wind: How the White House Ordered Warrantless NSA Wiretapping in October 2001

Period covered: 2001 to 2013 · 4 sources

Summary

On October 4, 2001 the president authorized the NSA to collect Americans' phone and internet records without a warrant. The order was drafted by the vice president's lawyer and kept in his safe. NSA employees who objected were told to stop asking questions, the Justice Department nearly resigned over it in 2004, the New York Times held the story for a year, and the people who talked were raided and one was charged under the Espionage Act. Congress made most of it legal in 2008.

FRONTLINE's United States of Secrets, broadcast in 2014, is the account of the NSA's domestic surveillance program told by the people who built it, the people who objected to it, and the reporters who exposed it. The NSA's own inspector general wrote a history of the program in 2009, marked top secret, which Edward Snowden disclosed in 2013. The two accounts agree on the facts that matter.

The Executive Order

The NSA was created after Pearl Harbor to prevent a surprise attack, and on September 11, 2001 it learned of one from the television in the director's office. In the days after, the vice president asked the CIA director what could be done that was not being done, and the CIA director called General Michael Hayden, the head of the NSA. Hayden's first answer was that there was nothing more within his authority. The question, he was told, was what he could do. He proposed collecting the phone and internet data of Americans and searching it for connections, and he took it to the Oval Office, where the president told him to go ahead.

The inspector general's report records what happened next. The vice president's counsel, David Addington, drafted the first authorization. Hayden told the inspector general that no other NSA employee took part in the drafting, including the agency's general counsel, and that the Justice Department was not involved in any of the discussions he attended. The president signed it on October 4, 2001. Addington carried a copy to Fort Meade himself. The order was kept in his safe, and for four years many of the people responsible for national security inside the government did not know it existed. Three NSA lawyers signed off on it as a use of the president's authority as commander in chief. The program was given the cover name STELLARWIND on October 31, 2001. It collected the content of communications with one end in the United States and bulk telephone and internet metadata, who called whom, who emailed whom, for hundreds of millions of people, from three telecommunications companies that the report identifies only as Company A, B, and C. It ran on the president's signature, renewed about every 45 days, until it was moved under court orders between 2004 and January 2007.

The people who objected

Before September 11 a team at the NSA led by the mathematician Bill Binney had built a system called ThinThread that could sort massive amounts of phone and email data. It encrypted anything belonging to an American unless a court unlocked it. Thomas Drake, a senior NSA manager whose first day was September 11, found it in the agency's labs and proposed it. His superior, the agency's third ranking official, wrote back in felt pen that they had gone with a different program and would not say what it was. Servers began piling up in the halls. Employees came to Drake saying they were being ordered to put foreign facing collection equipment on domestic networks. Binney's team learned that ThinThread was being used with the privacy protections stripped out. Binney, Kirk Wiebe, and Ed Loomis retired at the end of October 2001. Drake stayed and went to the general counsel's office, where a lawyer told him all the lawyers had approved it, that they were under emergency conditions, and not to ask any more questions.

Binney took it to Diane Roark, the House Intelligence Committee staffer responsible for the NSA. She wrote memos to the committee's leaders asking for the protections to be restored or the system stopped. The chairman told her she was not cleared for it and sent her to Hayden. Roark's account is that she asked him five times why the protections had been removed and that he finally said they had the power and did not need them. Hayden's account is that he told her he disagreed and thought the program was lawful and effective.

At the Justice Department, a lawyer named Thomas Tamm who prepared warrants for the foreign intelligence court found evidence of surveillance that had not come through the court and a supervisor who assumed the program was illegal and did not want to ask. In late 2003 Jack Goldsmith took over the Office of Legal Counsel and was shown the order in Addington's office. He concluded the bulk internet collection could not be justified. Addington's answer, in Goldsmith's account, was that the blood of a hundred thousand people killed in the next attack would be on his head. In March 2004 the attorney general refused to certify the program, then collapsed with pancreatitis. The White House counsel and the chief of staff went to his hospital bed with the order, and the acting attorney general, James Comey, got there first. Ashcroft refused them from the bed. The president reauthorized the program on March 11, 2004 with the White House counsel's signature where the attorney general's had been, and the inspector general's report confirms it in its own words: "the White House Counsel rather than the Attorney General signed the 11 March 2004 Authorization." Comey, the FBI director, and about two dozen Justice Department officials prepared to resign. The president backed down, stopped the bulk internet collection on March 19, and the NSA cut off access to it on March 26. Hayden then met twice on Saturdays with the chief judge of the foreign intelligence court, who signed an order on July 14, 2004 allowing the same collection under the statute written for tracing a single telephone. The telephone records followed on May 24, 2006 under the business records provision of the Patriot Act, the order that was renewed every 90 days until the Guardian published one in June 2013.

The exposure

Tamm called the New York Times from a pay phone in a subway station in 2004. The Times had the story that fall. The president, on the campaign trail, was saying that any wiretap required a court order. The White House met the paper's editors, told them the program was legal and that publishing would endanger the country, and the editor killed the story. It ran on December 16, 2005, after the reporter James Risen put it in a book. The president confirmed the program the next day and described only the smallest part of it, the international calls of people linked to al-Qaeda. Hayden told the press that no NSA employee had raised a concern about it.

The administration's response was a leak investigation. Goldsmith, by then at Harvard, was handed a grand jury subpoena. On July 26, 2007 the FBI raided the homes of Binney, Wiebe, Loomis, and Roark with guns drawn; Binney was coming out of the shower. On November 28, 2007 they raided Drake. A prosecutor told him he was screwed and talked about 35 years. On April 14, 2010, under the next administration, Drake was indicted under the Espionage Act for documents found in his home, which his defense showed had been unclassified until after they were seized. The case collapsed days before trial in 2011 and he pleaded to a misdemeanor, unauthorized use of a government computer, with no prison time. He was working at an Apple store. None of the others were charged. Tamm was never indicted.

What Congress did

In 2008 the president asked Congress to put the program into law. The FISA Amendments Act passed in July 2008 with Senator Obama's vote, after he had campaigned on ending illegal wiretapping of Americans. Roark's reading of the act is that it made legal the things the attorney general and the FBI director had objected to. Hayden's is that it went further, allowing what had been done against al-Qaeda for any foreign intelligence purpose. When Obama took office he was briefed on the full program and kept it. Snowden, working as a contractor, read the inspector general's history of it and concluded that people had done things that were wrong and had not been held accountable. He also read what had happened to Drake and Binney, and decided that this time it would have to be documents.

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (4)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2001
Congress.gov. Signed six weeks after the September 11 attacks.
2009
Published by The Guardian. The agency's own history: the October 4, 2001 authorization drafted by David Addington, the March 11, 2004 authorization signed by the White House counsel, the July 14, 2004 and May 24, 2006 court orders.
2013
Published by The Guardian. Orders daily production to the NSA of all call records, including calls wholly within the United States. On this site.
2014
FRONTLINE, PBS. The NSA's warrantless program from the October 2001 order through the Snowden leak, told by Hayden, Drake, Binney, Roark, Goldsmith, Tamm, and the reporters.

Documented Records (6)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2001
October 4, 2001
The president signed the authorization for the NSA to collect the content of communications with one end in the United States and the bulk telephone and internet metadata of Americans without a warrant. According to the NSA inspector general's history, the vice president's counsel, David Addington, drafted it, no NSA lawyer took part, and the Justice Department was not involved in the discussions. It was renewed about every 45 days and given the cover name STELLARWIND on October 31, 2001.
“According to General Hayden, the Vice President's Counsel, David Addington, drafted the first Authorization.”
President George W. Bush; Vice President Cheney; David Addington; General Michael Hayden. Violates: Fourth Amendment; the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which made surveillance inside the country without a court order a felony.. Source: NSA Office of the Inspector General, working draft report on the President's Surveillance Program (STELLARWIND), Published by The Guardian
October 26, 2001
The Patriot Act was signed six weeks after the attacks. It expanded the government's ability to collect information on Americans, and most of those powers remain in place.
Congress, President Bush. Violates: Fourth Amendment. Source: USA PATRIOT Act, H.R.3162, 107th Congress (2001), Congress.gov
2004
March 11, 2004
After the Justice Department found the bulk internet collection could not be justified and the attorney general refused to certify the program from his hospital bed, the president reauthorized it with the White House counsel's signature in place of the attorney general's. The deputy attorney general, the FBI director, and about two dozen Justice Department officials prepared to resign. The president withdrew the internet collection on March 19, and the NSA stopped it on March 26. The same collection resumed under a foreign intelligence court order on July 14, 2004.
“Consequently, the White House Counsel rather than the Attorney General signed the 11 March 2004 Authorization.”
President Bush; Alberto Gonzales; David Addington. Violates: The program's own requirement that the attorney general certify its lawfulness.. Source: NSA Office of the Inspector General, working draft report on the President's Surveillance Program (STELLARWIND), Published by The Guardian
2005
December 16 and 17, 2005
The New York Times published the existence of the program after holding the story for more than a year at the White House's request, during which the president said publicly that any wiretap required a court order. The next day the president confirmed the program and described only the interception of international calls of people linked to al-Qaeda; the bulk collection of domestic records was not mentioned. General Hayden told the press that no NSA employee had raised a concern about it.
“Not a single employee of the National Security Agency has addressed a concern about this program to the NSA IG.”
President Bush; General Michael Hayden. Violates: None in law. Listed for the account given to the public against the record.. Source: United States of Secrets, Part One: The Program, FRONTLINE, PBS
2007
2001 to 2011
NSA employees who objected to the program were told by the general counsel's office not to ask questions. After the New York Times exposed it in December 2005, the FBI raided the homes of Bill Binney, Kirk Wiebe, Ed Loomis, and Diane Roark in July 2007 and Thomas Drake's in November 2007, and Drake was indicted under the Espionage Act on April 14, 2010 for documents that had been unclassified until after they were seized. The case collapsed before trial and he pleaded to a misdemeanor. None of the officials who ordered the program were investigated.
“Don't ask any more questions, Mr. Drake.”
Department of Justice; Federal Bureau of Investigation. Violates: None found in law against the people raided. Listed for what happened to the people who objected.. Source: United States of Secrets, Part One: The Program, FRONTLINE, PBS
2013
April 25, 2013
The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court ordered Verizon Business Network Services to give the NSA, every day, the records of every call on its network, including calls wholly within the United States and local calls: the numbers on both ends, the time, the length, and the phone identifiers. The order barred Verizon from disclosing it. It was signed by Judge Roger Vinson and ran until July 19, 2013.
“all call detail records or "telephony metadata" created by Verizon for communications (i) between the United States and abroad; or (ii) wholly within the United States, including local telephone calls.”
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, FBI, NSA. Violates: Fourth Amendment requirement that a warrant describe the particular place to be searched and the things to be seized. Source: Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court secondary order to Verizon Business Network Services (April 25, 2013), Published by The Guardian

Timeline Events (4)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

April 14, 2010
Thomas Drake indicted under the Espionage Act
For documents that were unclassified until after they were seized. The case collapsed before trial in 2011.
December 16, 2005
New York Times reveals the NSA program after holding the story a year
The president confirmed a part of it the next day. The leak investigation that followed raided the homes of the people who had objected inside the agency.
March 11, 2004
Program reauthorized over the Justice Department's objection
Signed by the White House counsel after the attorney general refused from his hospital bed. The internet collection was stopped eight days later and resumed under a court order in July.
October 4, 2001
President authorizes warrantless collection on Americans
Drafted by the vice president's lawyer, kept in his safe, renewed every 45 days.
Stellar Wind: How the White House Ordered Warrantless NSA Wiretapping in October 2001 | Spirit of '76