2020 to today · Surveillance & Privacy
Mandatory Government ID and Age Verification Laws for Websites and App Stores
Period covered: 2023 to 2026 · 4 sources
Summary
On June 27, 2025 the Supreme Court upheld a Texas law that requires adults to prove their age with a government ID or other records before viewing websites the state classifies as harmful to minors, and noted that at least 21 other states had passed the same requirement. Texas then required every app store to verify the age of every user and get a parent's permission for every download by a minor. A district judge blocked that law as a rule that would require every bookstore to verify the age of every customer at the door; an appeals court let it take effect in June 2026. The identity check is becoming the price of reading.
For thirty years the rule for the internet in the United States was the rule for a library or a newsstand: an adult did not have to prove anything to read. In 1997 the Supreme Court struck down a federal law, and in 2004 it blocked another, that would have required age verification for material the government considered harmful to minors, on the ground that a law forcing adults to identify themselves to read lawful material burdened their speech and that filters in the home did the job without it. In 2025 the court changed the rule.
Texas
Texas House Bill 1181, passed in 2023, requires any commercial website where more than a third of the material is sexual material harmful to minors to verify that every visitor is at least 18, by government issued identification or transactional data, on penalty of injunctions and civil fines of up to $10,000 a day, and up to $250,000 more if a minor gets through. On June 27, 2025, in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, the court upheld the law by 6 to 3. Justice Thomas wrote that age verification is common when a law draws lines based on age and is an ordinary and appropriate means of enforcing an age restriction, and that the burden on adults was incidental, so the law needed to survive only intermediate scrutiny, which it did. The opinion noted that at least 21 other states had imposed materially similar age verification requirements, and that in 2024, 95 percent of American teens had access to a smartphone. Justice Kagan, dissenting for three, wrote that the law defines speech by content and tells people entitled to view that speech that they must incur a cost to do so, which had always required the strictest review.
The cost is the identity. To view the material a person must send a government ID, or a credit record, or a face scan, to the website or to a verification company working for it. The Texas law says the website and the verifier may not keep the identifying information. It does not say how anyone would know if they did, and the person who sent the ID has no way to check. Every such site, and every such verifier, is a place where a named person's reading can be recorded, and the only guarantee that it is not is the word of the company.
Every app, every user
Texas went further the same year. Senate Bill 2420, the App Store Accountability Act, requires every app store to verify the age of every person who opens an account, to link every minor's account to a parent's, to obtain the parent's permission before the minor downloads any application or makes any purchase, and to tell developers the age category of every user. Utah passed a similar law with an effective date of May 7, 2026, Louisiana one effective July 1, 2026, and California one effective January 1, 2027. The Texas law was to take effect January 1, 2026.
On December 23, 2025 Judge Robert Pitman in Austin blocked it, finding that it restricted access to a vast universe of speech and comparing it to a law that would require every bookstore to verify the age of every customer at the door. In June 2026 the Fifth Circuit paused his injunction and let the law take effect while the appeal goes on. In Texas, as of the summer of 2026, an adult who wants a weather application must first prove to Apple or Google that he is an adult, and a sixteen year old who wants a dictionary must have a parent approve it.
What is being built
The arguments for these laws are about children, and the harms they describe are real. What the laws build is something else: a system in which a person's identity is checked at the door of the ordinary internet, by private companies, under the compulsion of the state, with the records kept by whoever collected them. The Texas pornography law creates a record of what adults read. The app store law creates a record of who every user is. Each is defended as narrow. Together they are the end of anonymous reading on the two platforms, the web and the phone, where nearly all reading now happens, and the court that once said adults could not be made to identify themselves to read has now said that they can.
Primary Sources (4)
Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.
Documented Records (2)
Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.
Timeline Events (2)
Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.
More in Surveillance & Privacy
View all stories in Surveillance & Privacy → · Topic overview →
- 2025 to 2026153 Million Driver's License Scans Leaked for Sale After Mandatory ID Checks at Retailers and WebsitesOn September 1, 2026 a service opened on a Russian criminal forum selling scans of more than 153 million American and Canadian driver's licenses, 10 million identification cards, 3 million passports and other travel documents, and 579,000 medical cards, each record with front and back photographs of the card and the date it was scanned. The data appears to come from IDScan.net, a New Orleans company that checks IDs for Hertz, Target, FedEx, and casinos, more than 21 million times a month at more than 20,000 locations. The sellers said they had been taking it for over a year. Every law that requires an ID to be shown to a company builds a database like this one. The laws now require it to buy a phone application, to open a website, to board a plane, and, on the Justice Department's own site, to read the Epstein files.Surveillance & Privacy
- August 2026Flock License Plate Camera Networks and Police Warrantless TrackingOn August 26, 2026, Ron DeSantis said the Flock camera network that local police in Florida use to track vehicles is out of control and that he does not want the state to become a surveillance state. Five days later the state transportation department ordered the cameras off state roads within 30 days. The same week a Kentucky officer was charged with using the system to track his ex-girlfriend 2,048 times.Surveillance & Privacy
- 2008 to 2026FISA Section 702: 278,000 Improper FBI Searches of Americans and Warrantless SurveillanceSection 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act lets the NSA collect the communications of foreigners abroad from American companies without a warrant, and lets the FBI search what it collects for Americans' names. In 2022 a secret court found the FBI had run more than 278,000 improper searches in a little over a year. In 2025 the agencies targeted 349,823 people and the FBI searched for 7,413 Americans. The statute expired at midnight on June 12, 2026 for the first time since 2008 after the House refused a third short extension. The collection continues under court certifications that run to March 2027.Surveillance & Privacy
- March 2025 to July 2026The 2025 Executive Order Merging IRS, Medicaid, and Social Security Records into One Federal SystemOn March 20, 2025 the president ordered every agency to give federal officials full and prompt access to all unclassified records and to secure unfettered access to the data of every state program that takes federal money. Within a year the IRS had handed immigration agents the addresses of about 47,000 taxpayers under an agreement a judge found contrary to law, Medicaid had sent the records of enrollees in every state to the same agents, a copy of the Social Security file on more than 300 million people had been placed in a cloud outside the agency's controls, and the agents' contractor had been given data a court had ordered withheld.Surveillance & Privacy
- 1994 to 2025Salt Typhoon: How Chinese Hackers Used Congressionally Mandated Wiretap Backdoors Inside US Phone CarriersIn 1994 Congress required the phone companies to build interception into their networks so the government could listen with a court order. On November 13, 2024 the FBI confirmed that hackers affiliated with the Chinese government had been inside American carriers, had taken customer call records, had read and listened to the communications of people in government and politics, and had copied information from the systems that handle the government's own wiretap orders. By December a ninth carrier had been named. The government's advice to the public was to use encryption, which the FBI had spent a decade telling Congress was a danger. In January 2025 the FCC ruled that the 1994 law obliged carriers to secure their networks. In November 2025 it rescinded the ruling, 2 to 1.Surveillance & Privacy