2013 to 2019: The disclosures · Surveillance & Privacy

Project Hemisphere: How Police Searched Trillions of AT&T Phone Records Without Warrants

Period covered: 1992 to 2024 · 10 sources

Summary

From 2007 to 2024 the White House drug office paid AT&T to let police search a database of the company's call records that went back to 1987 and grew by four billion records a day. Any officer with a subpoena could use it, and many agencies write their own subpoenas. The training slides told officers never to mention the program in an official document. The New York Times found it in 2013. The funding was suspended, the program was renamed, and it was started again in 2017 and again in 2022. The Justice Department's inspector general found in 2019 that the DEA had never done a full legal analysis of it, or of an earlier program that collected the records of Americans' calls to as many as 116 countries from 1992 to 2013. In 2022 two senators disclosed that the CIA had been running its own bulk collection program with no statute behind it.

In 2013 an activist named Drew Hendricks filed public records requests and received a set of training slides. The New York Times published what they showed in September 2013. The program was called Hemisphere. AT&T kept a database of call records going back to 1987 and added about four billion records to it every day. AT&T employees sat in the offices of the government's drug task forces in Los Angeles, Houston, and Atlanta and ran searches for law enforcement. Their salaries were paid by the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy through a grant program called the High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas. The program had started in 2007.

The slides told officers to never refer to Hemisphere in any official document. When a search produced a result, the officer was to send a second subpoena to the phone company for the same records and cite only that second subpoena in reports and court filings. The slides called this walling off the source. A defendant, a judge, and a jury would see a subpoena for one person's records and would not know that the number had been found by searching a database of everyone's.

The contract

In October 2016 The Daily Beast obtained the contract terms under which AT&T sold the service. The government agency, the document said, agrees not to use the data as evidence in any judicial or administrative proceedings unless there is no other available and admissible probative evidence, and must make every effort to insure that information provided by the Contractor is non-attributable to AT&T if the data is provided to a third-party. AT&T said it complies with subpoenas, warrants, and court orders. The Electronic Frontier Foundation sued for the records in 2015, and in December 2016 a federal judge rejected the government's secrecy claims and ordered about 260 pages released.

The money

Senator Ron Wyden wrote to the attorney general on November 20, 2023 after his office was given the Justice Department's own records of the program. The White House drug office had paid $1.4 million for it in 2009 and about $500,000 a year by 2012. After the Times story in 2013 the Obama administration suspended the funding, and the program continued anyway under a new name, Data Analytical Services, paid for directly by the regional drug task forces. In 2017 the Trump administration resumed the White House funding at $300,000. In 2021 the Biden administration paused it. In 2022 it was restarted at $270,000. A law enforcement document quoted in the letter called the service AT&T's Super Search Engine and Google on Steroids. It could identify a target's other phone numbers, produce location data, and return two levels of call detail records for one target number, which means the records of everyone the target called and everyone those people called. The searches did not have to involve drugs. In most states the subpoena could be written by the agency itself; California and Texas required a court order. The documents were not classified. The Justice Department had marked them Law Enforcement Sensitive and would not let the senator publish them. He wrote that he had serious concerns about the legality of this surveillance program, and that the materials contain troubling information that would justifiably outrage many Americans.

On March 14, 2025 Wyden and Representative Andy Biggs announced that the inspector general had released previously redacted parts of a 2019 report about the program, and that federal funding for it had ended on September 30, 2024.

The inspector general

The Justice Department's inspector general published a review on March 28, 2019 of the DEA's use of administrative subpoenas to collect bulk data. It covered three programs. The first collected the records of calls from the United States to as many as 116 countries with a nexus to drugs, from 1992 to 2013, on subpoenas that named no target. The third, run since 2007, obtained telephone metadata through a contractor for a separate government agency. The inspector general found that the DEA, and the department itself with respect to one program, failed to conduct a comprehensive legal analysis of the use of the subpoena power to collect bulk data. Agents and analysts, the report said, were instructed not to use the information from these programs in affidavits, court pleadings, or the like, and to keep the information isolated from official files. The bulk data was used on an unknown number of occasions in support of investigations by other federal agencies. The report made 16 recommendations, and the department agreed with all of them.

In March 2025 the inspector general released the parts of the report about Hemisphere that had been redacted. They showed that the questions had been raised inside the agency from the start. In the program's first year a DEA supervisor asked the agency's chief counsel for assurance that it had been legally approved; the inspector general found no evidence that the lawyers substantially addressed the concerns. In 2008 a special agent in charge raised major concerns about how the program was being used. In August 2010 the FBI's top lawyer contacted the DEA about it, and the FBI suspended its own access that month. A DEA lawyer eventually wrote an analysis finding the program lawful. It was never finalized or distributed.

The CIA's

On April 13, 2021 Senators Wyden and Martin Heinrich wrote to the director of national intelligence and the director of the CIA. The letter was declassified on February 10, 2022, along with parts of a report by the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board. The senators wrote that the CIA has secretly conducted its own bulk program, entirely outside the statutory framework that Congress and the public believe govern this collection, and without any of the judicial, congressional or even executive branch oversight that comes from Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act collection. The program ran under Executive Order 12333, which is an order of the president and not a law. The board's staff found that when an analyst pulled up information about an American, the system showed a pop-up box reminding the analyst of the rules, and required nothing else. No written reason for the search had to be recorded. The board recommended that one be required. The senators said the documents reveal serious problems associated with warrantless backdoor searches of Americans, the same issue that has generated bipartisan concern in the FISA context. What the program collected, and from whom, is still redacted.

← 2013 to 2019

Primary Sources (10)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Electronic Frontier Foundation. The 2013 slides: records since 1987, four billion a day, AT&T employees in the task force offices, never refer to Hemisphere in any official document, the second subpoena to wall off the source. EFF's suits and the December 2016 ruling.
2016
Electronic Frontier Foundation. The contract language: the agency agrees not to use the data as evidence in any judicial or administrative proceedings unless there is no other available and admissible probative evidence.
2019
Nextgov. Program A, 1992 to 2013, calls from the United States to as many as 116 countries; Program C, since 2007, metadata obtained through a contractor for another agency.
2019
U.S. Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector General. Three bulk programs; no comprehensive legal analysis; agents instructed to keep the information out of affidavits and court pleadings and isolated from official files; 16 recommendations.
2022
Office of Senator Ron Wyden. The April 13, 2021 letter: the CIA has secretly conducted its own bulk program, entirely outside the statutory framework.
2022
The Register. The pop-up reminder, no written justification required for searches of Americans' information, and the board's recommendation that one be required.
2022
Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board. The declassified Deep Dive 1 report on CIA financial data activities, the Deep Dive 2 staff recommendations on one counterterrorism activity under E.O. 12333, and Member LeBlanc's statement.
2023
Office of Senator Ron Wyden. The funding history 2009 to 2022, the Data Analytical Services name, two levels of call records, self issued subpoenas, the Law Enforcement Sensitive marking, and the request to publish.
2025
Office of Representative Andy Biggs. The unredacted parts of the 2019 report released; federal funding ended September 30, 2024.
2025
Criminal Legal News. The unredacted findings: the first year request to chief counsel, the 2008 concerns, the FBI's August 2010 suspension, the legal analysis never finalized or distributed.

Documented Records (2)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2022
April 13, 2021, declassified February 10, 2022
Two senators on the Intelligence Committee disclosed that the CIA had run a bulk collection program under Executive Order 12333 with no statute behind it, and that its analysts could search Americans' information after a pop-up reminder with no written reason recorded. The oversight board recommended requiring one. What was collected remains redacted.
“The CIA has secretly conducted its own bulk program, entirely outside the statutory framework that Congress and the public believe govern this collection.”
Central Intelligence Agency. Violates: Fourth Amendment; the statutory framework Congress wrote for collection. Bypassed by executive order.. Source: Wyden and Heinrich: Newly Declassified Documents Reveal Previously Secret CIA Bulk Collection, Problems With CIA Handling of Americans' Information, Office of Senator Ron Wyden
2023
2007 to September 30, 2024
The White House drug office paid AT&T to let any officer with a subpoena search call records back to 1987, four billion added a day, and the training slides said never to refer to the program in an official document and to wall off the source with a second subpoena. Funding was suspended in 2013, restarted in 2017, paused in 2021, restarted in 2022, and ended September 30, 2024. The inspector general found the DEA never did a full legal analysis of it or of its 1992 to 2013 program collecting calls to 116 countries.
“I have serious concerns about the legality of this surveillance program, and the materials provided by the DoJ contain troubling information that would justifiably outrage many Americans.”
Office of National Drug Control Policy; Drug Enforcement Administration; AT&T; the police agencies that used it. Violates: Fourth Amendment. No judge, no warrant, and the search hidden from the court.. Source: Letter from Senator Ron Wyden to Attorney General Merrick Garland on the Hemisphere surveillance program, Office of Senator Ron Wyden

Timeline Events (7)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

September 30, 2024
Federal funding for Hemisphere ends
Seventeen years after it began.
November 20, 2023
Wyden: Hemisphere still running, funded again in 2022
Trillions of records; the documents marked Law Enforcement Sensitive.
February 10, 2022
Senators disclose the CIA's own bulk collection program
Outside the statutory framework; searches of Americans with no written reason.
March 28, 2019
Inspector general: DEA never did a legal analysis of its bulk collection
Agents told to keep it out of court filings. 16 recommendations.
September 2013
New York Times reveals Hemisphere
Never refer to Hemisphere in any official document.
2007
Hemisphere begins: AT&T employees run call record searches for police
Records back to 1987, four billion a day, paid for by the White House drug office.
1992
DEA begins bulk collection of calls from the US to foreign countries
As many as 116 countries; ended 2013; never given a full legal review.
Project Hemisphere: How Police Searched Trillions of AT&T Phone Records Without Warrants | Spirit of '76