1975 to 2000: Investigations and deregulation · Wall Street & Banking

The 1999 Repeal of Glass-Steagall (Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act)

Period covered: November 12, 1999 · 3 sources

Summary

For 66 years the Glass-Steagall Act kept the bank that held your deposits separate from the firm that traded securities. In November 1999 Congress repealed that separation by votes of 90 to 8 and 362 to 57, a year after Citicorp and Travelers had merged in anticipation of it. Nine years later the combined banks were too big to fail.

The Banking Act of 1933, known by the names of its sponsors as Glass-Steagall, was written in the wreckage of the 1929 crash. Its central rule was separation. A commercial bank, the kind that takes deposits and makes loans, could not also be an investment bank that underwrites and trades securities, and the two could not be under the same roof. The idea was that the money people put in the bank should not be used to gamble in the markets, and that if the gambling side failed it should not take the deposit side with it. Deposit insurance came in the same law, and it was the reason the separation mattered: the government now stood behind deposits, so the government had an interest in what the banks did with them.

For most of the century that followed, American banking was what Simon Johnson, in FRONTLINE's series, called plain vanilla business. Take deposits, lend them out, know who in the community is a good credit. Bankers earned what lawyers and doctors earned. Starting in the 1980s the banks lobbied to have the wall taken down, and the regulators let it erode piece by piece. In 1998 Citicorp, the largest bank, and Travelers, an insurance company that owned the investment bank Salomon Smith Barney, announced a merger that was illegal under the law as written, on the expectation that the law would change. It did.

What the Law Provided

Senate bill 900 of the 106th Congress was sponsored by Senator Phil Gramm of Texas, Congressman Jim Leach of Iowa, and Congressman Thomas Bliley of Virginia, all Republicans, and it had the support of the Clinton Treasury under Robert Rubin, who left the Treasury in 1999 and joined Citigroup a few months later. The final version passed the Senate 90 to 8 and the House 362 to 57 on November 4, 1999, and President Clinton signed it on November 12. It repealed the sections of Glass-Steagall that separated banking from securities and let a single holding company own a commercial bank, an investment bank, and an insurer. Supporters told Congress that without it London, Frankfurt, or Shanghai would become the financial capital of the world. Clinton said the Glass-Steagall law was no longer appropriate to the economy.

Lead Contamination and Legionnaires' Outbreak

The trading side of the merged banks grew, in the words of one banker in the FRONTLINE series, to three, four, and five times the size of the banking side. The banks began paying engineers and scientists multiples of what any other field paid, and the culture of trading for the bank's own account took over. When the mortgage securities market collapsed in 2008, the institutions that failed or nearly failed were the combined ones: Citigroup, which needed $45 billion in capital and hundreds of billions in guarantees, and Bank of America, which had absorbed Merrill Lynch. The government rescued them because their deposit sides, which it insured, were tied to their trading sides, which had failed. That is the situation the 1933 law had been written to prevent.

The law also has a second half that gets less attention. Title V set the rules for what financial companies may do with customers' personal information. It lets a company share nonpublic personal information with its affiliates and, unless the customer opts out, with outside companies, and it is the reason every bank mails a privacy notice once a year that almost nobody reads.

After the crisis, Paul Volcker, the former Fed chairman, proposed restoring the core of Glass-Steagall by separating proprietary trading from customer banking. The rule that carried his name grew from 10 pages to nearly 300 pages of exemptions under lobbying. The separation has not been restored.

← 1975 to 2000

Primary Sources (3)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

1999
Congress.gov. Repealed the Glass-Steagall separation of commercial and investment banking.
2012
FRONTLINE (PBS). The origin of the credit default swap and the decision not to regulate derivatives.
2012
FRONTLINE (PBS). Bonuses, derivatives sold to towns and countries, Jefferson County, Greece, and the lobbying on the rules.

Documented Records (12)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

1994
June 1994
JP Morgan's derivatives group, most of them in their twenties, met at a resort in Boca Raton and worked out how to separate the risk of a loan from the loan itself. This became the credit default swap.
“This idea was essentially created under the banner of making the financial system safer.”
JP Morgan. Violates: None at the time. This is where the market started.. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
1997
1990s
The first large credit default swap moved JP Morgan's exposure to Exxon to a bank in London, which allowed JP Morgan to hold less capital against the loan and lend more. Other banks learned they could use the same method to reduce their capital requirements.
“Credit derivatives made it possible for a bank to skirt capital requirements.”
JP Morgan, Blythe Masters. Violates: Capital requirements meant to keep banks solvent. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
1998
1998
JP Morgan wrote a single swap covering 306 companies, divided it into tranches with different levels of risk, and then began selling contracts based on portfolios it did not own. These became known as synthetic CDOs.
“It's just a pure bet by somebody who has no economic interest in what they're betting on.”
JP Morgan, Terri Duhon. Violates: None at the time. These contracts were unregulated.. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
1998
Brooksley Born, the head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, warned that unregulated derivatives would build up risk until they caused a crisis and a taxpayer bailout. The banks lobbied against regulation, and Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan supported the banks.
“Regulation of derivatives transactions that are privately negotiated by professionals is unnecessary.”
Alan Greenspan, the banking lobby. Violates: The government's responsibility to protect the public's money. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
1999
November 1999
Congress repealed the Glass-Steagall Act. Commercial banks that hold deposits could now merge with investment banks. At the merged companies the trading side grew to several times the size of the banking side.
“The Glass-Steagall law is no longer appropriate.”
Congress, President Clinton. Violates: The separation of deposit banking from trading, in place since 1933. Source: Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, S.900, 106th Congress (1999), Congress.gov
2003
2003
Georgia passed the strictest predatory lending law in the country. The mortgage lobby worked to defeat Governor Roy Barnes at the next election, and the new legislature removed most of the law about two weeks into its session.
“You would have thought I had recommended that we repeal the plan of Salvation. Why were they so opposed to it? Money.”
The mortgage lobby, the Georgia legislature. Violates: Consent of the governed. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2005
2003 to 2006
The chief executive of Wells Fargo told meetings of bankers and regulators, including Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke, that subprime mortgage securities were toxic and that a bubble was forming. The bankers involved in the market said there was no problem.
“This is toxic waste. We're building a bubble. We're not going to like the outcome.”
Federal Reserve, Wall Street banks. Violates: Regulators' duty to act on warnings. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2007
2007
Goldman Sachs assembled CDOs containing subprime mortgages, sold them to customers, and used credit default swaps to bet that they would fail. It later settled with the SEC over marketing materials that left out important information.
“They bet against their own clients, so when the clients lost money, Goldman was making money.”
Goldman Sachs. Violates: The duty not to deceive customers. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2011
2011
No bank chief executive was removed by the government or prosecuted for the crisis. An economist interviewed in the film said there was clear evidence of illegality and that prosecutions would have succeeded.
“It is pretty clear, actually, that there was massive illegality going on.”
Department of Justice. Violates: Equal justice under law. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part One, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2002 to 2011
JP Morgan sold Jefferson County, Alabama, interest rate swaps on $3 billion of sewer debt, with payments to a local adviser that federal prosecutors treated as bribes. When rates moved in 2008 the county owed hundreds of millions of dollars. JP Morgan settled with the SEC for $25 million and forgave $697 million in fees. In November 2011 the county filed the largest municipal bankruptcy in U.S. history. Across the country, similar swaps have cost taxpayers about $20 billion.
“They came down here like sharks to raw meat in the water.”
JP Morgan, Charles LeCroy, Larry Langford. Violates: The duty not to deceive public bodies. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Four, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2008 to 2011
Since the crash, New York banks have paid more than $80 billion in bonuses. In 2011, a year in which their share prices fell, they set aside $20 billion.
“It's Christmastime on Wall Street.”
Wall Street banks. Violates: None. Listed to show where the public money went.. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Four, FRONTLINE (PBS)
2012
2012
The five largest banks in America are larger than before the crisis, with assets equal to 56 percent of the economy. After lobbying, the threshold for oversight of swap dealers was raised from $100 million to $8 billion in annual trades, which left 85 percent of derivative dealers outside regulation.
“We now somehow believe that finance sort of drives everything.”
The banking lobby, federal regulators. Violates: Equal application of the law to the financial industry. Source: Money, Power and Wall Street, Part Four, FRONTLINE (PBS)

Timeline Events (1)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

November 12, 1999
Gramm-Leach-Bliley signed, repealing the separation of banking and securities
Passed the Senate 90 to 8 and the House 362 to 57 a year after Citicorp and Travelers merged in anticipation of it.
The 1999 Repeal of Glass-Steagall (Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act) | Spirit of '76