2020 to today · Surveillance & Privacy

How Intelligence Agencies and Police Buy Phone Location Data to Bypass the Fourth Amendment

Period covered: 2018 to 2026 · 8 sources

Summary

In 2018 the Supreme Court held that the government needs a warrant to get a person's phone location history from the phone company. The agencies then bought the same information from data brokers instead. The intelligence community's own 2022 review said the data covers nearly everyone, could identify every person who attended a protest, and could facilitate blackmail, stalking, harassment, and public shaming. Homeland Security's inspector general found three of its agencies ran at least 71,000 location queries without the privacy reviews their own rules required. A bill to close the loophole passed the House in 2024 and died in the Senate. In June 2026 the court held that a geofence request to Google is a search.

Every phone carries applications that report where it is. The reports go to advertising networks, and from there to companies whose business is to collect them, match them to a device, and sell the result. The result is a history of where a person has been, at what hour, for how long, on what days, down to the building. Since 2018 the Constitution has required a warrant for the government to get that history from a phone company. It has never required one for the government to buy it.

Carpenter and what came after

In Carpenter v. United States, decided June 22, 2018, the Supreme Court held that a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy in the record of his phone's movements, and that police who want that record from the carrier need a warrant. The ruling did not say what happens when the same record is for sale. Agencies concluded that it said nothing, and bought.

The Office of the Director of National Intelligence commissioned a review of what the agencies were buying. The report is dated January 2022 and was declassified in June 2023. It says that commercially available information includes information on nearly everyone that is of a type and level of sensitivity that historically could have been obtained, if at all, only through targeted and predicated collection. It says the same type of information on millions of Americans is openly for sale to the general public and that the agencies can purchase it. It says the data could be used, for example, to identify every person who attended a protest or rally based on their smartphone location or ad tracking records, that it can reveal religion or religious practices, sexual activity, and medical information including mental health, and that in the wrong hands, sensitive insights gained through it could facilitate blackmail, stalking, harassment, and public shaming. The report cites Carpenter and notes that acquiring the same location data from a carrier is a search that generally requires probable cause.

Homeland Security

The Department of Homeland Security's inspector general audited three of its agencies, Customs and Border Protection, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and the Secret Service, and reported in September 2023 that all three had bought and used commercial telemetry data, the location records described above, without the privacy impact assessments the department's own policy requires, and that between fiscal 2019 and 2020 they ran at least 71,000 queries against it. The inspector general recommended that the department stop using the data until the assessments were done. The recommendation was left open.

The brokers

The Federal Trade Commission has since taken action against the sellers. Its complaint of December 3, 2024 against Gravy Analytics and its subsidiary Venntel, one of the vendors the government bought from, alleged that the two gathered more than 17 billion signals from about a billion smartphones every day, and sold location data tied to medical facilities, including those relating to substance abuse, reproductive care, and psychiatry, to religious organizations, correctional facilities, labor union offices, and homeless shelters. The final order of January 14, 2025 bars the companies from selling sensitive location data, with an exception for national security and law enforcement uses. On the same day in December 2024 the commission acted against Mobilewalla, which it said had collected more than 500 million advertising identifiers matched to precise locations between 2018 and 2020, tracked women to health clinics to sell lists of pregnant women, and built segments of protesters sorted by race. None of the orders bars a government agency from buying the same data from the next broker.

The bill that died

The Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act would have barred law enforcement and intelligence agencies from buying data that they would otherwise need a warrant or court order to obtain. The House passed it on April 17, 2024, 219 to 199. The Senate never voted on it. In the 2026 fight over Section 702, described on another page, closing the data broker loophole was one of the four reforms the privacy groups asked for. None was adopted.

Chatrie

The court took up a related question in 2026. A geofence warrant asks Google for the identity of every device that was inside a drawn area during a window of time. Police in Virginia used one to find a bank robber in 2019, and the defendant, Okello Chatrie, argued that the demand was a search of everyone in the area. On June 29, 2026 the Supreme Court held, in an opinion by Justice Kagan, that obtaining a person's location history from Google is a Fourth Amendment search, that location history provides an even more fine tuned picture of a person's movements than the cell tower records in Carpenter, and that a cell phone user is not to be viewed as sharing private information with third parties just by doing the ordinary things cell phone users do. Five justices joined the opinion and a sixth agreed with the result. Three dissented. The court sent the case back for a decision on whether the warrant itself was valid, and it said nothing about purchase.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (8)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2022
Office of the Director of National Intelligence. Information on nearly everyone; could identify every person who attended a protest; could facilitate blackmail, stalking, harassment, and public shaming.
2023
Department of Homeland Security Office of Inspector General. The recommendation to stop using the data until the assessments are done, left open.
2024
Electronic Privacy Information Center. The inspector general's finding of at least 71,000 queries of commercial location data without approved privacy assessments.
2024
American Civil Liberties Union. The 219 to 199 vote of April 17, 2024.
2024
The Record. 17 billion signals a day from about a billion phones; the sensitive locations; Mobilewalla's 500 million identifiers and its segments of pregnant women and protesters.
2025
Federal Trade Commission. The December 3, 2024 complaint and the January 14, 2025 order barring sales of sensitive location data.
2026
Supreme Court of the United States. Obtaining location history from Google by geofence is a Fourth Amendment search. Kagan for five, Gorsuch concurring in the judgment, Alito dissenting.
2026
Just Security. The lineup and the holding.

Documented Records (4)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2023
January 2022, declassified June 2023
The intelligence community's own review of commercially available information found that it includes information on nearly everyone of a type and sensitivity that historically could have been obtained only through targeted and predicated collection, that the agencies can purchase it, that it could identify every person who attended a protest or rally, and that in the wrong hands it could facilitate blackmail, stalking, harassment, and public shaming.
“CAI could be used, for example, to identify every person who attended a protest or rally based on their smartphone location or ad-tracking records.”
Office of the Director of National Intelligence; the agencies that buy the data. Violates: Fourth Amendment, evaded by purchase.. Source: Report to the Director of National Intelligence on Commercially Available Information (declassified), Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Fiscal 2019 to 2020, reported September 2023
Customs and Border Protection, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and the Secret Service bought and used commercial phone location data without the privacy impact assessments the department requires and ran at least 71,000 queries against it. The inspector general recommended they stop until the assessments were done; the recommendation was left open.
“All three DHS components used CTD without approved PIAs in the audited years and, in total, conducted at least 71,000 queries between FY 2019 and 2020.”
Department of Homeland Security. Violates: The department's own privacy policy.. Source: DHS Disregards Internal Policies and Avoids Fourth Amendment Protections to Track Your Location, Electronic Privacy Information Center
2024
April 17, 2024
The House passed the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act, 219 to 199, which would have barred agencies from buying data they would otherwise need a warrant or court order to obtain. The Senate never voted on it.
United States Senate. Violates: Fourth Amendment. Left as it was.. Source: After House Passes Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act, ACLU Urges Senate to Follow Suit, American Civil Liberties Union
2026
June 29, 2026
The Supreme Court held in Chatrie v. United States that obtaining a person's location history from Google under a geofence warrant is a Fourth Amendment search, that the history is a finer picture of a person's movements than cell tower records, and that a cell phone user does not share private information with third parties just by doing the ordinary things cell phone users do. Five justices joined, a sixth concurred in the result, three dissented. The court did not address purchase.
“A cell-phone user is not to be viewed as sharing private information with third parties just by doing the ordinary things cell-phone users do.”
Supreme Court. Violates: Fourth Amendment. Applied.. Source: Chatrie v. United States, 609 U.S. ___ (2026), Supreme Court of the United States

Timeline Events (5)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

June 29, 2026
Chatrie: a geofence request to Google is a search
Five justices, a sixth concurring; nothing said about purchase.
December 3, 2024
FTC: a broker gathered 17 billion location signals a day from a billion phones
Sold to agencies and others; barred from selling sensitive locations in January 2025.
April 17, 2024
House passes the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act, 219 to 199
The Senate never votes.
September 28, 2023
Homeland Security inspector general: 71,000 location queries without privacy review
Three agencies; recommendation to stop left open.
January 27, 2022
Intelligence community's own review: purchased data covers nearly everyone
Declassified June 2023.
How Intelligence Agencies and Police Buy Phone Location Data to Bypass the Fourth Amendment | Spirit of '76