2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Health, Food & Regulators
Bill Gates on Population, Vaccine Funding, BioNTech Stock, and the World Health Organization
Period covered: 1999 to 2026 · 23 sources
Summary
Five widely circulated clips of Bill and Melinda Gates speaking about population growth, set beside the full recordings they were cut from. The 6.8 billion sentence is from a 2010 talk on carbon dioxide, and the next sentence in the recording is that population still goes up. The institute the narrator calls the Institute for Population Control is the Bill and Melinda Gates Institute for Population and Reproductive Health at Johns Hopkins, founded in 1999 with $20 million, and its founding director was Laurie Zabin, not Dr. Zaven. What is true is that Gates did say his foundation began with reproductive health because he thought population growth was the biggest problem poor countries face, that he did say the death panel line, and that his foundation has put $4.1 billion into Gavi, more into the World Health Organization in 2024 and 2025 than the United States government, $560 million into contraception, $55 million into BioNTech the year before the pandemic, and a $1 per dose deal with Pfizer.
The words are from a talk Gates gave at TED in February 2010 called Innovating to zero, about getting carbon dioxide emissions to zero. He put an equation on the screen: CO2 equals people times the services each person uses times the energy each service takes times the CO2 per unit of energy, and said one of those four numbers would have to get near zero. Then he went through them. The official transcript reads: First, we've got population. The world today has 6.8 billion people. That's headed up to about nine billion. Now, if we do a really great job on new vaccines, health care, reproductive health services, we could lower that by, perhaps, 10 or 15 percent. But there, we see an increase of about 1.3. The second factor is the services we use.
The sentence the video stops before is the one that says population goes up by a factor of about 1.3 either way. He was saying that the growth from 6.8 to 9 billion could be lowered by 10 or 15 percent, that it could not be lowered to zero, and that the zero would have to come from the other three numbers. Whether that reading is right is not a matter of opinion; the full TED transcript records both the sentence before and the sentence after.
The clip: Melinda and I wondered whether keeping children alive would create a population problem
This is from a video Gates posted on February 17, 2018 with the caption: As counterintuitive as it may seem, population sizes don't go up as the world gets healthier. They go down. In it he says the foundation had asked itself whether providing new medicines and keeping children alive would create more of a population problem, and answers: what we found out is that as health improves, families choose to have less children. And this effect is very, very dramatic. We find that in every country of the world, this is repeated. The population growth goes down as we improve health.
Melinda Gates's line, if you start to save these children, will women just keep overpopulating the world, is from a 60 Minutes interview with Scott Pelley broadcast in October 2010. The next words in the CBS transcript are: And thank goodness, the converse is absolutely true. They don't do that. Because women say to themselves they want two children to survive into adulthood. The video keeps the question and cuts the answer. The same argument is in the foundation's 2014 annual letter under the heading Saving Lives Leads to Overpopulation, listed as a myth: when children survive in greater numbers, parents decide to have smaller families.
The clip: when our foundation first started up, it was focused on reproductive health
This one is real and is the most useful thing in the video. It is from a question and answer session with Chris Anderson after Gates's TED talk in February 2009, published by TED with a transcript. A questioner said his charity was adding enormously to the problem of overpopulation. Gates answered: When our foundation first started up, it was focused on reproductive health. That was the main thing we did because I thought population growth in poor countries is the biggest problem they face. You've got to help mothers who want to limit family size, have the tools and education to do that. That's the only thing that really counts. He went on: Well then, I came across articles that showed that the key thing you can do to reduce population growth is actually improve health, and said that if health improved rapidly the peak population would be as much as a billion below the current expected peak, about 8.3 billion versus 9.3.
So he said it. The foundation started out to limit family size in poor countries because its founder thought population growth was their biggest problem, and it still funds that work, in the amounts given below. He also said, in the same breath, that the way to do it is to keep children alive.
The clip: the death panel
This is from the Aspen Ideas Festival in July 2010, in a conversation with Walter Isaacson, and the recording is on the Aspen Institute's channel. Isaacson had asked whether the share of the economy going to health care was too high. Gates answered that the United States spends 17 percent of its economy on health care against 12 percent in Switzerland, that rising medical costs squeeze out everything else including universities, and then: That's a trade-off society is making because of very, very high medical costs and a lack of willingness to say, you know, is spending a million dollars on that last three months of life for that patient, would it be better not to lay off those ten teachers and to make that trade-off in medical costs? But that's called the death panel, and you're not supposed to have that discussion. He then said the country would be laying off over 100,000 teachers, which, you know, I'm very much against that.
He said the line. It was an argument about how a state budget is spent, and he said it while saying the choice was one nobody was willing to make out loud.
The clip: the Institute for Population Control
The narrator says that in 1998 Dr. Zaven became the founding director of the Bill and Melinda Gates Institute for Population Control. There is no such institute and no such person. The Bill and Melinda Gates Institute for Population and Reproductive Health was established at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health in 1999 with a $20 million grant from the foundation, after a planning grant in 1997. Its founding director was Laurie Schwab Zabin, a demographer who ran it until 2002; Johns Hopkins's own obituary of her in May 2020 says so. In 2023 it was renamed the William H. Gates Sr. Institute for Population and Reproductive Health. Its work, in the university's words, is family planning and reproductive health in the developing world.
What the record actually shows
The video does not need editing to make the point it wants to make, because the documents make a plainer one. This is the size and reach of the foundation, from its own pages and the pages of the organizations it funds.
The foundation's fact sheet as of December 31, 2025 gives total grant payments since 1994 of $90.0 billion and an endowment of $89 billion. In January 2010, at Davos, Bill and Melinda Gates pledged $10 billion over ten years to vaccines and Gates said: We must make this the decade of vaccines. In December 2010 the foundation, the World Health Organization, UNICEF, and the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases announced a Decade of Vaccines Collaboration whose leadership council was Margaret Chan of the WHO, Anthony Fauci of NIAID, Anthony Lake of UNICEF, Joy Phumaphi, and Tachi Yamada of the foundation. The foundation was a founding partner of Gavi, the vaccine alliance, with $750 million in 2000, and Gavi's own donor page puts the foundation's commitments at $4.1 billion to date. At the World Health Organization, the budget portal lists the foundation as the third largest contributor for 2022 and 2023, behind the United States and Germany, at $829.5 million, and as the largest contributor for 2024 and 2025 at $761.1 million, above the United States at $751.6 million. A private foundation now puts more money into the WHO than the United States government does.
On family planning, the foundation and the British government co-hosted the London Summit on Family Planning on July 11, 2012, whose goal was contraception for an additional 120 million women and girls in the world's poorest countries by 2020, at a cost put at $4.3 billion. Melinda Gates announced that day that the foundation would raise its family planning spending by $560 million over eight years, to more than $1 billion by 2020, doubling it from $70 million a year to $140 million. On November 13, 2014 Pfizer, the foundation, and the Children's Investment Fund Foundation announced that Pfizer's injectable contraceptive Sayana Press would be sold at $1 a dose to qualified purchasers in 69 of the world's poorest countries; in May 2017 the price went to 85 cents, and the foundation's investment fund lists the deal as a volume guarantee. On September 4, 2019 the foundation made an equity investment of $55 million in BioNTech, a German company, for HIV and tuberculosis work, with total funding that could reach $100 million; fifteen months later BioNTech's product with Pfizer was the first COVID-19 vaccine authorized in the United States. On October 18, 2019 the foundation co-hosted, with the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security and the World Economic Forum, a pandemic exercise called Event 201 built around a fictional coronavirus that killed 65 million people in the scenario; the center said in January 2020 that the exercise was not a prediction and that the inputs we used for modeling the potential impact of that fictional virus are not similar to nCoV-2019. In 2015 Gates had said at TED: if anything kills over 10 million people in the next few decades, it's most likely to be a highly infectious virus rather than a war. The Columbia Journalism Review counted, in August 2020, more than $250 million in foundation grants to journalism, with the BBC, NBC, Al Jazeera, ProPublica, the Guardian, the Financial Times, the Atlantic, and Le Monde among the recipients.
Primary Sources (23)
Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.
Documented Records (1)
Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.
Timeline Events (2)
Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.
More in Health, Food & Regulators
View all stories in Health, Food & Regulators → · Topic overview →
- 2017 to 2026COVID-19 Hospital Payment Bonuses, Remdesivir Approval, PREP Act Hospital Immunity, and Pre-2020 Pandemic PlansIn 2020 Congress paid hospitals 20 percent more for every Medicare patient with a COVID-19 diagnosis and then added a bonus for new treatments, the Food and Drug Administration approved remdesivir seven days after the World Health Organization's own trial found it had little or no effect on death, the government told the public not to take ivermectin in words a federal appeals court later said it had no authority to use, and the March 2020 declaration that gave drugmakers immunity was read by a state supreme court in 2026 to shield a hospital from a patient's death. The plans written before the pandemic had said not to do most of what was done: the government's 2017 guidance said an exposed household in a severe pandemic should stay home for up to three days, and the WHO's 2019 guidance said quarantine of the exposed and contact tracing were not recommended in any circumstances. At a Senate roundtable on September 28, 2026, patients, relatives, nurses, and doctors described what they say was done to patients in hospitals; no hospital or health agency took part, and the senator's office has released no report on it.Health, Food & Regulators
- 2007 to 2026The August 2026 Tariff Waiver for 660 Million Pounds of Foreign Beef Six Days After JBS Met the PresidentOn August 26, 2026 the President signed a proclamation letting 300,000 metric tons of foreign lean beef trimmings, about 660 million pounds, into the country over three months at the low in-quota tariff instead of the 26.4 percent rate that applies above the quota, on the stated ground that ground beef had become too expensive. The Wall Street Journal reported that six days earlier the co-owner of JBS, Joesley Batista, had met the President in the Oval Office and argued for exactly that; the announcement came the next day, and the White House said the decision "was not done as the result of any one conversation." JBS is the Brazilian company whose owners pleaded guilty in the United States in 2020 to bribery, admitted in Brazil to paying nearly 1,900 politicians, and bought their American packing plants with money from a Brazilian state bank. In 2017 the Agriculture Department had halted fresh Brazilian beef after refusing 11 percent of it at the border against 1 percent for the rest of the world. Since 2015 beef in the store has not had to say what country it came from. The week the quota opened, Europe stopped taking Brazilian beef over antibiotic use, the American cattle herd stood at its smallest since 1951, cattle prices fell, and the retail price of ground beef was $6.92 a pound.Health, Food & Regulators
- 1984 to 2026Anthony Fauci's Record: Private Mask Emails, Wuhan Lab Grants, Preemptive Pardon, and Pleadings of the FifthAnthony Fauci ran the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases for 38 years, was the highest paid employee of the federal government, and in 2020 became the government's voice on the pandemic. The government's own documents record: the email in which he told a cabinet secretary that masks are not really effective and that he did not recommend one, a month before he said the same on television and four months before he explained the advice had been about preserving supply; the herd immunity number he said he nudged up as the polls moved; the six-foot rule that, in his words to Congress, sort of just appeared; the Senate testimony that NIH had not funded a kind of research in Wuhan, and the NIH letter five months later describing an experiment there that EcoHealth failed to report; the audit, the suspension, and the debarment of the grantee; the pardon covering January 2014 to January 2025; the emails in which he wrote please delete this e-mail after you read it; and the day in July 2026 when, under subpoena, he invoked the Fifth Amendment more than a hundred times, after which a Senate committee voted to hold him in contempt.Health, Food & Regulators
- 2021 to 2026The 2026 Health Insurance Premium Spike After ACA Tax Credits ExpiredThe larger premium credits that had made insurance on the exchanges affordable since 2021 expired on December 31, 2025. Congress shut the government for 43 days over them in the fall, took a Senate vote that failed, passed a three year extension in the House in January by 230 to 196, and let it die. Enrollment fell from 22.1 million to 19.2 million, premium payments rose 58 percent for the people who stayed, deductibles rose $1,000, and the budget office expects more than 4 million more people uninsured by 2034, on top of the 10 million from the July 2025 law.Health, Food & Regulators
- 2018 to 2026Boeing 737 MAX Crashes: How the FAA Let Boeing Certify Its Own Planes and the DOJ Dropped Criminal ChargesTwo new Boeing 737 MAX jets crashed in October 2018 and March 2019, killing 346 people, because of a flight control system the company had not fully disclosed to the regulator, the airlines, or the pilots. A congressional investigation found a horrific culmination of faulty assumptions, a lack of transparency, and grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA, which had delegated much of the plane's certification to Boeing's own employees. The Justice Department charged the company with fraud and let it defer prosecution for $2.5 billion. Boeing broke the agreement, a door blew off another MAX in 2024, and in 2025 the government dropped the charge for $1.1 billion. A federal judge said the deal failed to secure the necessary accountability, and that he could not stop it.Health, Food & Regulators