2020 to today · Health, Food & Regulators

Boeing 737 MAX Crashes: How the FAA Let Boeing Certify Its Own Planes and the DOJ Dropped Criminal Charges

Period covered: 2018 to 2026 · 4 sources

Summary

Two new Boeing 737 MAX jets crashed in October 2018 and March 2019, killing 346 people, because of a flight control system the company had not fully disclosed to the regulator, the airlines, or the pilots. A congressional investigation found a horrific culmination of faulty assumptions, a lack of transparency, and grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA, which had delegated much of the plane's certification to Boeing's own employees. The Justice Department charged the company with fraud and let it defer prosecution for $2.5 billion. Boeing broke the agreement, a door blew off another MAX in 2024, and in 2025 the government dropped the charge for $1.1 billion. A federal judge said the deal failed to secure the necessary accountability, and that he could not stop it.

Lion Air Flight 610 went into the Java Sea on October 29, 2018, twelve minutes after takeoff, with 189 people aboard. Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 went into a field outside Addis Ababa on March 10, 2019, six minutes after takeoff, with 157. Both were Boeing 737 MAX 8 jets, months old. Both were pushed into the ground by a piece of software called MCAS that the pilots had not been told about, acting on a single sensor that had failed.

Congressional Investigation Findings

The House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure spent eighteen months on it and reported on September 16, 2020. Its conclusion was that the crashes were the horrific culmination of a series of faulty technical assumptions by Boeing's engineers, a lack of transparency on the part of Boeing's management, and grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA. It found that production pressure from competition with the Airbus A320neo had jeopardized safety; that Boeing had assumed pilots would recognize and correct an MCAS failure within four seconds, when its own test pilot had taken more than ten seconds in a simulator and had called the condition catastrophic; that Boeing withheld crucial information from the FAA, its customers, and 737 MAX pilots; and that FAA management overruled a determination of the FAA's own technical experts at the behest of Boeing.

The oversight had a structure. Under a program called Organization Designation Authorization, the FAA lets a manufacturer's own employees perform much of the certification work on the manufacturer's behalf. The committee's fourth finding was that this arrangement produced conflicted representation: the people certifying the airplane for the government worked for the company building it. The plane was grounded worldwide for twenty months.

The prosecution

On January 7, 2021 the Justice Department charged Boeing with conspiracy to defraud the United States by deceiving the FAA about MCAS, and on the same day agreed not to prosecute if the company paid $2.5 billion, most of it to airlines and a fund for the families, and stayed out of trouble for three years. The company paid a criminal penalty of $243.6 million. No executive was charged. The families of the dead were not consulted, and a federal judge later found that their rights under the Crime Victims' Rights Act had been violated by the way the deal was made.

Two days before the three years ran out, on January 5, 2024, a door plug blew out of a 737 MAX 9 in flight over Oregon. The plane landed. The inspections that followed found the bolts had never been installed. In May 2024 the department found that Boeing had breached the agreement. In July 2024 it offered a guilty plea with a fine and a monitor; in December 2024 Judge Reed O'Connor in Texas rejected it over the way the monitor would be chosen. In May 2025 the department withdrew the plea and offered a non prosecution agreement instead: $487.2 million in penalties, $444.5 million for the families, and $455 million to be spent on compliance and safety, with a consultant in place of a monitor, and no conviction. On November 6, 2025 the judge dismissed the charge. He wrote that the agreement fails to secure the necessary accountability to ensure the safety of the flying public, and that he lacked the authority to refuse it: poor discretion may not be countered with judicial overreach. In March 2026 the appeals court denied the families' attempt to reopen the case.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (4)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2020
House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. A horrific culmination of faulty technical assumptions, a lack of transparency, and grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA; the five themes; the ten second test.
2025
Claims Journal. The 2021 agreement and its $243.6 million penalty; the door plug two days before dismissal; the rejected plea; the $487.2 million, $444.5 million, and $455 million terms; the judge's words.
2025
Manufacturing Dive. The crash dates, 346 dead, the May 2025 agreement, and the families' response.
2026
U.S. News and World Report (Reuters). The Fifth Circuit's denial.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2025
2018 to 2026
Two 737 MAX jets crashed in 2018 and 2019, killing 346, because of a system Boeing had not disclosed to the FAA, which had delegated much of the certification to Boeing's own employees; a House investigation found grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA and that FAA management overruled its own experts at Boeing's behest. The Justice Department deferred prosecution in 2021 for $2.5 billion, found Boeing in breach in 2024 after a door blew off a MAX 9, and in 2025 dropped the charge for $1.1 billion. Judge O'Connor wrote that the deal fails to secure the necessary accountability and that he could not refuse it. The families' appeal was denied in March 2026.
“Poor discretion may not be countered with judicial overreach.”
Federal Aviation Administration; Department of Justice; Boeing. Violates: The duty of the regulator; the fraud statute. Charged and dropped.. Source: Boeing Avoids US Criminal Charge in 737 Max Jet Crash Case, Claims Journal

Timeline Events (2)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

November 6, 2025
Boeing criminal case dismissed for $1.1 billion
The judge: it fails to secure the necessary accountability.
September 16, 2020
House report: grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA on the 737 MAX
346 dead; Boeing's own employees certified the plane.
Boeing 737 MAX Crashes: How the FAA Let Boeing Certify Its Own Planes and the DOJ Dropped Criminal Charges | Spirit of '76