2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Health, Food & Regulators

The 1946–1948 US Public Health Service Experiments That Deliberately Infected 1,308 Guatemalans with Syphilis

Period covered: 1946 to 2024 · 10 sources

Summary

From 1946 to 1948 the United States Public Health Service, paid for in part by a grant from the National Institute of Health and run under the Surgeon General, deliberately infected people in Guatemala with syphilis, gonorrhea, and chancroid to study the diseases. A 2011 presidential commission, working from the lead doctor's own records, found that 1,308 prisoners, soldiers, and psychiatric patients were intentionally exposed, that only 678 were documented as receiving any treatment, and that at least 83 subjects died, though the records do not settle whether the experiments killed them. The government kept the work quiet at the time and it stayed hidden until a historian found the papers in a university archive. In 2010 the Secretary of State and the Secretary of Health and Human Services apologized and the President telephoned Guatemala's president to do the same. The courts held the government immune and the private defendants not liable. No compensation ever reached the subjects or their families.

In September 2011 the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues published its investigation, titled "Ethically Impossible": STD Research in Guatemala from 1946 to 1948. Working from the records of the doctor who ran it, the commission set out the numbers. "The studies encompassed research on three STDs, syphilis, gonorrhea, and chancroid, and involved the intentional exposure to STDs of 1,308 research subjects from three populations: prisoners, soldiers, and psychiatric patients. Of the 1,308 subjects exposed to an STD, the researchers documented some form of treatment for 678 subjects." Sex workers, "who in most cases were also intentionally infected with STDs, were used to transmit disease." Beyond the exposure experiments, the researchers drew blood and spinal fluid from 5,128 people for diagnostic testing, "including soldiers, prisoners, psychiatric patients, children, leprosy patients, and Air Force personnel at the U.S. base in Guatemala." The subjects in the exposure experiments ranged in age "from 10 to 72 years."

The commission recorded the deaths in the doctor's own files. "Dr. Cutler's contemporaneous records note 83 deaths during the course of the experiments. The exact relationship between the experimental procedures and the subject deaths is unclear." A summary the Centers for Disease Control had prepared the year before, from the same papers, counted "71 subjects" who "were noted to have died," and said "the records do not allow determination of the relationship of the deaths to study procedures."

How it was done

The commission described the methods in its own words, from the records. The plan was to use the central penitentiary, "where exposure of volunteers to infected prostitutes would provide the testing opportunities," and the report notes that sex work "was legal in Guatemala but not in the United States." When infection through contact proved slow, the report says, "the researchers began abrading the membranes of psychiatric subjects' penises to improve the syphilis transmission rate," a method the doctor later reported "achieved a 91.6-percent transmission rate." Seven women in the psychiatric hospital "were exposed to syphilis via cisternal puncture, the injection of syphilis into the spinal fluid from the back of the skull," a procedure the commission called "particularly dangerous because of its proximity to the brain stem." Two of those women developed headaches, one "lost the use of her legs for a period of time," and one who received penicillin "later died." The researchers also examined 1,384 Guatemalan children between the ages of one and eighteen, drawing blood and in some cases spinal fluid, with "no record that the children knew that they were a part of an experiment or had an individual parent or guardian consent on their behalf."

Who ran it

The work "led by Dr. Cutler took place from approximately July 1946 to December 1948, with follow-up work continuing through 1953." Its costs were borne by the Pan American Sanitary Bureau, the Public Health Service's Venereal Disease Division, and the government of Guatemala, with the federal share coming through a grant "issued from the Research Grants Office of the then U.S. National Institute of Health." The commission recorded that "Surgeon General Thomas Parran approved the grant," which was funded at $110,450, and it quoted a 1947 letter describing Parran's interest: "You know, we couldn't do such an experiment in this country." Guatemalan officials took part as well; the research staff "included leaders and senior medical personnel of the government of Guatemala." The doctor who ran it, John Cutler, went on during the 1950s and 1960s to become a lead researcher on the Public Health Service's syphilis study of Black men in Tuskegee, Alabama, and one of its defenders. He died in 2003.

The commission also found the men had known better. In 1943 and 1944 the same researchers and their superiors, testing a vaccine on prisoners at Terre Haute, Indiana, had required that participants be at least 21 and give written consent with "a thorough understanding of the purpose underlying the study and the possible risks involved." The commission's conclusion, in the letter that opened the report, was that "the Guatemala experiments involved gross violations of ethics as judged against both the standards of today and the researchers' own understanding of applicable contemporaneous practices." It found that the men "thought that they were above the rules, and went to some lengths to shield themselves from normal institutionally imposed scrutiny," quoting the doctor's own wish "to keep the work strictly in your hands," to "those who can be trusted not to talk."

How it came to light

The record stayed buried for sixty years. Cutler donated his papers to the University of Pittsburgh in 1990. A Wellesley College historian, Susan Reverby, found them there while researching the Tuskegee study, presented her findings in May 2010, and gave a copy of her paper to a former director of the CDC, who alerted the agency. In her published account she wrote that the Public Health Service "exposed their subjects through the use of infectious prostitutes or directly through inoculums made from tissue." The government reviewed the records, determined they were federal records, and transferred them to the National Archives in October 2010.

The apology, and the courts

On October 1, 2010 the Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, and the Secretary of Health and Human Services, Kathleen Sebelius, issued a joint statement: "The sexually transmitted disease inoculation study conducted from 1946-1948 in Guatemala was clearly unethical. Although these events occurred more than 64 years ago, we are outraged that such reprehensible research could have occurred under the guise of public health. We deeply regret that it happened, and we apologize to all the individuals who were affected by such abhorrent research practices." The same day President Obama telephoned President Alvaro Colom of Guatemala "to express his deep regret" and "to extend an apology to all those affected." Colom told reporters the study was "a crime against humanity."

The lawsuits did not reach the government. In Garcia v. Sebelius, Guatemalan victims and their heirs sued in Washington in 2011. On June 13, 2012 Judge Reggie Walton dismissed the case, holding that the claims "are thus barred by the FTCA's foreign country exception," so that "the United States's sovereign immunity remains intact and the Court consequently lacks subject matter jurisdiction." He wrote that "the Guatemala Study is a deeply troubling chapter in our Nation's history," that "this Court is powerless to provide any redress to the plaintiffs," and that "their pleas are more appropriately directed to the political branches of our government." A second suit, against Johns Hopkins University and the Rockefeller Foundation, ran for nine years and ended on March 20, 2024 when the Fourth Circuit affirmed judgment for the last defendant. One judge wrote that "it was our own government, not the Rockefeller Foundation, that was the driving force behind these monstrous wrongs."

What was paid

No compensation ever reached the subjects or their families. The presidential commission's second report, in December 2011, recommended that the government "study the issue of research-related injuries to determine if there is a need for a national system of compensation." In January 2012 the Department of Health and Human Services announced it would spend about $1.8 million, roughly $775,000 to fight sexually transmitted diseases in Guatemala and about $1 million to study new rules for protecting research volunteers. As one legal historian summarized the record, "no compensation was delivered to them in Guatemala." A Guatemalan vice president said in 2011 that investigators had found "three or four patients who are still alive."

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (10)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2010
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC Stacks). Under the on-site direction of John C. Cutler; 71 subjects noted to have died, the records not allowing determination of the relationship to study procedures; no indication the results were ever published.
2010
U.S. Department of State (2009-2017 archive). Clearly unethical; we are outraged that such reprehensible research could have occurred under the guise of public health; we deeply regret that it happened, and we apologize to all the individuals who were affected.
2010
The White House (Obama archive). President Obama expressed his deep regret and extended an apology to all those affected.
2011
Journal of Policy History (Cambridge University Press). Susan Reverby's paper from Cutler's papers at the University of Pittsburgh; the subjects exposed through infectious prostitutes or direct inoculums; she gave a copy to a former CDC director in 2010.
2011
National Archives and Records Administration. About 12,000 pages donated to the University of Pittsburgh in 1990, transferred to the federal government in 2010 after the CDC determined they were federal records.
2011
Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues (govinfo). 1,308 prisoners, soldiers, and psychiatric patients intentionally exposed, 678 documented as treated; 5,128 tested; 83 deaths recorded, the relationship to the procedures unclear; ages 10 to 72; abrasion and cisternal puncture; Cutler, Parran, and the NIH grant; gross violations of ethics known to the researchers at the time.
2011
Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues. Recommends the government study whether a national system of compensation or treatment for research-related injuries is needed; the swift apology described as an act of moral repair.
2012
The Washington Post. About $775,000 to fight sexually transmitted diseases in Guatemala and about $1 million to study rules for protecting research volunteers; no payment to the subjects or families.
2012
United States District Court for the District of Columbia, via govinfo. Claims barred by the Federal Tort Claims Act foreign country exception; the United States's sovereign immunity remains intact; this Court is powerless to provide any redress; the pleas are more appropriately directed to the political branches.
2024
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. Affirms judgment for the last private defendant; concurrence: it was our own government, not the Rockefeller Foundation, that was the driving force behind these monstrous wrongs.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2011
1946 to 2024
The United States Public Health Service, paid in part by a National Institute of Health grant and approved by the Surgeon General, deliberately infected 1,308 prisoners, soldiers, and psychiatric patients in Guatemala with syphilis, gonorrhea, and chancroid, and tested 5,128 more; only 678 of those exposed were documented as treated, and at least 83 subjects died. A presidential commission found the researchers knew it was wrong and worked to keep it quiet. Two cabinet secretaries and the President apologized in 2010, the courts held the government immune and the private defendants not liable, and no compensation ever reached the subjects or their families.
“The Guatemala experiments involved gross violations of ethics as judged against both the standards of today and the researchers' own understanding of applicable contemporaneous practices.”
The Public Health Service; the National Institute of Health; the Surgeon General. Violates: The plainest claim a person has, that the government will not use the body without consent.. Source: Ethically Impossible: STD Research in Guatemala from 1946 to 1948, Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues (govinfo)

Timeline Events (5)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

March 20, 2024
The last Guatemala suit ends; the appeals court affirms for the private defendant
It was our own government that was the driving force behind these monstrous wrongs.
June 13, 2012
Court dismisses the victims' suit: the United States is immune
This Court is powerless to provide any redress to the plaintiffs.
September 13, 2011
Presidential commission: gross violations of ethics, known to the researchers at the time
The men thought that they were above the rules.
October 1, 2010
Two cabinet secretaries apologize for the Guatemala experiments; Obama calls Guatemala's president
We are outraged that such reprehensible research could have occurred under the guise of public health.
1946 to 1948
U.S. Public Health Service doctors deliberately infect 1,308 people in Guatemala with syphilis, gonorrhea, and chancroid
Only 678 of those exposed were documented as treated; at least 83 subjects died.
The 1946–1948 US Public Health Service Experiments That Deliberately Infected 1,308 Guatemalans with Syphilis | Spirit of '76