2013 to 2019: The disclosures · Police, Courts & Prisons

Overloaded Public Defenders: How Indigent Defendants Get Less Than 14 Hours of Legal Work on a Felony

Period covered: 1963 to 2023 · 6 sources

Summary

In 1963 the Supreme Court ruled that a person too poor to hire a lawyer cannot be given a fair trial unless the state provides one. The right is real and the funding is not. A national standard set in 1973 said one defense lawyer should carry no more than 150 felonies a year; a 2007 federal survey found about three-quarters of county public defender offices took more than the recommended limit, and most had no power to say no. A 2023 study by the RAND Corporation and the American Bar Association found offices carrying 300 to 350 felonies per lawyer, which leaves under 14 hours for the average felony case. Missouri's system, ranked 49th in the country on spending, once tried to appoint the governor himself as a public defender to make the point. New Orleans put poor defendants on a waiting list for a lawyer. A defense that thin is one more reason the plea offer gets signed.

On March 18, 1963 the Supreme Court decided Gideon v. Wainwright. Clarence Earl Gideon had been tried for a break-in in Florida with no lawyer because he could not afford one, and had asked the court to appoint one and been refused. The Court ruled for him, and Justice Hugo Black wrote for a unanimous bench: "in our adversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel is provided for him. This seems to us to be an obvious truth." From then on, states had to provide a lawyer to a defendant who could not pay.

The load

The promise was that the poor would have a lawyer. It did not come with the money to make that lawyer able to do the work. In 1973 a national commission set a limit on how many cases one defense lawyer should carry in a year: no more than 150 felonies, or 400 misdemeanors. The standard has held as the benchmark for fifty years, and offices across the country blow past it. The Bureau of Justice Statistics, in a 2007 census of public defender offices, found that "about three-quarters (73%) of county-based public defender offices exceeded the maximum recommended limit of cases received per attorney in 2007." The same survey found that most offices could do nothing about it: "about 6 in 10 (59%) offices reported having neither caseload limits nor the authority to refuse cases." Those offices took in "more than 4 million cases" that year.

A 2023 study by the RAND Corporation, the American Bar Association, and the National Center for State Courts measured what those numbers mean case by case. It found that "excessive caseloads are pervasive in public defense, even when judged against the 1973 NAC standards," and gave an example: "in December 2022, the public defender office in St. Clair County, Illinois, reported caseloads of 350 felony cases per attorney per year." Even at the old 1973 limit, the study calculated, a lawyer working full time on cases all year would have "an average of only 13.9 hours to be spent by that attorney on each felony case." At 350 felonies, the time per case is a fraction of that. A case that a lawyer cannot investigate, whose witnesses the lawyer cannot interview, is a case that ends in a plea.

Missouri, ranked 49th

Missouri showed what the shortage does to a system. Its public defenders were carrying loads far above any standard, and in 2016 the director of the state public defender system, Michael Barrett, made the point in a way that could not be ignored. After the governor, Jay Nixon, vetoed a bill to cap public defender caseloads and repeatedly cut the office's budget, Barrett used a state law that let him assign counsel when no staff lawyer was available, and assigned the governor. He wrote to Nixon: "it strikes me that I should begin with the one attorney in the state who not only created this problem, but is in a unique position to address it." He noted that the state ranked "49th in the U.S." on indigent-defense spending, with a budget worth less than it had been in 2009. The Missouri Supreme Court had already been drawn into the caseload fight, ruling in 2009 in State ex rel. Missouri Public Defender Commission v. Pratte on when the office could decline cases it could not competently handle.

The waiting list in New Orleans

In January 2016 the American Civil Liberties Union sued the public defender's office in New Orleans and the Louisiana Public Defender Board because the office had begun placing new clients "on a waiting list for representation due to a shortage of public defenders." A person charged with a crime, presumed innocent, was told to wait for the lawyer the Constitution guarantees. As the ACLU's lawyer put it, "so long as you're on the public defender waiting list in New Orleans, you're helpless. Your legal defense erodes along with your constitutional rights." The suit reported that "at least three other parishes in Louisiana have waiting lists for public defenders." The case ended in 2018 after the state legislature moved money to clear the non-capital waitlists, and a federal appeals court dismissed it as moot, even as all parties agreed the waitlists had been unconstitutional while they lasted.

← 2013 to 2019

Primary Sources (6)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

1963
Supreme Court of the United States (U.S. Reports, via govinfo). In our adversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel is provided for him; this seems to us to be an obvious truth.
2009
Supreme Court of Missouri (CourtListener). The Missouri Supreme Court on when the public defender may decline cases it cannot competently handle given excessive caseloads.
2010
Bureau of Justice Statistics. About three-quarters, 73 percent, of county public defender offices exceeded the maximum recommended cases per attorney in 2007; about 6 in 10 had neither caseload limits nor the authority to refuse cases; more than 4 million cases received.
2016
American Civil Liberties Union. A class action over the Orleans Parish office placing new clients on a waiting list; so long as you are on the public defender waiting list in New Orleans, you are helpless; at least three other parishes had waiting lists.
2016
NBC News. Director Michael Barrett assigned Governor Jay Nixon to represent an indigent defendant; the one attorney in the state who not only created this problem but is in a unique position to address it; the state ranked 49th in indigent defense spending.
2023
RAND Corporation, American Bar Association, and National Center for State Courts. Excessive caseloads are pervasive; St. Clair County, Illinois reported 350 felony cases per attorney a year; even at the 1973 limit of 150, a lawyer would have 13.9 hours per felony case.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2016
1963 to 2023
The Supreme Court ruled in 1963 that the state must give a lawyer to a defendant too poor to hire one, and then left that lawyer without the money to do the work. A 1973 standard set 150 felonies a year as the most one defense lawyer should carry; a 2007 federal survey found about three-quarters of public defender offices took more than the limit, and most had no power to refuse. A 2023 study found offices carrying 300 to 350 felonies per lawyer, under 14 hours a case. Missouri, ranked 49th on spending, once assigned the governor to a case to prove the point, and New Orleans put poor defendants on a waiting list for counsel.
“Any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel is provided for him.”
The legislatures that fund indigent defense; a system that guarantees a lawyer but not the time to use one. Violates: The right to counsel the Supreme Court called an obvious truth in Gideon v. Wainwright.. Source: Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335 (1963), Supreme Court of the United States (U.S. Reports, via govinfo)

Timeline Events (4)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

2023
Study: public defender offices carry 300 to 350 felonies per lawyer
The 1973 standard was 150, and even that leaves under 14 hours a case.
August 4, 2016
Missouri's public defender assigns the governor to a case to protest the caseloads
The state ranked 49th in the country on indigent defense.
January 15, 2016
New Orleans puts poor defendants on a waiting list for a public defender
At least three other Louisiana parishes had waitlists too.
March 18, 1963
Supreme Court: a person too poor to hire a lawyer cannot get a fair trial unless the state provides one
Gideon v. Wainwright, decided unanimously.
Overloaded Public Defenders: How Indigent Defendants Get Less Than 14 Hours of Legal Work on a Felony | Spirit of '76