2020 to today · Police, Courts & Prisons

Three Men Cleared After 35 Years in Prison for a 1986 Chicago Fire Built on Beaten Confessions

Period covered: 1986 to 2026 · 6 sources

Summary

In 1986 a fire killed two brothers in a Chicago house, and three young men were convicted of setting it and sentenced to life. The case against them was confessions a police detective, Victor Switski, obtained, which the men said were beaten out of them and false. The confessions described starting the fire by throwing a lit cigarette into gasoline. In 2005 an episode of the television show MythBusters, and a later study by the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, showed that a lit cigarette cannot ignite gasoline. One of the men saw the episode in prison in 2007 and called his lawyer. At the hearing that followed, five other men testified that the same detective had beaten confessions out of them in unrelated cases, and a fire expert testified there was no valid scientific evidence the fire was arson. The three were released on July 13, 2022, after more than 35 years, and the city later agreed to pay $48 million.

In the early morning of September 21, 1986, a fire broke out at a house at 2603 West 24th Place in Chicago. Two brothers died in it, 19-year-old Julio Martinez and 28-year-old Guadalupe Martinez. Three young men were charged with first-degree murder and aggravated arson: John Galvan, who was 18, Arthur Almendarez, who was 19, and Francisco Nanez, who was 21. Galvan was tried alone and convicted on May 30, 1989, and sentenced to life in prison without parole. Almendarez and Nanez were tried together before separate juries and convicted on January 29, 1990, and each sentenced to life.

The confessions

There was no physical evidence connecting the three to the fire that held up. The case was built on statements a Chicago police detective, Victor Switski, took from them. Galvan, who was five feet two inches tall and weighed about a hundred pounds, said Switski pushed his head into a wall, kicked him, and punched the back of his head, and that he signed a statement he knew was false because he was told it was the only way home. Almendarez said Switski and another detective kicked him in the groin and struck him in the head, did not read him his rights, and denied his requests to call a lawyer or his family. Nanez said he was drunk and without his glasses, could not see what he was signing, and was not read his rights. The confession attributed to Galvan said the men soaked the house with gasoline and that Galvan started the fire by throwing a lit cigarette into it.

The impossible ignition

The detail that the fire was set with a cigarette dropped into gasoline is the detail that eventually undid the case, because it cannot happen. In 2005 the television program MythBusters, in an episode called "Hollywood on Trial," tried to ignite a pool of gasoline with a lit cigarette and could not. The federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives later published a study of the question. Its researchers ran "over 4,500 instances of exposure across 70 distinct tests involving 723 cigarettes," and reported "there were no instances of the ignition of gasoline vapors from the exposure of those vapors to a lit tobacco cigarette during any of the experiments." A lit cigarette is not hot enough at its surface, and the liquid cools it before it can ignite the vapor.

In 2007, about 21 years into his sentence, Galvan saw a rerun of the MythBusters episode on a prison television and reached out to his attorney, Tara Thompson.

The pattern, and the hearing

The case went back to court for an evidentiary hearing, where Galvan presented 23 witnesses over 14 days. Five men who had nothing to do with the fire testified that Detective Switski had done to them what the three said he did to them: handcuffed them to a wall, beaten them, and held them for days until they signed. One said Switski "slapped him and punched him several times over the course of the night"; another said two officers including Switski "handcuffed him to a wall" and beat him until he signed after two and a half days. Called to the stand himself, Switski, by then retired, "denied having any memory of the investigation of the case at bar or of taking confessions from petitioner, the testifying witnesses, or other pattern witnesses." A fire and explosion expert, Dr. Russell Ogle, testified that there was no valid scientific evidence the fire had been set, and that the burn-pattern methods used at the original trials had been repudiated by modern fire science.

The release

The Illinois Appellate Court reversed in 2019 and, after further proceedings, ruled in June 2022 that the men's convictions had been vacated and a new trial ordered. On July 13, 2022, the prosecution dismissed the charges against all three, and they were released, each having spent more than 35 years in custody since their arrest. In 2025 the Chicago City Council approved a $48 million settlement of their civil rights lawsuit, and in January 2026 all three were granted certificates of innocence.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (6)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2014
Fire Technology (Marcus and Geiman, Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives). Over 4,500 instances of exposure across 70 tests with 723 cigarettes; there were no instances of the ignition of gasoline vapors from the exposure of those vapors to a lit tobacco cigarette during any of the experiments.
2019
Illinois Appellate Court, First District. Records the 14-day evidentiary hearing, five pattern witnesses who said Detective Switski beat confessions out of them, Switski's testimony that he had no memory, and Dr. Russell Ogle's testimony that there was no valid evidence of arson.
2022
Innocence Project. Galvan saw the 2005 MythBusters episode Hollywood on Trial in prison in 2007 and contacted his attorney Tara Thompson.
2022
National Registry of Exonerations. Co-defendant; signed a statement he said he could not read without his glasses and was not read his rights; convicted January 29, 1990; released July 13, 2022.
2022
National Registry of Exonerations. The 1986 fire at 2603 W. 24th Place that killed Julio and Guadalupe Martinez; Galvan's coerced statement that he threw a lit cigarette to ignite the gasoline; Detective Victor Switski; released July 13, 2022 after more than 35 years.
2025
CBS News Chicago. The Chicago City Council's $48 million settlement of the three men's civil rights suit.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2022
1986 to 2022
Three Chicago men, John Galvan, Arthur Almendarez, and Francisco Nanez, spent more than 35 years in prison for a 1986 fire that killed two brothers, convicted on confessions a detective took that they said were beaten out of them. The confessions described starting the fire by throwing a lit cigarette into gasoline. A 2005 television episode and a federal study of over 4,500 tries showed a lit cigarette cannot ignite gasoline. At the hearing, five other men testified the same detective had beaten confessions out of them, and a fire expert found no valid evidence of arson. The three were freed on July 13, 2022, and Chicago agreed to pay them $48 million.
“There were no instances of the ignition of gasoline vapors from the exposure of those vapors to a lit tobacco cigarette during any of the experiments.”
The Chicago Police detective who took the confessions; the courts that took 35 years to undo them. Violates: Convictions built on coerced confessions to a fire that could not have started the way they described.. Source: The Propensity of Lit Cigarettes to Ignite Gasoline Vapors, Fire Technology (Marcus and Geiman, Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives)

Timeline Events (3)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

May 15, 2025
Chicago agrees to pay $48 million to the three men convicted on the impossible confession
The detective who took it had a documented pattern.
July 13, 2022
Three Chicago men freed after 35 years; the fire could not have started as they confessed
The confession said a lit cigarette lit a pool of gasoline, which cannot happen.
2014
Federal fire study: a lit cigarette did not ignite gasoline in over 4,500 tries
The method the Chicago confession described.
Three Men Cleared After 35 Years in Prison for a 1986 Chicago Fire Built on Beaten Confessions | Spirit of '76