2013 to 2019: The disclosures · Taxes & Government Spending

How the IRS Targeted Tea Party, Patriot, and Occupy Groups Applying for Tax-Exempt Status

Period covered: 2010 to 2018 · 11 sources

Summary

Between 2010 and 2013 the Internal Revenue Service pulled aside applications for tax-exempt status using the words in the group's name and the positions it took. A 2013 report by the Treasury's own inspector general found the agency flagged applications with Tea Party, Patriots, or 9/12 in their names, held 160 of them open from 206 to 1,138 days, and asked 27 groups for their donor lists it later agreed it should not have requested. A 2017 report found the agency had also flagged names like Progressive, Occupy, and ACORN Successors. A bipartisan Senate report and the Justice Department both concluded the delays were mismanagement, and the department found no evidence that any official acted from a political motive that would support a prosecution. No one was charged. The IRS apologized and paid $3.5 million to settle one class action.

On May 14, 2013 the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration issued a report titled Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review. Its finding: "The IRS used inappropriate criteria that identified for review Tea Party and other organizations applying for tax-exempt status based upon their names or policy positions instead of indications of potential political campaign intervention." A unit in Cincinnati began building a spreadsheet it called the Be On the Look Out listing in May 2010, and by August 2010 the first formal version told specialists to watch for "various local organizations in the Tea Party movement" applying under sections 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4) of the tax code. By June 2011 the written criteria included whether "Tea Party, Patriots or 9/12 Project is referenced in the case file," whether the group's issues included "government spending, government debt or taxes," and whether there was a "statement in the case file criticize how the country is being run," as the report quoted it.

The inspector general counted the applications the specialists set aside. As of May 31, 2012 there were 298 of them: 72 with Tea Party in the name, 13 with Patriots, 11 with 9/12, and 202 others. Of the 296 with complete files, the review found no sign of significant political campaign activity in 91. The delays were long. As of December 17, 2012, 160 of the applications were still open, from 206 to 1,138 days, "some for more than three years and crossing two election cycles," and the report found that "no work was completed on the majority of these applications for 13 months." The agency also asked questions it did not need to ask. It "requested donor information from 27 organizations that it would be required to make public if the application was approved," and a later review found the agency decided "to destroy all donor lists that were sent in for potential political cases that the IRS determined it should not have requested."

What the official said, and did not say

On May 10, 2013, four days before the report came out, Lois Lerner, who ran the IRS division that handled the applications, answered a question at a bar association meeting that she had arranged in advance to be asked. She said the specialists "used names like Tea Party, or Patriots" and "selected cases simply because the application had those names in the title," and that "that was wrong, that was absolutely incorrect, it was insensitive, and it was inappropriate." The acting commissioner later confirmed to Congress that the question had been "a prepared Q&A."

On May 22, 2013 Lerner appeared before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, read a statement that "I have not done anything wrong. I have not broken any laws," and then said: "I've been advised by my counsel to assert my constitutional right not to testify or answer questions related to the subject matter of this hearing." On May 7, 2014 the House voted 231 to 187 to hold her in contempt of Congress. On March 31, 2015 the United States Attorney for the District of Columbia, Ronald Machen, wrote to the Speaker that his office would "not bring the Congressional contempt citation before a grand jury," because his team had concluded Lerner "did not waive her Fifth Amendment privilege by making an opening statement," which "would provide Ms. Lerner with an absolute defense should she be prosecuted." She had been placed on administrative leave in May 2013 and retired that September after an internal board found "neglect of duties" and moved to remove her, a finding the same release said included no finding of "political bias or willful misconduct."

What the investigations concluded

Two investigations reached the same place. On August 5, 2015 the Senate Finance Committee released a bipartisan report. Its chairman, Orrin Hatch, said the investigation "shows gross mismanagement at the highest levels of the IRS." Its ranking member, Ron Wyden, said the results "showcase pure bureaucratic mismanagement without any evidence of political interference." The report also documented that a year of the investigation was lost after the IRS disclosed that many of Lerner's emails were gone when her hard drive crashed in 2011, and that in March 2014, after officials knew the emails were missing, IRS employees in West Virginia "magnetically erased 422 backup tapes that are believed to have contained Lerner's emails." The inspector general's investigators testified that they found no evidence "the erasure was done in furtherance of an effort to destroy evidence," and that the employees appeared not to have followed a directive to preserve the tapes, and they recovered more than a thousand emails the IRS had not produced.

On October 23, 2015 the Justice Department closed its criminal investigation. Its letter to Congress said the investigation "uncovered substantial evidence of mismanagement, poor judgment, and institutional inertia," and then: "But poor management is not a crime. We found no evidence that any IRS official acted based on political, discriminatory, corrupt, or other inappropriate motives that would support a criminal prosecution." It also reported that "according to an analysis by the FBI, nearly 70 percent of the applications coordinated for review were submitted by right-leaning groups."

The other names

On September 28, 2017 the inspector general issued a second report, this one a "historical account" of the criteria the IRS had used. It found that "from August 2004 through June 2013, the IRS potentially used 259 criteria to identify tax-exempt applications for further review," most of which, in the report's words, "involved issues besides political campaign intervention, such as potential fraud, abuse, and links to terrorism." Among the political ones, the names were not only conservative. The report examined seventeen criteria and listed them: they included Progressive, Occupy, ACORN Successors, Emerge, Medical Marijuana, Green Energy, Healthcare Legislation, and Paying National Debt. The IRS had flagged 61 cases under the Progressive criterion, which it used in various forms "from October 2005 through April 2013." The report noted that when the unit began pulling political cases in 2010, "the Tea Party case coordinators did not accept 'progressive' cases for review," and sent them back to general inventory instead.

The apology and the settlements

On October 26, 2017 the Justice Department settled two lawsuits by groups that had been flagged. Attorney General Jeff Sessions said the criteria "included names such as 'Tea Party,' 'Patriots,' or '9/12' or policy positions," that "the IRS's use of these criteria as a basis for heightened scrutiny was wrong and should never have occurred," and that the affected groups "deserve an apology from the IRS." In the first case, Linchpins of Liberty, the consent order the court entered had the IRS state that its treatment of the plaintiffs, "including screening their applications based on their names or policy positions, subjecting those applications to heightened scrutiny and inordinate delays, and demanding of some Plaintiffs' information that TIGTA determined was unnecessary," was "wrong," and that "the IRS expresses its sincere apology." In the second, NorCal Tea Party Patriots, a class of more than 400 groups released its claims for a payment of $3,500,000 from the United States, approved on August 8, 2018. One of the plaintiff groups, the Albuquerque Tea Party, did not receive its final approval "until June of 2017, over seven years after filing its application."

← 2013 to 2019

Primary Sources (11)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2013
Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (hosted at oversight.gov). The IRS used inappropriate criteria that identified for review Tea Party and other organizations based upon their names or policy positions; the Be On the Look Out listing; 298 applications set aside, 72 Tea Party, 13 Patriots, 11 9/12; 160 open from 206 to 1,138 days; donor lists requested from 27 groups and later destroyed.
2013
House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, via govinfo. Lois Lerner: I have not done anything wrong, I have not broken any laws; then invokes her constitutional right not to testify.
2014
Clerk of the U.S. House of Representatives. The House holds Lois Lerner in contempt of Congress, 231 to 187.
2015
U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Columbia (DocumentCloud copy via NPR). Lerner did not waive her Fifth Amendment privilege by making an opening statement; the office will not bring the citation before a grand jury.
2015
Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (hosted by House Oversight). 422 of 424 backup tapes degaussed on or about March 4, 2014, one month after the IRS realized it was missing emails; no evidence the erasure was done to destroy evidence; over 1,000 emails recovered.
2015
U.S. Senate Committee on Finance. Bipartisan; Hatch: gross mismanagement at the highest levels; Wyden: pure bureaucratic mismanagement without any evidence of political interference; 422 backup tapes believed to hold Lerner's emails magnetically erased in March 2014.
2015
U.S. Department of Justice (hosted by House Oversight Democrats). Substantial evidence of mismanagement, poor judgment, and institutional inertia; but poor management is not a crime; no evidence that any IRS official acted based on political, discriminatory, corrupt, or other inappropriate motives; nearly 70 percent of the applications coordinated for review were from right-leaning groups.
2017
Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (hosted at oversight.gov). From August 2004 through June 2013 the IRS potentially used 259 criteria; the seventeen examined included Progressive, Occupy, ACORN Successors, Emerge, and Medical Marijuana; 61 cases pulled under the Progressive criterion; the Tea Party coordinators did not accept progressive cases for review.
2017
United States District Court for the District of Columbia (copy hosted by the American Center for Law and Justice). The IRS admits its treatment, including screening by names or policy positions, heightened scrutiny, inordinate delays, and unnecessary demands, was wrong, and expresses its sincere apology; the Albuquerque Tea Party got its status over seven years after applying.
2017
U.S. Department of Justice. The IRS's use of these criteria as a basis for heightened scrutiny was wrong and should never have occurred; Linchpins of Liberty 41 plaintiffs, NorCal a class of 428; the groups deserve an apology from the IRS.
2018
United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, via govinfo. A class of more than 400 groups; the $3,500,000 settlement approved August 8, 2018; the litigation funded by Citizens for Self Governance.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2015
2010 to 2018
The Internal Revenue Service flagged applications for tax-exempt status by the words in the group's name and the positions it took, held 160 of them open from 206 to 1,138 days, and asked 27 groups for donor lists it later agreed it should not have requested and then destroyed. Its inspector general documented the criteria, first for Tea Party, Patriots, and 9/12 names and later for Progressive, Occupy, and ACORN Successors names. A bipartisan Senate report and the Justice Department both found mismanagement and no provable political motive, no one was prosecuted, and the agency apologized under a court order and paid one class of more than 400 groups $3.5 million.
“The IRS used inappropriate criteria that identified for review Tea Party and other organizations applying for tax-exempt status based upon their names or policy positions.”
The Internal Revenue Service; the Treasury and Justice Department reviewers who found no crime. Violates: The even hand the tax law owes every applicant, whatever its name or view.. Source: Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review (Ref. 2013-10-053), Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (hosted at oversight.gov)

Timeline Events (6)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

October 26, 2017
The IRS apologizes and settles; a class of more than 400 groups is paid $3.5 million
Its treatment was wrong and should never have occurred.
September 28, 2017
Inspector general: the IRS also flagged names like Progressive, Occupy, and ACORN Successors
61 cases pulled under the Progressive criterion.
October 23, 2015
Justice Department closes the IRS case: mismanagement, but poor management is not a crime
No evidence any official acted from a political motive; no charges.
August 5, 2015
Bipartisan Senate report: gross mismanagement, no evidence of political interference
422 backup tapes believed to hold Lerner's emails were erased in March 2014.
May 22, 2013
Lois Lerner invokes the Fifth Amendment before the House after saying she broke no laws
The House votes her in contempt a year later, 231 to 187.
May 14, 2013
Treasury inspector general: the IRS flagged Tea Party and other applications by name and viewpoint
298 applications set aside; some held more than three years; donor lists requested and later destroyed.
How the IRS Targeted Tea Party, Patriot, and Occupy Groups Applying for Tax-Exempt Status | Spirit of '76