2020 to today · Taxes & Government Spending

How the 2006 Retiree Prefunding Law and 2021 Delivery Cuts Damaged the US Postal Service

Period covered: 2006 to 2026 · 23 sources

Summary

In 2006 Congress passed a law, without a recorded vote in either chamber, that made the Postal Service set aside more than $5 billion a year to prefund the health benefits of retirees who had not yet retired, a burden no other agency carries. The payments drove most of the reported losses that followed, and in 2022 Congress repealed the mandate and canceled about $57 billion in missed payments. By then the service was slower and dearer. A 2021 plan lengthened first-class delivery from one to three days to one to five, the price of a stamp rose from 55 cents in 2019 to 82 cents in July 2026, and a 2025 change added a day to mail sent from any post office more than 50 miles from a regional hub, which the regulator found would fall hardest on rural areas. The service lost $9.5 billion in fiscal 2024 and $9.0 billion in fiscal 2025, and in April 2026 it stopped paying into its pension fund to keep cash on hand.

The Postal Service is written into the Constitution, which gives Congress the power "to establish Post Offices and post Roads." It is meant to pay for itself out of postage, not taxes.

The mandate

On December 20, 2006 Congress enacted the Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act, Public Law 109-435. Its Title VIII required the Postal Service to prefund the health benefits of its future retirees, paying more than $5 billion into a fund each year from 2007 through 2016, from $5.4 billion in the first year to $5.8 billion in the last. No other federal agency and few private companies fund retiree health decades ahead this way. The law moved through a lame-duck session and cleared both the House and the Senate without a recorded roll-call vote in either chamber.

The payments became most of the losses. The Government Accountability Office, describing the argument in a 2012 report, wrote that the Postal Service and others "have argued that the prefunding requirement is a major contributor to USPS's financial decline, contributing $32 billion towards its $41 billion of net losses over the past 6 years." The service stopped making the full payments, and the unpaid balance grew.

The repeal

On April 6, 2022 Congress reversed the mandate. The Postal Service Reform Act, Public Law 117-108, canceled the unpaid prefunding: "Any payment required from the Postal Service under section 8909a of title 5, United States Code, as in effect on the day before the date of enactment of this Act that remains unpaid as of such date of enactment is canceled." That erased about $57 billion in obligations, which the service booked as "a one-time, non-cash benefit of $57.0 billion to net income" and which turned fiscal 2022 into a reported $56 billion gain. The law also required most new retirees to enroll in Medicare, wrote six-day delivery into statute, and ordered a public performance dashboard. This one had recorded votes, and both parties supplied them: the House passed it 342 to 92 on February 8, 2022, and the Senate 79 to 19 on March 8, 2022.

Slower, and dearer

The service the public used had already begun to change. In 2020 the incoming Postmaster General, Louis DeJoy, made operational changes that summer, and court records later showed the agency removed 711 mail-sorting machines that year, about double the usual number. Mail slowed; the inspector general found on-time delivery of single-piece first-class mail "declined from 90.1 to 79.7" percent over July and August. On August 18, 2020 DeJoy suspended the changes "to avoid even the appearance of any impact on election mail." On September 17, 2020 a federal judge in Washington State, Stanley Bastian, blocked the changes; from the bench he called them, as CBS News reported, "a politically motivated attack on the efficiency of the Postal Service," and his written order pointed to "voter disenfranchisement."

In March 2021 DeJoy released a ten-year plan, Delivering for America, meant to "reverse a projected $160 billion in losses over 10 years." Under it, effective October 1, 2021, the standard for first-class mail within the contiguous states widened from one to three days to one to five. The Postal Regulatory Commission, in its advisory opinion, said it "is concerned that the Postal Service did not conduct any operational or pilot testing," and that "it is not clear that the tradeoff between financial viability and maintaining high-quality service standards is reasonable." The price rose alongside. A first-class stamp cost 55 cents in 2019, and by the schedule of increases that followed it reached 58 cents in 2021, 63 cents in 2023, 73 cents in 2024, 78 cents in 2025, and 82 cents on July 12, 2026. When the plan consolidated processing into regional centers, service fell where the centers opened. The inspector general found that after the Atlanta center launched in early 2024, "the percent of First-Class Mail delivered on-time dropped to a low of 36 percent before rebounding to about 80 percent in early June."

The extra day for rural mail

A further change in 2025 lengthened delivery for mail that starts far from a hub. Under a rule effective April 1, 2025, the Postal Service designates a ZIP code for "regional transportation optimization" when the post office serving it "is more than 50 miles from the originating Regional Processing and Distribution Center," and mail from those offices gets an added service day. The Postal Regulatory Commission, in its January 2025 advisory opinion, found that "rural communities will experience disproportionate negative service standard impacts" and that "49.5 percent of ZIP Code pairs will have downgraded service" for single-piece first-class mail. It added that the projected savings, "even if fully realized, represent approximately 4.4 percent of the Postal Service's FY 2024 operating expenses," and warned that "these changes must not come at the expense of the Postal Service's core mission."

Where it stands

The repeal of the mandate did not end the losses. The service reported a net loss of $9.5 billion in fiscal 2024, its largest since 2012, and $9.0 billion in fiscal 2025. DeJoy resigned on March 24, 2025, after signing an agreement that month to let the Department of Government Efficiency assist on several initiatives, and David Steiner, a former FedEx director and Waste Management chief executive, took over in July 2025 and told employees he does not "believe that the Postal Service should be privatized." Earlier that year the President had said at a February 2025 event that the post office might become "a form of a merger" with the Commerce Department, though no order followed. In December 2025 the Government Accountability Office reported the service had "accumulated approximately $118 billion in net losses since fiscal year 2006," that its unfunded liabilities and debt had reached "$163.7 billion," and that it "projects potential cash depletion by fiscal year 2026 if making full pension payments, or 2029 with partial payments." In April 2026 the service stopped making its biweekly pension contributions, about $200 million a pay period, to keep cash for operations.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (23)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2006
U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo). Enacted December 20, 2006; Title VIII creates the Postal Service Retiree Health Benefits Fund and the prefunding schedule of more than $5 billion a year from 2007 through 2016; cleared both chambers without a recorded roll-call vote.
2012
U.S. Government Accountability Office. The Postal Service and others have argued the prefunding requirement is a major contributor to its financial decline, contributing $32 billion toward its $41 billion of net losses over the past 6 years.
2020
U.S. Postal Service. To avoid even the appearance of any impact on election mail, I am suspending these initiatives until after the election is concluded.
2020
The Hill. A court filing showed USPS removed 711 mail-sorting machines in 2020, about double the usual number; removals ordered stopped August 18, 2020.
2020
Office of the Washington State Attorney General. The preliminary injunction in State of Washington v. Trump; the written order points to voter disenfranchisement and an intentional effort to disrupt the elections.
2020
CBS News. Judge Stanley Bastian called the changes a politically motivated attack on the efficiency of the Postal Service from the bench; a written order followed the same day.
2020
U.S. Postal Service Office of Inspector General. On-time delivery of single-piece first-class mail declined from 90.1 to 79.7 percent; delayed mail at processing facilities rose 21 percent over July 2020.
2021
U.S. Postal Service. The plan to reverse a projected $160 billion in losses over 10 years by reaching break-even while changing service.
2021
Postal Regulatory Commission. First-class mail widened from 1 to 3 days to 1 to 5 days on October 1, 2021; the Commission is concerned the Postal Service did not conduct any operational or pilot testing, and it is not clear the tradeoff is reasonable.
2022
Clerk of the U.S. House of Representatives. The House passes the Postal Service Reform Act 342 to 92; Democrats 222 to 0, Republicans 120 to 92.
2022
United States Senate. The Senate passes the Postal Service Reform Act 79 to 19.
2022
U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo). Any payment required under section 8909a that remains unpaid is canceled; requires most new retirees to enroll in Medicare; writes six-day delivery into law; orders a public performance dashboard.
2024
U.S. Postal Service Office of Inspector General. After the Atlanta center launched in early 2024, the percent of first-class mail delivered on time dropped to a low of 36 percent before rebounding to about 80 percent in early June.
2025
Postal Regulatory Commission. Rural communities will experience disproportionate negative service standard impacts; 49.5 percent of ZIP code pairs will have downgraded single-piece first-class service; the savings represent about 4.4 percent of operating expenses; the changes must not come at the expense of the core mission.
2025
NBC Los Angeles. At a February 21, 2025 event the President said the post office could become a form of a merger with the Commerce Department while remaining the Postal Service; no executive order was signed.
2025
U.S. Postal Service. Describes the March 13, 2025 agreement authorizing the DOGE team to assist on seven initiatives; only the data required will be provided; the Postal Service remains an independent establishment of the executive branch.
2025
U.S. Postal Service. Louis DeJoy informs the Board of Governors that his last day is that day, after nearly five years as the 75th postmaster general.
2025
U.S. Postal Service (Federal Register, via govinfo). Effective April 1, 2025; the Postal Service designates a ZIP code for regional transportation optimization when its post office is more than 50 miles from the originating Regional Processing and Distribution Center, adding a service day.
2025
NPR. Steiner, a former FedEx director and Waste Management chief executive, took office in July 2025 and told employees he does not believe the Postal Service should be privatized.
2025
U.S. Postal Service. A net loss of $9.0 billion for the year under generally accepted accounting principles, compared to $9.5 billion the prior year.
2025
U.S. Government Accountability Office. Approximately $118 billion in net losses since fiscal 2006; unfunded liabilities and debt of $163.7 billion, 206 percent of annual revenue; projects potential cash depletion by fiscal 2026 with full pension payments, or 2029 with partial payments.
2026
Federal News Network. In April 2026 the Postal Service suspended its biweekly FERS pension contributions, about $200 million a pay period, to conserve cash; the CFO said the liquidity risk outweighed the longer-term pension risk.
2026
U.S. Postal Service. The first-class stamp: 55 cents in 2019, 58 in 2021, 60 in 2022, 63 and 66 in 2023, 68 and 73 in 2024, 78 in July 2025, 82 in July 2026.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2025
2006 to 2026
Congress made the Postal Service prefund its retirees' health benefits at more than $5 billion a year in a 2006 law passed without a recorded vote, a burden no other agency carries, and the payments drove most of the losses that followed. Congress repealed the mandate in 2022 and canceled about $57 billion in missed payments, but by then the service was slower and dearer: first-class delivery stretched from one to three days to one to five, the stamp rose from 55 cents to 82, and a 2025 change added a day to mail from any office more than 50 miles from a hub. The service lost $9.0 billion in fiscal 2025 and stopped paying into its pension fund in April 2026 to keep cash.
“Accumulated approximately $118 billion in net losses since fiscal year 2006.”
Congress; the Postal Service's own management. Violates: A self-funded public service that reaches every address, loaded with a mandate no one else carries.. Source: U.S. Postal Service: Action Needed to Fix Unsustainable Business Model (GAO-26-107336), U.S. Government Accountability Office

Timeline Events (5)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

December 16, 2025
GAO: $118 billion in postal losses since 2006, with cash possibly gone in 2026
The stamp had reached 78 cents, on the way to 82.
January 31, 2025
Postal regulator: the 2025 standards will downgrade service for half of ZIP code pairs, worst for rural areas
Mail more than 50 miles from a hub gets an added day.
April 6, 2022
Congress repeals the prefunding mandate and cancels about $57 billion in missed payments
House 342 to 92, Senate 79 to 19.
September 17, 2020
A federal judge blocks the 2020 mail changes; from the bench he calls them a politically motivated attack
On-time first-class mail had dropped from 90 to 80 percent.
December 20, 2006
Congress makes the Postal Service prefund retiree health at more than $5 billion a year, without a recorded vote
A burden no other agency carries.
How the 2006 Retiree Prefunding Law and 2021 Delivery Cuts Damaged the US Postal Service | Spirit of '76