2020 to today · Taxes & Government Spending

Clay County, Florida Residents Challenge New Stormwater Property Tax

Period covered: July 2026 · 3 sources

Summary

In July 2026 the Clay County, Florida commission approved a new stormwater assessment on every developed property in the unincorporated county, $51 to $161.50 a year, to show up on tax bills in November. At the public hearing, residents who maintain their own ditches read the ordinance aloud and asked the board what they were being charged for.

Clay County sits south of Jacksonville, Florida. In 2026 its Board of County Commissioners took up a stormwater assessment for the unincorporated parts of the county, a fee separate from property taxes, to pay for drainage maintenance, ditch cleaning, pipe and culvert repair, pond maintenance, and flood control. The board approved it as Ordinance 2026-33 on July 28, 2026. It takes effect October 1, 2026 and appears for the first time on the tax bills mailed in November. A single family home pays $51, $85, or $161.50 a year depending on how much of the lot is covered by roof and pavement. Commercial property pays $85 per unit. The ordinance allows the rate to rise to $120 per unit without a new round of public notice. The four towns inside the county, Orange Park, Green Cove Springs, Keystone Heights, and Penney Farms, are not covered.

At the public hearing on the assessment, residents who maintain their own drainage ditches put their objections on the record.

The first speaker

The first speaker said what he wanted to say had been said better in 1867, and read from Lysander Spooner. The passage begins with the theory of the Constitution, that all taxes are paid voluntarily and that government is a mutual insurance company the people enter into with each other, and says the practice is different. The government, Spooner wrote, says to a man, your money or your life, and most taxes are paid under that threat. The highwayman at least takes responsibility for his own act. He does not claim a rightful title to your money, does not pretend he is taking it for your benefit, does not call himself your protector, and does not follow you down the road afterward claiming to be your sovereign, telling you what to do, taking more when it suits him, and calling you a traitor if you resist. The passage ends with the line that the robber, unlike the government, does not try to make you either his dupe or his slave.

The second speaker

The next resident said he had moved to the county less than a year earlier and, like many of the elderly and many of his fellow veterans in the room, had received the notice of the assessment. His was addressed to someone else. If his kids had not torn open the mail by accident he would never have known it existed. He asked what happens when the county puts a lien on his house for not paying something that never came to him in his name.

Then he read the ordinance. Article 1, Section 20-1, subparagraph D, gives the intent: the money funds things that help the property, managing heavy rain by maintaining storm drains, clearing ditches, and building retention ponds. He said he does that himself. He works away from home during the week so his wife and kids do not have to work, comes home on weekends, and had left work early to come to the meeting. He maintains his own ditches. He and his 70 year old neighbor maintain the road together, because it is the right thing to do. He read Section 20-5: increased safety and improved access to developed property through the management of stormwater on public rights of way, roadways, and other public infrastructure, and the alleviation of the burdens caused by stormwater runoff, including flood control. He said the only time he had seen the county on his road was to pull a utility truck out of the culvert, and the county did not repair the damage that did.

He asked the board where he should send his invoice for taking care of the county's ditches. He said he had already paid taxes on the property when he bought the house, and asked whether the county meant to charge him for what God puts on the earth.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (3)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2026
Clay County, Florida. The county's own description of the fee, who pays, and what it funds.
2026
Clay Views. Ordinance 2026-33, approved July 28, 2026: the rates, the effective date, and the rate ceiling.

Documented Records (3)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2026
July 2026
Another resident read a passage by Lysander Spooner from 1867 comparing taxation under threat of penalty to robbery, and noting that a robber does not claim to be acting for the victim's benefit.
“The fact is that the government, like a highwayman, says to a man, your money or your life, and many, if not most taxes are paid under the compulsion of that threat.”
Clay County board. Violates: Consent of the governed. Source: "Where Do I Send That Invoice?" Clay County Residents Challenge Taxes & Stormwater Assessment, Municipal Minutes
July 2026
A Clay County resident who maintains his own ditches and helps his neighbor maintain their road received a stormwater assessment issued under someone else's name. He read the ordinance to the board, which says the fee pays for storm drains, ditches, and retention ponds, and said he was already doing that work. He said the county's only visit had been to remove a truck from a culvert, and the damage from that was not repaired.
“Apparently, by the way this looks, I should be charging you for taking care of my own ditches. So where do I send that invoice?”
Clay County board. Violates: Payment required for services not provided. Source: "Where Do I Send That Invoice?" Clay County Residents Challenge Taxes & Stormwater Assessment, Municipal Minutes
July 28, 2026
The Clay County, Florida Board of County Commissioners approved Ordinance 2026-33, a stormwater assessment on developed property in the unincorporated county: $51, $85, or $161.50 a year for a home depending on its impervious surface, $85 per unit for commercial property, effective October 1, 2026 and appearing on the November tax bills as a non-ad valorem assessment. The ordinance allows the rate to rise to $120 per unit without new public notice.
Clay County Board of County Commissioners. Violates: None in law. Listed for what the residents at the hearing were charged for.. Source: New Stormwater Tax For Unincorporated Clay County: How Much Will You Pay?, Clay Views

Timeline Events (1)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

July 28, 2026
Clay County approves a stormwater assessment on every developed property
$51 to $161.50 a year per home, on tax bills from November. Residents at the hearing read the ordinance back to the board.
Clay County, Florida Residents Challenge New Stormwater Property Tax | Spirit of '76