2001 to 2012: After September 11 · Housing & Private Equity

Kelo v. New London: Eminent Domain to Seize Private Homes for Corporations and Pipelines

Period covered: 2005 to 2026 · 7 sources

Summary

In 2005 the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 that a city could take homes from their owners and give the land to a private developer because the new use would pay more taxes. The homes in New London were demolished, the developer never built, Pfizer left, and the lot stood empty for nearly twenty years. Forty seven states changed their laws in response. The power has since moved to pipelines and power lines, where a federal certificate lets a private company condemn land across state lines, and where Congress in 2023 ordered one pipeline approved and barred the courts from reviewing it.

The Fifth Amendment ends with twelve words: nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation. For most of the country's history public use meant a road, a canal, a courthouse, a rail line, something the public would use. The question in Kelo v. City of New London was whether it also meant a private developer's project that a city expected to produce more tax revenue than the homes it replaced.

New London

In 1998 Pfizer built a $270 million research facility in New London, Connecticut. The city's development corporation drew up a plan for the Fort Trumbull neighborhood next to it: a hotel, offices, upscale housing, and a marina, to be built by a private developer on land the city would assemble. Most owners sold. Seven did not, among them Susette Kelo, a nurse who had bought a small pink house on the water in 1997, and Wilhelmina Dery, who had been born in her house in 1918 and had lived there since. The city condemned the homes. The Connecticut Supreme Court upheld the takings 4 to 3, and the case went to Washington.

On June 23, 2005 the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 for the city. Justice Stevens wrote that economic development is a public purpose, and that the court would not second guess the city's judgment that the plan would create jobs and tax revenue. Justice O'Connor's dissent said that under the ruling the specter of condemnation hangs over all property, and that nothing is to prevent the state from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz Carlton, any home with a shopping mall, or any farm with a factory. Justice Thomas wrote separately that something has gone seriously awry with this court's interpretation of the Constitution.

The homes were demolished. The developer never built. Pfizer announced in 2009 that it would leave New London, as the tax break it had received was expiring. The Institute for Justice, which represented the owners, puts the public money spent on the project at more than $80 million, and records that the Fort Trumbull land stood as a vacant lot for nearly twenty years after the demolition, until a developer put up 100 apartments and a hotel in 2022. Susette Kelo's house was moved to a lot downtown.

The ruling produced a wave of state law reform. By the institute's count, 47 states strengthened their eminent domain laws afterward, 12 of them by constitutional amendment, and 11 state supreme courts either tightened their own standards or rejected the reasoning of Kelo under their state constitutions. The federal rule is unchanged. Kelo is still the law.

Pipelines

The power to take land for a private company did not go away. It moved to energy. Under the Natural Gas Act, a company that obtains a certificate from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for an interstate pipeline gets with it the federal power of eminent domain over every parcel on the route. In PennEast Pipeline Company v. New Jersey, decided June 29, 2021, the Supreme Court held 5 to 4 that this delegated power reaches even land owned by a state that objects. The certificate is issued by five commissioners in Washington. The land is taken by a private company. The owner gets a hearing on the price and nothing else.

In 2023 Congress went further. The Mountain Valley Pipeline, 303 miles through West Virginia and Virginia, had been stopped repeatedly by the federal appeals court in Richmond, which found its permits deficient. Section 324 of the Fiscal Responsibility Act, the debt ceiling law signed June 3, 2023, ratified every permit the pipeline needed, directed the agencies to issue any that remained, and provided that no court shall have jurisdiction to review them. The land had already been condemned. The law removed the last place the owners could be heard.

South Dakota and Iowa

The carbon pipelines proposed across the Midwest, to carry carbon dioxide from ethanol plants to underground storage in North Dakota, brought the question to farm country. Summit Carbon Solutions planned about $9 billion of pipe across five states and sought eminent domain against the landowners who would not sign. On March 6, 2025 the governor of South Dakota signed House Bill 1052, which prohibits the use of eminent domain for a pipeline carrying carbon dioxide.

I don't just care about landowners. I am a landowner.Governor Larry Rhoden, March 6, 2025

On April 22, 2025 the state's Public Utilities Commission denied Summit's second permit application.

Iowa's legislature passed a similar bill, House File 639, by 85 to 10 in the House and 27 to 22 in the Senate. In June 2025 the governor vetoed it, saying it went much further than eminent domain and set a troubling precedent that threatened Iowa's energy reliability, economy, and reputation as a place where businesses can invest with confidence. Summit had, by then, signed voluntary easements with more than 1,300 Iowa landowners and paid $175 million for them. The ones who had not signed were left where Kelo left Susette Kelo.

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (7)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Institute for Justice. The owners, the plan, the $80 million, the vacant lot, and the 47 states that changed their laws.
2005
Supreme Court of the United States. 5 to 4: economic development is a public use. O'Connor and Thomas dissenting.
2021
Supreme Court of the United States. 5 to 4: a private pipeline company holding a federal certificate may condemn land owned by a state.
2023
Congress.gov. Ratifies every permit for the Mountain Valley Pipeline and provides that no court shall have jurisdiction to review them.
2025
Iowa Capital Dispatch. House Bill 1052 signed by Governor Larry Rhoden; Summit's $9 billion, five state pipeline.
2025
South Dakota Public Broadcasting. The commission's second denial.
2025
N'West Iowa REVIEW. House File 639, passed 85 to 10 and 27 to 22, vetoed; the governor's statement; 1,300 voluntary easements and $175 million.

Documented Records (3)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2005
June 23, 2005
The Supreme Court held 5 to 4 in Kelo v. City of New London that a city may take homes by eminent domain and transfer the land to a private developer because the planned use would produce more tax revenue and jobs. The homes were demolished. The development was never built, the land stood vacant for nearly twenty years, and Pfizer, the company the plan was built around, left in 2009. More than $80 million in public money was spent. Forty seven states changed their laws in response; the federal rule stands.
“The specter of condemnation hangs over all property. Nothing is to prevent the State from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz-Carlton, any home with a shopping mall, or any farm with a factory.”
Supreme Court; City of New London and its development corporation. Violates: Fifth Amendment public use clause. Held not violated.. Source: Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469, Supreme Court of the United States
2023
June 3, 2023
Section 324 of the Fiscal Responsibility Act ratified every federal permit for the Mountain Valley Pipeline, 303 miles through West Virginia and Virginia, after the Fourth Circuit had repeatedly found them deficient, directed the agencies to issue any that remained, and provided that no court shall have jurisdiction to review them. The land along the route had already been condemned by the private company under its federal certificate.
Congress; President Biden. Violates: Separation of powers; the owners' access to the courts. Enacted.. Source: H.R. 3746, Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023, Public Law 118-5, Section 324, Congress.gov
2025
March 6 and June 2025
South Dakota's governor signed House Bill 1052 prohibiting eminent domain for carbon dioxide pipelines, and the state's utilities commission denied Summit Carbon Solutions' permit on April 22. Iowa's legislature passed a similar bill, House File 639, 85 to 10 and 27 to 22, and the governor vetoed it in June, saying it set a troubling precedent for Iowa's reputation as a place where businesses can invest with confidence.
Governor Larry Rhoden (signed); Governor Kim Reynolds (vetoed). Violates: None. Listed as the two answers a state can give.. Source: Gov. Reynolds vetoes eminent domain bill, N'West Iowa REVIEW

Timeline Events (4)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

March 6, 2025
South Dakota bans eminent domain for carbon pipelines
Iowa's governor vetoes the same bill in June.
June 3, 2023
Congress approves the Mountain Valley Pipeline and bars court review
Section 324 of the debt ceiling law.
June 29, 2021
PennEast: a private pipeline company may condemn state land under a federal certificate
5 to 4.
June 23, 2005
Kelo: homes may be taken for a private developer
5 to 4. The land stood empty for nearly twenty years.
Kelo v. New London: Eminent Domain to Seize Private Homes for Corporations and Pipelines | Spirit of '76