2013 to 2019: The disclosures · Housing & Private Equity

IRS "Structuring" Seizures: $242 Million Taken from Small Businesses for Cash Deposits Under $10,000

Period covered: 2005 to 2019 · 3 sources

Summary

Federal law makes it a crime to deposit cash in amounts under $10,000 in order to avoid the report banks must file on deposits above it, whether or not the money is legal. From 2005 to 2012 the IRS used that law to seize more than $242 million from more than 2,500 people. The Treasury's inspector general later sampled 278 of the cases and found no evidence of any crime other than the deposits in 91 percent of them. Agents interviewed the owners without telling them they could refuse, in most cases did not tell them why they were there, and ignored the explanations they gave. A dairy farmer lost $29,500 and a convenience store supplier more than $400,000. Neither was charged. The IRS stopped in October 2014; Congress made the change law in 2019.

Banks must report any cash deposit over $10,000 to the Treasury. A separate law, written for money launderers, makes it a crime to structure deposits, that is, to keep them under $10,000 on purpose so that no report is filed. The crime is the pattern of deposits. It does not matter where the money came from. A restaurant that deposits its take every few days, a farm stand paid in cash, a store owner who does not like to carry more than a few thousand dollars to the bank, all fit the pattern, and the government may seize the account without charging anyone.

What the IRS did

The Institute for Justice, which represented some of the owners, counted the seizures from the IRS's own records: from 2005 to 2012 the agency seized more than $242 million in more than 2,500 cases on structuring allegations. Randy Sowers, a dairy farmer in Maryland, lost $29,500. Jeff Hirsch, whose family business supplied convenience stores on Long Island, lost more than $400,000. Neither was ever charged with a crime.

Inspector General Audit Findings

The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration reviewed the program in a report dated March 20, 2017. It sampled 278 investigations. In 91 percent of them there was no evidence that the structured funds came from an illegal source or involved any other illegal activity. In 231 cases where the money was legal, $17.1 million had been seized and forfeited to the government. Of 229 interviews the agents conducted, in only five were the owners told of rights such as the right to remain silent. In 202 interviews the property owners were not adequately informed of important information, such as the purpose of the interview. In 54 investigations the owners gave what the inspector general called realistic defenses or explanations, and in 43 of those there was no evidence the agency considered them. The IRS had changed its policy in October 2014, after the seizures were reported, and said it would no longer pursue forfeiture where the money was legal. It later reviewed 464 petitions from people whose money it had taken. Of the 208 it controlled, it granted about 84 percent and returned more than $9.9 million. Of the 256 that the Justice Department controlled, the IRS recommended returning the money in 194, and the department agreed to 41 and kept more than $22.2 million.

The law that fixed it

On September 5, 2017 the House passed the Clyde-Hirsch-Sowers RESPECT Act unanimously, named for three of the people whose money had been taken. It limits forfeiture for structuring to cases where the money came from an illegal source or was used to conceal illegal activity, and gives the owner a prompt hearing after a seizure. It became law as part of the Taxpayer First Act on July 1, 2019.

← 2013 to 2019

Primary Sources (3)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2017
Federal Tax Crimes blog (summarizing the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration report). $17.1 million forfeited in 231 legal source cases; rights read in 5 of 229 interviews; 202 interviews without adequate information; 54 explanations, 43 not considered.
2017
Institute for Justice. More than $242 million in more than 2,500 cases 2005 to 2012; the TIGTA 91 percent finding; Hirsch and Sowers; the October 2014 policy.
2019
Institute for Justice. The Taxpayer First Act's structuring limit; 464 petitions; 84 percent granted and $9.9 million returned by the IRS; 41 of 256 accepted by the Justice Department, $22.2 million kept.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2017
2005 to 2019
The IRS seized more than $242 million from more than 2,500 people between 2005 and 2012 for depositing cash in amounts under $10,000. The Treasury inspector general found no evidence of any other crime in 91 percent of 278 sampled cases, found owners told their rights in 5 of 229 interviews and not told the purpose in 202, and found their explanations ignored. The agency stopped in October 2014; the Justice Department returned money in 41 of 256 petitions it controlled and kept $22.2 million. Congress limited the practice in 2019.
“In 91 percent of cases there was no evidence that the structured funds came from an illegal source or involved any other illegal activity.”
Internal Revenue Service, Criminal Investigation; Department of Justice. Violates: Fourth and Fifth Amendments. Property taken from people never charged.. Source: House Unanimously Passes Bill to Curb Civil Forfeiture by the IRS, Institute for Justice

Timeline Events (4)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

July 1, 2019
Structuring forfeiture limited to illegal money by law
The Taxpayer First Act.
March 20, 2017
Treasury inspector general: rights read in 5 of 229 IRS structuring interviews
$17.1 million forfeited from 231 people with legal money.
October 2014
IRS stops seizing legal source deposits
After the seizures were reported.
2005 to 2012
IRS seizes more than $242 million in structuring cases
More than 2,500 people; 91 percent with no other alleged crime.
IRS "Structuring" Seizures: $242 Million Taken from Small Businesses for Cash Deposits Under $10,000 | Spirit of '76