2013 to 2019: The disclosures · Housing & Private Equity
IRS "Structuring" Seizures: $242 Million Taken from Small Businesses for Cash Deposits Under $10,000
Period covered: 2005 to 2019 · 3 sources
Summary
Federal law makes it a crime to deposit cash in amounts under $10,000 in order to avoid the report banks must file on deposits above it, whether or not the money is legal. From 2005 to 2012 the IRS used that law to seize more than $242 million from more than 2,500 people. The Treasury's inspector general later sampled 278 of the cases and found no evidence of any crime other than the deposits in 91 percent of them. Agents interviewed the owners without telling them they could refuse, in most cases did not tell them why they were there, and ignored the explanations they gave. A dairy farmer lost $29,500 and a convenience store supplier more than $400,000. Neither was charged. The IRS stopped in October 2014; Congress made the change law in 2019.
Banks must report any cash deposit over $10,000 to the Treasury. A separate law, written for money launderers, makes it a crime to structure deposits, that is, to keep them under $10,000 on purpose so that no report is filed. The crime is the pattern of deposits. It does not matter where the money came from. A restaurant that deposits its take every few days, a farm stand paid in cash, a store owner who does not like to carry more than a few thousand dollars to the bank, all fit the pattern, and the government may seize the account without charging anyone.
What the IRS did
The Institute for Justice, which represented some of the owners, counted the seizures from the IRS's own records: from 2005 to 2012 the agency seized more than $242 million in more than 2,500 cases on structuring allegations. Randy Sowers, a dairy farmer in Maryland, lost $29,500. Jeff Hirsch, whose family business supplied convenience stores on Long Island, lost more than $400,000. Neither was ever charged with a crime.
Inspector General Audit Findings
The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration reviewed the program in a report dated March 20, 2017. It sampled 278 investigations. In 91 percent of them there was no evidence that the structured funds came from an illegal source or involved any other illegal activity. In 231 cases where the money was legal, $17.1 million had been seized and forfeited to the government. Of 229 interviews the agents conducted, in only five were the owners told of rights such as the right to remain silent. In 202 interviews the property owners were not adequately informed of important information, such as the purpose of the interview. In 54 investigations the owners gave what the inspector general called realistic defenses or explanations, and in 43 of those there was no evidence the agency considered them. The IRS had changed its policy in October 2014, after the seizures were reported, and said it would no longer pursue forfeiture where the money was legal. It later reviewed 464 petitions from people whose money it had taken. Of the 208 it controlled, it granted about 84 percent and returned more than $9.9 million. Of the 256 that the Justice Department controlled, the IRS recommended returning the money in 194, and the department agreed to 41 and kept more than $22.2 million.
The law that fixed it
On September 5, 2017 the House passed the Clyde-Hirsch-Sowers RESPECT Act unanimously, named for three of the people whose money had been taken. It limits forfeiture for structuring to cases where the money came from an illegal source or was used to conceal illegal activity, and gives the owner a prompt hearing after a seizure. It became law as part of the Taxpayer First Act on July 1, 2019.
Primary Sources (3)
Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.
Documented Records (1)
Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.
Timeline Events (4)
Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.
More in Housing & Private Equity
View all stories in Housing & Private Equity → · Topic overview →
- 2020 to 2026Unsealed State Farm Records Show a Nationwide Program to Cut Roof Replacements by $1.4 BillionIn August 2026 a judge in Comanche County, Oklahoma unsealed State Farm's internal documents in a lawsuit by a couple whose hail claim was denied. A 2020 planning document called wind and hail the greatest opportunity to impact enterprise results, roof claims being more than half of the company's weather payouts; a program began in Dallas County that June and was nationwide by the end of the year; managers had to approve any full roof replacement; each percentage point fewer replacements was calculated at $78.8 million a year; and the company recorded a $1.4 billion drop in payouts in the first year, with full replacements falling from 5.6 for every repair to 2. The attorney general sued the company under the state racketeering law on June 24, 2026. Two months later he lost the Republican runoff for governor by 2,020 votes to a candidate who had called the lawsuit political, who took donations from at least nine people listed as State Farm agents or employees, one of them a State Farm corporate lawyer listed as an agent, and who proposes to lower premiums by limiting lawsuits against insurers.Housing & Private Equity
- March to July 2026The 2026 Law Barring Big Investors from Buying Single-Family HomesIn March 2026 Senator Elizabeth Warren said the country was short 7 million homes and the median first time buyer was 40 years old. That month the Senate passed a bill barring investors that own 350 or more single family homes from buying any more. It became law on July 11, 2026 without the president's signature, with the build to rent industry exempted.Housing & Private Equity
- 2008 to 2026Right to Repair, Software Locks, and Manufacturers Controlling Products After You Buy ThemLouis Rossmann started fixing MacBooks in 2008 and spent fifteen years finding out why the parts were so hard to get. The answer led him from repair to ownership to surveillance: products that stop working when the maker stops supporting them, cars that report your driving to your insurer, phone carriers that sold your location to bounty hunters, and camera networks pushed through city councils by hiring the people on them.Housing & Private Equity
- 2022 to 2026Private Equity Rent Hikes in Florida Retirement ParksAt a 55 and over park in central Florida, Legacy Communities talked residents out of the inflation clause in their leases and the rent more than doubled. Down the road at a Sun Communities park the lot rent is up almost 50 percent since 2014. In Brunswick, Maine, residents facing the same thing bought their park.Housing & Private Equity
- 1980 to 2025Private Equity Bankruptcies and the $3 Trillion Private Credit MarketPrivate equity backed companies accounted for 54 percent of the largest bankruptcies of 2025. The industry owns a growing share of the homes, the hospitals, and the entry level jobs, and it has built a $3 trillion private credit market outside the view of regulators. The people coming of age now are the ones who inherit it.Housing & Private Equity