2020 to today · Housing & Private Equity

Right to Repair, Software Locks, and Manufacturers Controlling Products After You Buy Them

Period covered: 2008 to 2026 · 1 source

Summary

Louis Rossmann started fixing MacBooks in 2008 and spent fifteen years finding out why the parts were so hard to get. The answer led him from repair to ownership to surveillance: products that stop working when the maker stops supporting them, cars that report your driving to your insurer, phone carriers that sold your location to bounty hunters, and camera networks pushed through city councils by hiring the people on them.

Louis Rossmann became a repairman by accident. In 2008 he needed a laptop that ran Logic to finish a recording session, bought a broken one on eBay, fixed it, and sold it for a few hundred dollars. He built a shop in New York that repaired Apple logic boards at the component level, replacing the fifty cent part instead of the $1,500 board, and put the work on YouTube. The channel became the center of the right to repair movement. He has testified in state legislatures, fought Apple and John Deere, and co-founded the Fulu Foundation to work on digital ownership.

From repair to ownership

The thread was parts. A plumber goes to a supply house and buys pipe. A person who fixes modern electronics cannot buy the parts that way, and Rossmann said the supply chain for what he does looks like an arms smuggling movie, down to the report of tunnels dug under factories in China so workers could sneak recycled components out. The question of why you cannot fix what you bought turned into the question of whether you own it at all. Everything is becoming a subscription. When the company stops supporting the product, it stops working, and the answer is to buy a new one. He gave the example of a home automation company that went under and pushed out a firmware update requiring customers to pay $117 a year to get back into systems they had paid for, and an exercise bike that locks the owner out unless they subscribe.

He said the legal obstacle is Section 1201 of the copyright law, which makes it illegal to break a digital lock and to share the way around it, even to repair a product you own. The foundation runs a bounty program that pays people to break those locks. At the time of the interview it was offering up to $18,000 to anyone who could make an Amazon Ring camera work without connecting to Amazon's servers. It also runs a public wiki, consumerrights.wiki, where people log every case of a company selling customers' data or revoking something they paid for, with a browser extension that warns a shopper before they buy from a company on the list.

California passed a law he called one of the best property rights laws he has read: if a company markets a digital good with the words buy, purchase, own, or sell, and keeps the right to take the product away later, it may no longer use those words, because they imply a transfer of ownership that is not happening. He had hundreds of people write to the state attorney general about a company breaking it. Each got a form letter saying the office could not help and suggesting they hire a lawyer.

The car and the phone

In 2015 General Motors began collecting data on how its customers drove and selling it to LexisNexis, a data broker, which sold it on to insurers. The New York Times put on its front page the case of a Chevy Bolt owner whose insurance rates went up after he accelerated hard, because his insurer had bought his driving record from the carmaker. The attorney general of Texas sued General Motors over it. Rossmann's point is that people who mocked electric car owners for being spied on had bought a Chevy and were being spied on the same way, and that the habit of laughing at the neighbor who bought the wrong brand is what keeps everyone from looking at the companies doing it.

AT&T, T-Mobile, Sprint, and Verizon were caught collecting customers' location data and selling it to advertisers, bail bondsmen, and bounty hunters. They were fined tens of millions of dollars each in a year when they made billions. Rossmann said a fine that small removes whatever self imposed limit a company had on its greed, and that it shows a law on the books does not mean the law is followed. He also raised the point that the government cannot collect certain data on citizens itself but can buy it from companies that collected it through terms of service nobody reads, which gets around the Fourth Amendment.

On his own phone he found, in the data Google lets a user export, every voice to text recording he had made since 2010, transcribed and stored with the audio. When he set up an LG television in 2023, the option to stop the sale of his personal information was 27 clicks deep. In Washington State, connecting a phone to a car and allowing access to text messages leaves the messages stored in the car with no way for the owner to delete them, though software exists that can retrieve them. He said the refrigerator in the 1990s did not come with ads and a subscription and the car in 1997 did not report to the insurance company, and that at some point the pendulum has to come back.

The cameras

Rossmann got involved with license plate cameras in Austin, where a company called LiveView Technologies wanted to install them. Residents emailed to object and showed up at city hall. The item was pulled from the agenda at the last minute, residents were told they would be notified when it returned, and the next month two of the company's salespeople were signed up to speak in public comment while residents could not address an item that was not on the agenda. He organized people to sign up for whatever item was open and talk about the cameras anyway. The mayor called them out of order. His reason was the pattern he had seen elsewhere.

In Cleveland, a city council staffer left to work for Flock Safety, the largest maker of the cameras, and the contract went through as an emergency ordinance. The city's ethics rule bars a former council employee from working on the matters he handled, and the exemption is emergency ordinances. In Moreno Valley, California, Flock hired the sitting mayor, who later sued the company, saying he was let go for refusing to use his connections to get the cameras installed. In Denver, contracts over $500,000 need council approval, and the mayor's office rewrote the Flock contract to come in just under it. Rossmann said that if the cameras were something people wanted, none of this would be necessary.

He described the case of a woman in a Rivian who drove through a small town and later had an officer at her door accusing her of stealing a $7 package from a porch. Her dash camera showed she never stopped. The officer told her nobody gets a breath of fresh air in that town without the police knowing, and refused to show her the evidence. The systems are right often enough that police lean on them, he said, and the tenth time they are wrong the person accused has no way to see what the machine said. He pointed to the Supreme Court's own reasoning that a system that watches everyone all the time is a dragnet, and that a person in public has not agreed to be tracked by one.

The foundation built a site, alpr.watch, that scans the agendas of every city over 50,000 people for camera contracts and emails residents when one comes up in their zip code.

What he thinks works

Rossmann said his experience over ten years is that repair and ownership always get tabled for a bigger issue, whatever it is that year, and that the one politician who was open to a bill on digital locks stopped answering after three months. He pursues the laws anyway. His view is that the change that matters comes from people refusing: the engineer told to push the update that turns a product into a subscription, the employee at the phone company told to give a bail bondsman access to someone's location. And from neighbors helping each other fix things, which he set against what he called the how dare you brand of activism. He said he never wants to lecture people. He wants them to have the experience of getting back something they thought was gone, and to remember who tried to take it.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (1)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Richard Ryan. Ownership, repair, and manufacturer control after the sale.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2025
Interview
Louis Rossmann describes how manufacturers control products after they are sold: repairs restricted to authorized shops, features sold as subscriptions, and devices disabled remotely.
Consumer technology companies. Violates: Ownership of purchased goods. Source: "They Want You to Own Nothing": Louis Rossmann on Tech, Control & Sovereignty, Richard Ryan
Right to Repair, Software Locks, and Manufacturers Controlling Products After You Buy Them | Spirit of '76