1975 to 2000: Investigations and deregulation · Police, Courts & Prisons

Ruby Ridge (1992) and Waco (1993): Federal Rules of Engagement, Tear Gas Fires, and Cover-Ups

Period covered: 1992 to 2000 · 5 sources

Summary

In August 1992 federal marshals went to arrest Randy Weaver on a gun charge after a probation officer had sent him the wrong court date. His fourteen year old son and a deputy marshal were killed in the first exchange, and the next day an FBI sniper, under rules that said agents can and should shoot any armed adult male, killed Weaver's wife as she stood in her doorway holding their baby. The Justice Department's own review found the rules did not meet the Constitution. Weaver was acquitted of everything but missing the court date. Six months later, in Waco, the ATF raided the Branch Davidians knowing it had lost the element of surprise and lied about it afterward, by the Treasury Department's finding; four agents and six Davidians died. Fifty-one days after that the FBI's tear gas assault ended in a fire that killed about 80 people, including children, and the bureau denied for six years that it had fired pyrotechnic rounds that day. The government paid the Weavers $3.1 million. One FBI official was convicted, for destroying a document.

Randy Weaver lived with his family in a cabin on Ruby Ridge in northern Idaho. In 1989 he sold two sawed off shotguns to an informant for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms and was charged. A probation officer sent him a letter giving his trial date as March 20, 1991. The date was February 20. When he did not appear, a warrant was issued, and the United States Marshals Service began watching the cabin. On August 21, 1992 marshals in camouflage on the property were discovered by the family's dog. They shot the dog. Weaver's son Samuel, who was fourteen, followed the dog and was shot and killed. Deputy Marshal William Degan was killed in the same exchange, by Weaver's friend Kevin Harris. The FBI's Hostage Rescue Team was flown in. Its rules of engagement for the siege said that agents can and should use deadly force against any armed adult male seen on the property, before or after any call to surrender. On August 22 an FBI sniper, Lon Horiuchi, fired twice. The first shot wounded Weaver. The second went through the cabin door, wounded Harris, and killed Vicki Weaver, who was standing behind the door holding her ten month old daughter.

Weaver and Harris were tried in 1993. Harris was acquitted of everything. Weaver was acquitted of everything except failing to appear for the trial date he had been told wrongly, and was sentenced to 18 months. In 1994 a Justice Department task force reviewed the siege and found that the rules of engagement did not satisfy constitutional standards for legal use of deadly force. In 1995 the Senate Judiciary Committee held hearings, and the government paid the Weaver family $3.1 million to settle its claims. In 1997 the state of Idaho charged Horiuchi with manslaughter; the charge was dismissed on the ground that a federal officer acting within his duties cannot be tried by a state. On August 15, 1997 the Justice Department announced that it would not prosecute the FBI officials who had approved the rules, finding it could not prove that the two most senior of them had falsely denied knowing about the rules. The one conviction from Ruby Ridge was of E. Michael Kahoe, an FBI official, who pleaded guilty to obstruction of justice for destroying the bureau's own after action critique of the siege.

Waco

On February 28, 1993 ATF agents raided the Branch Davidian community outside Waco, Texas to serve a warrant for illegal weapons. Four agents were killed and 16 wounded; six of the Davidians died. The Treasury Department's report on the raid, released at the end of September 1993, found that the commanders had learned from an informant that the raid was compromised, that they were under orders to call it off if the element of surprise was lost, and that they went ahead anyway. It found that afterward some ATF agents told the truth to investigators, but some lied, claiming they did not know the element of surprise had been lost, and their lies became the basis of the ATF's public explanations. The bureau's director was replaced and the commanders were suspended.

The FBI took over and the siege lasted 51 days. On April 19, 1993 the bureau began pumping tear gas into the buildings with armored vehicles. A fire began, and about 80 people died in it, including the children inside. For six years the government said it had used nothing that could start a fire. In August 1999 documents surfaced showing that the FBI had fired pyrotechnic tear gas rounds that morning. The attorney general appointed John Danforth, a former Republican senator, as special counsel. His report of July 21, 2000, after 2 million documents, 900 witnesses, and $11 million, found that federal agents did not start the fire, did not shoot at the Davidians on the last day, and did not improperly use the military, and that the Davidians had started the fire themselves; it also found that an FBI agent had fired three pyrotechnic rounds near the buildings and that government officials did not admit their use until August 1999.

← 1975 to 2000

Primary Sources (5)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Wikipedia (consolidated record with citations to the trial, the 1994 Justice Department task force report, and the 1995 Senate hearings). The wrong court date; August 21 and 22, 1992; the rules of engagement; the 1993 acquittals; the task force's constitutional finding; the $3.1 million settlement; the state charge dismissed.
PBS Frontline. February 28, 1993: four agents killed, 16 wounded; the 51 days; the August 1999 revelation; Danforth appointed; the July 21, 2000 findings including the three pyrotechnic rounds.
1993
United Press International. The commanders knew surprise was lost and violated orders by proceeding; some agents lied and their lies became the ATF's public explanations.
1997
U.S. Department of Justice. No prosecution of the officials who approved the rules; Kahoe's guilty plea for destroying the after action critique; the can and should rule.
2000
CBS News. About 80 dead including children; 2 million documents, 900 witnesses, $11 million; the six year denial of the incendiary rounds.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

1993
August 1992 to April 1993
At Ruby Ridge federal marshals and the FBI, under rules of engagement the Justice Department later found did not satisfy constitutional standards, killed a fourteen year old boy and a mother holding her baby, in a case that began with a wrong court date; the family was paid $3.1 million and one official was convicted, for destroying a document. At Waco the ATF raided knowing surprise was lost and lied about it, by the Treasury's finding, four agents and six Davidians died, and after the FBI's assault and fire killed about 80 people the bureau denied for six years that it had fired pyrotechnic rounds.
“The rules of engagement did not satisfy constitutional standards for legal use of deadly force.”
United States Marshals Service; Federal Bureau of Investigation; Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms. Violates: Fourth Amendment; the constitutional limits on deadly force, by the Justice Department's own finding.. Source: Justice Department announces conclusion of Ruby Ridge investigation, U.S. Department of Justice

Timeline Events (5)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

July 21, 2000
Danforth: the government did not start the Waco fire, and hid the pyrotechnic rounds for six years
2 million documents, 900 witnesses.
August 15, 1997
No prosecution of the officials who approved the Ruby Ridge rules
One conviction, for destroying the after action critique.
April 19, 1993
Waco fire kills about 80 after the FBI's tear gas assault
Pyrotechnic rounds denied until August 1999.
February 28, 1993
ATF raids Waco knowing surprise is lost; four agents and six Davidians die
Treasury: some agents lied and their lies became the public explanation.
August 22, 1992
FBI sniper kills Vicki Weaver at Ruby Ridge
Rules of engagement later found unconstitutional; $3.1 million paid.
Ruby Ridge (1992) and Waco (1993): Federal Rules of Engagement, Tear Gas Fires, and Cover-Ups | Spirit of '76