2020 to today · Wall Street & Banking

How the Federal Reserve Hired BlackRock to Run the 2008 and 2020 Bailouts

Period covered: 1988 to 2021 · 1 source

Summary

In 2008 the Federal Reserve Bank of New York gave BlackRock the contracts to manage the toxic assets of Bear Stearns, AIG, and Citigroup, without competitive bidding, while BlackRock was one of the largest shareholders in the banks being rescued. In 2020 the Fed hired the same firm to buy corporate bonds, including bonds of companies BlackRock owns large stakes in.

BlackRock is the largest asset manager in the world. By 2021 it managed more than $9 trillion, which is more than the 300 largest pension funds in the world hold between them. Its clients include pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, central banks, college endowments, Fortune 500 companies, and millions of individual investors. It is one of the top shareholders of Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, and the big banks. Together with Vanguard and State Street, the three largest asset managers held about $15 trillion, close to 70 percent of the American economy's annual output. The man who built it, Larry Fink, has said he does not think of himself as powerful.

How Fink got there

Fink studied political science at UCLA and went to Wall Street at 23. He joined First Boston, where he traded bonds and helped develop the market for debt securitization: bundling car loans, credit card loans, and mortgages together, slicing the bundle into pieces, and selling the pieces to investors. Mortgage backed securities were considered an innovation at the time. They are also the instruments at the center of the 2008 collapse. At 31 he was the youngest managing director in the firm's history and had added about a billion dollars to its bottom line.

Then he lost $100 million on one bet. He had positioned the firm for interest rates to rise, and they fell. The hedge that was supposed to cover the loss was miscalculated. He was pushed out of the company he had spent twelve years at. In 1988, at 35, he started over with backing from Stephen Schwarzman of the Blackstone Group. The two later split, and Fink's firm became BlackRock. It went public in 1999 and later took over Merrill Lynch's investment management business, adding half a trillion dollars in assets.

What set the firm apart was its software. Aladdin is a network of about 5,000 computers that watches millions of trades and analyzes clients' portfolios around the clock for risk. It is used by so much of the industry that the film calls it the central nervous system of investment management. To run it, BlackRock is given access to sensitive data from banks, insurers, and pension funds around the world. Through Aladdin the firm has an eye on about $21 trillion in assets, and that figure comes from only a third of the software's 240 clients. That is at least 10 percent of all the stocks and bonds in the world.

2008

When the financial system failed in 2008 and Washington bailed out Wall Street, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York went to Fink. BlackRock was hired to manage $30 billion in toxic assets from Bear Stearns, to advise on $100 billion in toxic assets from AIG, and to handle $31 billion of Citigroup's assets. The contracts were awarded behind closed doors with no competitive bidding. BlackRock was at the same time one of the biggest shareholders in the banks being rescued. It made at least $200 million from the contracts. The film quotes a report that the bailout was far bigger than the Fed let the public or members of Congress know at the time. One observer quoted in the documentary called BlackRock "the Blackwater of finance, almost a shadow government."

Defenders of the arrangement argue that The government was going to step in regardless, it was partly responsible for the mess through low interest rates, and it had no expertise in mortgage backed securities, so it went to the man who helped invent them. The filmmaker calls it shady and understandable at the same time.

2020

In March 2020, at the start of the pandemic, the Federal Reserve announced it would buy corporate bonds and corporate bond exchange traded funds for the first time in its history. The firm it hired to run those purchases was BlackRock. The companies whose debt the Fed bought included companies in which BlackRock holds some of its largest stakes, and the ETFs it bought included ETFs that BlackRock manages. The Fed's published list of holdings, on the New York Fed's website, runs to 794 companies. BlackRock also helped the Fed buy more mortgage backed securities.

Global Reach and Circular Ownership

BlackRock has what the film calls circular ownership: it owns shares in companies that own shares in BlackRock. In 2020 the Chinese government approved it to set up a mutual fund in China, the first foreign asset manager allowed to. It holds stakes across Europe in energy, oil and gas, transportation, food, and finance. In 2019 there were petitions against the firm for being among the top shareholders in oil and coal, and Fink responded by pushing environmental, social, and governance investing, writing to companies that they must contribute to society to keep his firm's support. The film's view is that the ESG rating system amounts to a phony rating that rewards companies for saying the right things.

Asked what matters to him personally, Fink told an interviewer that it is important for him to be seen as a good human being, caring and real, and that he is the same person he was thirty years ago.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (1)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Jake Tran. BlackRock's role in the 2008 bailout and the 2020 Federal Reserve bond purchases.

Documented Records (3)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2008
2008
The Federal Reserve Bank of New York hired BlackRock to manage about $30 billion in assets from Bear Stearns, to advise on about $100 billion in assets from AIG, and to handle $31 billion in Citigroup assets. The contracts were awarded without competitive bidding. BlackRock was at the same time one of the largest shareholders in the banks being rescued. It earned at least $200 million from the contracts.
“It's like the Blackwater of Finance, almost a shadow government.”
Federal Reserve Bank of New York, BlackRock. Violates: Public contracts awarded without competition, to a firm with a financial interest in the outcome. Source: BlackRock: The Company that Owns the World, Jake Tran
2020
March 2020
The Federal Reserve hired BlackRock to run its programs buying corporate bonds and bond ETFs during the pandemic, the first time the Fed had bought corporate debt. The purchases included companies in which BlackRock holds large stakes and ETFs that BlackRock manages. The Fed's published list of holdings ran to 794 companies.
Federal Reserve, BlackRock. Violates: Public money directed through a firm with a financial interest in where it went. Source: BlackRock: The Company that Owns the World, Jake Tran
2021
2021
BlackRock managed more than $9 trillion, more than the 300 largest pension funds in the world combined. With Vanguard and State Street, the three largest asset managers managed about $15 trillion, close to 70 percent of U.S. GDP. The three firms are also each other's largest shareholders.
BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street. Violates: None in law. Listed for scale and for the ownership loop.. Source: BlackRock: The Company that Owns the World, Jake Tran

Timeline Events (1)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

March 2020
The Federal Reserve hires BlackRock to run its corporate bond purchases
The first time the Fed bought corporate debt. The purchases included ETFs managed by BlackRock and companies in which BlackRock is a major shareholder. The same firm had managed toxic assets for the Fed in 2008.
How the Federal Reserve Hired BlackRock to Run the 2008 and 2020 Bailouts | Spirit of '76