2001 to 2012: After September 11 · CIA, War & Covert Operations

Top Secret America: The Post-9/11 Intelligence Complex of 1,900 Private Contractors

Period covered: 2001 to 2011 · 2 sources

Summary

Within a week of the attacks the president signed a finding that let the CIA capture, interrogate, and kill anywhere in the world. Congress wrote a blank check. Ten years later two reporters counted close to a million people with top secret clearances, 1,900 private companies, and 17,000 locations, with no public accounting of what it cost or whether it worked. The next president kept nearly all of it.

On the night of the attacks, President Bush told the CIA in the basement of the White House that it would have everything it needed. Congress, in the words of one official, said tell us what you need, blank check. One senior CIA official recalled the president turning in his direction and saying never let this happen again, and understood it to mean there was no end of the earth they would not go to and nobody they would not work with. Vice President Cheney said publicly that the government would have to work the dark side and spend time in the shadows. Priest's summary is that the entire blueprint for the next decade was written in the first few days, in secret, and that it took reporters years to find out.

The CIA, led on this by its counterterrorism chief Cofer Black, had plans on the shelf and brought them to the White House before the military had a map of Afghanistan. The program was code named Greystone. It came with a matrix of the countries the agency would go into to kill and capture al-Qaeda members and their supporters. Within a week the president laid down about a dozen decisions in the Cabinet Room, one of them that he wanted the CIA in first, and signed a finding, the legal document that authorizes covert action. John Rizzo, a senior CIA lawyer, said it was generally worded, that it amounted to go out and get the bad guys, disrupt them, kill them, interrogate them, and that he had never seen a presidential authorization so far reaching or so aggressive in scope. It set in motion the largest covert action program since the Cold War, and by some accounts larger. One CIA officer said the agency went from a junkyard dog staked to the ground, able to report but not act, to new authorities, new rules of engagement, and lots of funding, in a nanosecond.

What the finding allowed

The first CIA team, seven officers and three air crew, flew into Afghanistan on September 26 carrying cash, and the Taliban fell within weeks. Greystone then ran in more than a dozen countries. In November 2002 a drone flying over Yemen from a control room in Tampa, Florida fired on an SUV on the verbal approval of an official who described the decision as no different from going to the store for eggs. Everyone in the vehicle died. It was the first known use of the weapon in that way, and Priest's question at the time was whether it was assassination and what rules it operated under.

Prisoners taken in Afghanistan did not all go into the military system. Priest eventually found where the high value ones went: a network of about two dozen secret prisons in other countries, run, paid for, and organized by the CIA. Rizzo, who helped authorize them, said building a prison system was something the agency had never done and that the prisoners had to be held in absolute isolation overseas. The Justice Department approved seven interrogation methods, including waterboarding, which one interviewee said is torture by any definition. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was waterboarded 183 times. The White House had approved an international prison system entirely in secret.

At the Pentagon, Secretary Rumsfeld wrote memos saying the CIA's lead could not stand and built his own capacity by expanding Joint Special Operations Command, which began a systematic series of capture and kill operations with less oversight than the CIA. Covert action by the CIA requires a presidential finding and notice to Congress. The same operations run by JSOC are classified as military operations, which the president does not have to approve individually and the intelligence committees are not told about.

Iraq

By the spring of 2002 war with Iraq was taken for granted inside the government. George Tenet and the CIA said there was no evidence that Saddam Hussein had helped al-Qaeda. Rumsfeld created the Office of Special Plans, a small unit in a vault in the Pentagon with access to all intelligence, to produce the analysis the CIA would not. Its material, rarely vetted, went to the vice president's office and was leaked to journalists to establish a link between Iraq and al-Qaeda. The public case shifted to weapons of mass destruction. After eight months of searching, David Kay, who was given the job of finding them, concluded there were none, and said that if the public had understood what he was reporting there would have had to be a major shakeup of American intelligence. The 9/11 Commission's remedy was a Director of National Intelligence, but the Pentagon fought to keep its authority over its own intelligence agencies and the position was cut down day by day until, as one interviewee said, it was an emperor without clothes. Its office grew anyway, from eleven people to 500,000 square feet.

At home

A few weeks into the war the president asked the NSA what more it could do. Its director, Michael Hayden, told the vice president and the president there were things it could do but did not have the authority for. That became the terrorist surveillance program, which authorized the agency to intercept phone calls and emails of Americans without a warrant, a change from where the agency's boundaries had always been. Hayden said nobody was in a mood to ask about privacy. The NSA built a system that captured about 1.7 billion intercepts a day, more than any number of people could read, and to process it the agency spent billions of dollars on more than 480 private companies. Hayden said he did it at NSA, Tenet did it at CIA, and everyone did it, because contractors could be hired faster than government employees. The agency's budget was and is a state secret.

Priest and Arkin set out to map what had been built. It took Arkin about a year to catalog the government and corporate entities working in this world, and the only way to verify any of it was to drive there. They found hundreds of locations in office parks around Washington and Baltimore, buildings four stories high that go ten stories down, with shops and restaurants underground for the people inside. If it had been built in one place, Arkin said, it would be the size of the District of Columbia. Their count: close to a million people with top secret clearances, about three dozen new federal organizations a year, 1,900 private companies, and 17,000 locations. Nobody outside can say what they do, whether it works, or what it costs.

The next president

Barack Obama campaigned on reining it in. Once he was briefed, his people signaled to the agencies that they would be as tough or tougher, and the film says no one in his administration would talk about it. He reauthorized almost all of the programs, expanded the covert war in Afghanistan and Pakistan, increased drone strikes many fold, and ramped up JSOC raids. One interviewee explained the political logic: if you cut the terrorism budget and there is an attack, the other party says you caused it. The Department of Homeland Security began a $3.4 billion headquarters that rivals the Pentagon and sent billions to state and local police for 74 fusion centers, surveillance cameras, biometric scanners, and license plate readers.

The film closes on what the system caught and missed. The man who carried a bomb onto a Detroit flight in December 2009 had been reported to the American embassy by his own father, and his name was buried in the 5,000 pieces of information the counterterrorism center receives each day, misspelled by one letter. A passenger stopped him. The Times Square bomber was stopped by a street vendor. Bin Laden was found by a small group of analysts, not by the apparatus of tens of thousands. The last words in the documentary are Priest's: there are close to a million people living in this different world who were not there before, their numbers rival the active army, and we do not know what they are doing, whether it works, or how much it costs.

← 2001 to 2012

Primary Sources (2)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2001
Congress.gov. Signed six weeks after the September 11 attacks.
2011
FRONTLINE (PBS). Dana Priest and William Arkin's investigation of the intelligence system built after 2001.

Documented Records (12)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2001
September 11, 2001
On the night of the attacks the president told the CIA it would have whatever it needed, and Congress agreed to provide the funding. The plan for the following decade was made in secret.
“In the first few days, the entire blueprint for what would happen over the next decade was written. All in secret.”
President Bush, Congress, CIA. Violates: Government conducted with public consent. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
September 17, 2001
The president signed a finding that authorized the CIA to conduct a covert war against al-Qaeda in any country. The head of the CIA's counterterrorism center described the authority as permission to capture, interrogate, and kill. It was the largest covert program since the Cold War.
“I had never seen a presidential authorization as far-reaching and as aggressive in scope.”
President Bush, Cofer Black, CIA. Violates: Congress's authority over war and due process. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
October 26, 2001
The Patriot Act was signed six weeks after the attacks. It expanded the government's ability to collect information on Americans, and most of those powers remain in place.
Congress, President Bush. Violates: Fourth Amendment. Source: USA PATRIOT Act, H.R.3162, 107th Congress (2001), Congress.gov
2002
2002
The NSA was authorized to intercept phone calls and emails of American citizens without a warrant. The director of the agency said this went beyond every boundary the agency had previously observed. According to a participant, nobody in the discussions raised the question of privacy.
“Nobody was in a mood to say, well, wait a minute, are you infringing on privacy?”
President Bush, Vice President Cheney, NSA Director Michael Hayden. Violates: Fourth Amendment. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
2002
Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld expanded Joint Special Operations Command and used it for capture and kill operations. Because the operations were classified as military rather than covert action, the president did not have to approve each one and the congressional intelligence committees were not informed.
“So, the president does not, by law, have to approve every operation. And the intelligence committees are not notified.”
Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld, JSOC. Violates: Congressional oversight. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
2002 onward
The NSA built a collection system that captured about 1.7 billion intercepts a day and paid more than 480 private companies billions of dollars to process them. The agency's budget is classified.
“The National Security Agency has a huge vacuum cleaner around the world.”
NSA, private contractors. Violates: Fourth Amendment, and public accounting of spending. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
2002 to 2003
The Pentagon's Office of Special Plans produced reports linking Saddam Hussein to al-Qaeda that the CIA had not found evidence for. The reports were passed to the vice president's office and used publicly to support the invasion of Iraq. After eight months of searching, the government's weapons inspector reported that Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction.
“They needed an office that would produce the intelligence that the CIA wouldn't produce.”
Secretary Rumsfeld, Office of Special Plans, Vice President Cheney. Violates: The government's duty to tell the public the truth. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
November 2002
A CIA drone destroyed a vehicle in Yemen, killing everyone in it, on the verbal approval of an official watching from Tampa. The legal basis for the strike was not made public.
“Does the Director of Central Intelligence now have a James Bond-style license to kill?”
2003
2002 to 2006
The CIA operated about two dozen secret prisons in other countries. The Justice Department approved seven interrogation methods, including waterboarding, under the name enhanced interrogation. One prisoner was waterboarded 183 times. None of this was disclosed until reporters found it years later.
“Waterboarding, for example, by any definition, it's torture.”
CIA, Department of Justice, John Rizzo. Violates: Fifth Amendment due process, Eighth Amendment. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
2009
2009
The new president, who had campaigned on transparency, was briefed on the programs and continued nearly all of them. Drone strikes in Afghanistan and Pakistan increased several times over. No one in the administration agreed to be interviewed about it.
“They kept just about everything that has been going on since 9/11.”
President Obama. Violates: Consent of the governed. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
2010
2009 to 2011
The Department of Homeland Security spent billions of dollars on state and local police, including 74 fusion centers, surveillance cameras, biometric scanners, and license plate readers, and began building a $3.4 billion headquarters.
“What DHS wants to do is to turn all of the local and state law enforcement personnel into the tipsters for the FBI.”
Department of Homeland Security. Violates: Fourth Amendment, Tenth Amendment. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
July 2010
Two reporters at the Washington Post counted close to a million people with top secret clearances, about three dozen new federal organizations a year, 1,900 private companies, and 17,000 locations. There was no public accounting of what it cost or whether it worked. The two attacks that got through the system in 2009 and 2010 were stopped by passengers and a street vendor.
“We have a growing number of people who are doing things that you and I cannot know about. And we can't know whether it works or not.”
The intelligence community. Violates: Public accountability. Source: How the U.S. Built a Hidden Anti-Terror Apparatus After 9/11 (Top Secret America), FRONTLINE (PBS)
Top Secret America: The Post-9/11 Intelligence Complex of 1,900 Private Contractors | Spirit of '76