2013 to 2019: The disclosures · CIA, War & Covert Operations

NSA Surveillance Inside Online Video Games and US Military Recruitment on Twitch

Period covered: 2002 to 2023 · 4 sources

Summary

A 2008 NSA document from the Snowden files described agents from the NSA, CIA, FBI, and Pentagon inside World of Warcraft, Second Life, and Xbox Live, so many that a group was set up to keep them from surveilling each other, with no plot found. The Army built a free game in 2002 to recruit teenagers and ran giveaways on Twitch in 2020 that led to a recruiting form. A 2019 Call of Duty put a real 1991 American bombing in Russia's name.

The video's other examples of games and secrets are also on the record. In April 2023 an Air National Guardsman named Jack Teixeira, 21, was arrested for posting photographs of classified Pentagon documents to a Discord server of about 40 gamers; he was sentenced to 15 years. Players of the tank game War Thunder have repeatedly posted restricted manuals for real tanks and aircraft to win forum arguments about how accurately the vehicles are modeled.

Recruitment and training

In July 2002 the Army released America's Army, a free game built by the Army as a recruiting tool. By the video's account, the Army's surveys found it had more effect on recruiting than any other form of advertising, one in five cadets entering West Point in 2005 had played it, and the officer who ran it said it was aimed at boys of 12 and 13 who had not decided what to do with their lives; the law bars enlistment under 17. It was shut down in 2022. In 2018 the Army opened a channel on Twitch where soldiers in uniform played Call of Duty and Fortnite on stream, the audience mostly children, and in 2020 ran giveaways whose link went to a recruiting form with no contest behind it, until Twitch made it stop. Since 2005 nearly every Call of Duty has had a retired military adviser, and the most prolific of them, a retired lieutenant colonel, says on camera that sergeants link Xboxes together and train their teams on the game. Full Spectrum Warrior, sold in 2004, was an Army training simulator with a retail game on top and a code that unlocked the military build.

The Highway of Death

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare, released in October 2019, includes a mission on a road the game calls the Highway of Death, where the narrator says the Russians bombed the people trying to escape. The Highway of Death is a real road, Highway 80 from Kuwait toward Basra, and on the night of February 26 to 27, 1991 American led coalition aircraft attacked a retreating Iraqi column on it and destroyed it, an action that drew accusations of excessive force at the time. The publisher's answer was that the game is set in a fictional country and does not represent real events. The video's reading, borrowed from a 2001 game it quotes, is that this is not control of content but control of context.

What is not documented

The video connects a 2014 talk at the Atlantic Council by the director of two Call of Duty games, in which he described a possible attack on a Las Vegas hotel, to the shooting at the Mandalay Bay hotel three years later. It offers the date as the connection. There is none on the record, and the site does not repeat it as one. The video's account of Pokemon Go is that its developer was founded by a former State Department official whose earlier mapping company took money from the CIA's venture fund in 2003 and was bought by Google in 2004, that the game had players photograph their streets, and that in 2024 a company executive said on camera he could see governments and militaries buying the three dimensional map built from that footage. The corporate history is accurate. What was done with the map is not known. The video's closing argument, that drone pilots were trained by games and that targeting is becoming a game the software plays, is argument.

← 2013 to 2019

Primary Sources (4)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Moon. A video essay on games, surveillance, and recruiting. The title's claim is not shown; the documented parts are separated on the story page.
2013
Published by The New York Times. 82 pages published December 9, 2013 with ProPublica and the Guardian. The 2008 paper admits the agency could not recognize the traffic and recommends a group to keep the agencies from surveilling each other.
2013
ProPublica, with The New York Times and The Guardian. The 2008 NSA document Exploiting Terrorist Use of Games and Virtual Environments.
2019
Snopes. The Highway of Death mission, the 1991 attack on Highway 80, and the publisher's response.

Documented Records (3)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2008
2008
An NSA paper titled Exploiting Terrorist Use of Games and Virtual Environments told the agency to begin planning collection inside online games because terrorists would likely be using them by 2010, while admitting that with a few exceptions the NSA could not even recognize the traffic. It reported GCHQ exploitation modules for Xbox Live and World of Warcraft, human intelligence operations by the FBI, CIA, and Defense Humint Service inside Second Life, and recommended a group to deconflict the agencies' operations. A companion NSA and GCHQ paper called World of Warcraft a potentially target-rich communication network. The documents, published by the New York Times on December 9, 2013, are kept on this site.
“With a few exceptions, NSA can't even recognize the traffic, and therefore it is impossible to even say what percentage of the environment is GVE; let alone determine how targets are using the communications features of GVEs.”
National Security Agency; GCHQ; FBI; CIA; Defense Humint Service. Violates: Fourth Amendment as to any Americans swept in. Listed for a collection program planned before any use by a target had been shown.. Source: NSA and GCHQ documents on games and virtual environments: World of Warcraft target development, Exploiting Terrorist Use of Games and Virtual Environments, and a contractor's study of the games industry, Published by The New York Times
2013
December 9, 2013
A 2008 NSA document from the Snowden files, Exploiting Terrorist Use of Games and Virtual Environments, described the NSA and GCHQ collecting inside World of Warcraft, Second Life, and Xbox Live, with so many CIA, FBI, and Pentagon operatives in Second Life that a deconfliction group was set up to keep them from surveilling each other. The document cited no counterterrorism success and no evidence that any terrorist group used the games.
National Security Agency; Central Intelligence Agency; Federal Bureau of Investigation. Violates: Fourth Amendment as to any Americans swept in. Listed for a surveillance program with no threat shown.. Source: World of Spycraft: NSA and CIA Spied in Online Games, ProPublica, with The New York Times and The Guardian
2019
October 2019
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare, the best selling game of its year, includes a mission on a road it calls the Highway of Death in which the player is told the Russians bombed the people trying to escape. The Highway of Death is Highway 80 from Kuwait toward Basra, where American led coalition aircraft destroyed a retreating Iraqi column on the night of February 26 to 27, 1991. The publisher said the game is set in a fictional country. Since 2005 nearly every game in the series has had a retired military adviser.
Activision; Infinity Ward. Violates: None in law. Listed for the version of events given to the people who play it.. Source: Is 'Call of Duty' Promoting Anti-Russian Propaganda?, Snopes

Timeline Events (1)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

December 9, 2013
NSA document on surveillance inside online games published
World of Warcraft, Second Life, and Xbox Live. No plot found.
NSA Surveillance Inside Online Video Games and US Military Recruitment on Twitch | Spirit of '76