2020 to today · Congress, Elections & Speech
Entry-Level Jobs and Recent College Graduate Hiring Drop 19% in AI-Exposed Fields
Period covered: 2022 to 2026 · 3 sources
Summary
Stanford economists tracking payroll records from ADP report that employment of workers aged 22 to 25 in the jobs most exposed to artificial intelligence is now about 19 percent below where it would be if it had kept pace with their peers in less exposed work, a gap that was 15 percent a year earlier. Experienced workers show no comparable gap. The unemployment rate for recent college graduates was 5.6 percent in the second quarter of 2026 against 4.1 percent for everyone, and 42 percent of them were in jobs that did not require the degree. In July 2026 the country lost 23,000 jobs.
For as long as there have been careers there has been a first rung: the junior analyst, the paralegal, the entry level programmer, the customer service desk, the jobs where a person out of school learns the trade by doing the parts of it that can be written down. Those are the parts that the new software does.
The canaries
Economists at Stanford's Digital Economy Lab have been following the question in the payroll records of ADP, the company that processes paychecks for about one worker in six, which lets them see hiring and separation by age and occupation month by month instead of through surveys. Their first paper, in August 2025, was called Canaries in the Coal Mine. Its finding was that since late 2022, when the first widely used AI chat systems appeared, employment among workers aged 22 to 25 in the occupations most exposed to the software had fallen about 13 percent relative to what it would have been, while employment of older workers in the same occupations, and of young workers in less exposed occupations, had not.
The update of August 12, 2026 says the gap has widened. Employment among workers aged 22 to 25 in highly exposed occupations is now about 19 percent below where it would be if it had kept pace with employment among similarly aged workers in less exposed occupations, up from 15 percent in the data as of July 2025. Experienced workers show no comparable gap. The researchers' explanation, in the paper's words, is that employment has declined among young workers in occupations that rely heavily on codified knowledge, the knowledge that is in the manuals and the training data, while it has increased among experienced workers in occupations that rely more heavily on tacit knowledge acquired through practice. The young have the first kind and are hired to acquire the second. The software has the first kind.
The graduates
The Federal Reserve Bank of New York tracks the labor market for recent college graduates, people aged 22 to 27 with a bachelor's degree. In the second quarter of 2026 their unemployment rate was about 5.6 percent. The unemployment rate for all workers, by the Bureau of Labor Statistics' report for July 2026, was 4.1 percent. The degree that was supposed to be the safer position now comes with the higher rate. The New York Fed's underemployment rate, the share of recent graduates working in jobs that do not require a degree, edged up to 42 percent.
The economy behind it
The bureau's July 2026 report counted 6.9 million unemployed and a loss of 23,000 payroll jobs in the month. The unemployment rate of 4.1 percent is not high by the standards of past recessions. What the payroll records show is that the losses are not spread evenly by age. They are concentrated in the people at the start, in the jobs that were the start.
Primary Sources (3)
Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.
Documented Records (1)
Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.
Timeline Events (1)
Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.
More in Congress, Elections & Speech
View all stories in Congress, Elections & Speech → · Topic overview →
- September 3 to October 1, 2026YouTube's September 2026 Ban on Firearm Sponsorships Following Gun Control LobbyingOn September 3, 2026 YouTube replaced its policy on paid product placements with a policy on branded content, which it defines as content a creator makes under a brand's influence in exchange for payment, free products, or a sponsorship. The new page lists weapons and ammunition among the things branded content may not feature, says the rule covers the whole video, and says YouTube may remove videos that break it. YouTube told creators the rewrite brought no dramatic changes. In 2024 its spokespeople described its rule on gun sponsorships differently to two news outlets. Thirteen days after the announcement The Smoking Gun, a program of the Everytown for Gun Safety Support Fund, published a report on gun channels and their sponsors that said the change came while the report was being written. Gun Owners of America says the change likely came from pressure by gun control groups and officials, as it says the 2024 changes did. The record shows who asked YouTube for changes before, who claimed credit, and what YouTube said about it. It does not show why YouTube made this one.Congress, Elections & Speech
- 2012 to 2026Congressional Stock Trading and How Lawmakers Quietly Gutted the 2012 STOCK ActMembers of Congress may own and trade the stocks of the companies they regulate. In 2012, after a television report on their trading, Congress passed the STOCK Act 96 to 3 and 417 to 2 to require disclosure within 45 days. A year later it repealed the searchable database by unanimous consent, with no debate. The penalty for a late filing is $200. In 2020 four senators sold stock after a private briefing on the coming pandemic; the Justice Department closed every investigation without a charge. In 2025 members bought stock in the days around the president's tariff announcements. On July 22, 2026 the House passed a bill, 232 to 198, that bans new purchases but lets members keep what they hold, and attached a voter ID requirement that has stalled it in the Senate. No member of Congress has ever been prosecuted under the act.Congress, Elections & Speech
- 1978 to 2026Why $1.65 Trillion in Student Loans Cannot Be Discharged in BankruptcyAmericans owe $1.651 trillion in student loans, and 7.83 percent of it was at least 90 days late in June 2026. A student loan is the one consumer debt Congress has made nearly impossible to discharge in bankruptcy, in laws passed in 1978, 1998, and 2005. In 2025 the government resumed taking the wages, tax refunds, and Social Security checks of the more than 5 million borrowers in default, then paused the garnishment in January 2026 while it built a new system. On July 1, 2026 the graduate loan program that let students borrow the full cost of a degree ended, the old repayment plans closed to new borrowers, and a new plan began that runs for thirty years.Congress, Elections & Speech
- March 2025 to May 2026How Rep. Thomas Massie Forced the Epstein Files Vote and Lost a $32 Million PrimaryThomas Massie, a Republican who has represented Kentucky's Fourth District since 2012, filed the petition that forced the House to vote on releasing the Epstein files, over the objection of his party's leadership and the president. The president had called for a primary challenge against him in March 2025 over his budget votes, endorsed a challenger in October before the challenger had entered the race, and flew to Kentucky in March 2026 to say Massie has got to be voted out of office as soon as possible. The primary became the most expensive House primary in American history, with over $32 million in advertising, more than $9 million of it from pro-Israel groups against Massie. On May 19, 2026 he lost, 57,822 votes to 47,539. He leaves office in January 2027.Congress, Elections & Speech
- 2026Economist Steve Keen and Konstantin Kisin on Housing Costs, Debt, and Political InstabilitySteve Keen, who predicted the 2008 crash, and Konstantin Kisin, who grew up in the Soviet Union, disagree on nearly everything. On The Diary of a CEO in 2026 they agreed on this: young people shut out of the housing market have no way to build capital and no reason to support the system, and where economic trouble meets social instability, unrest follows.Congress, Elections & Speech