2020 to today · Congress, Elections & Speech

Economist Steve Keen and Konstantin Kisin on Housing Costs, Debt, and Political Instability

Period covered: 2026 · 1 source

Summary

Steve Keen, who predicted the 2008 crash, and Konstantin Kisin, who grew up in the Soviet Union, disagree on nearly everything. On The Diary of a CEO in 2026 they agreed on this: young people shut out of the housing market have no way to build capital and no reason to support the system, and where economic trouble meets social instability, unrest follows.

The Diary of a CEO put two men at the same table for two hours in 2026. Steve Keen is an Australian economist who predicted the 2008 crash and has spent his career arguing that mainstream economics ignores private debt. Konstantin Kisin is a commentator who was born in the Soviet Union and moved to Britain. Kisin thinks the answer to most problems is cheaper energy, enforced borders, and a growing economy. Keen thinks capitalism is going to fail and blames economists for it.

Why young people are turning on the system

The host raised the rise of socialism among young Americans. Kisin said that democratic socialism is communism by another name and that he grew up under it, so he knows it fails: it takes from the productive fifth and spreads it out, which removes the reason for anyone to produce, and central planners cannot see what the market sees. He also said the turn toward it is understandable. If you are locked out of the housing market, which for an ordinary person is the only way there has ever been to accumulate capital, and asset prices have been inflating for years, you are watching the possibility of capitalism run away from you. Of course you turn over the apple cart.

Keen went further. He said civil unrest is guaranteed, and that the system that failed the Soviet Union is not the only one that has failed us. Capitalism is failing too, and he blames the economists whose models describe a version of it that does not exist. Both men said the political class, left and right, has lost control. Kisin's account is that as long as governments refuse to deal with the problems in front of them, more people will adopt harder positions, and the right will keep gaining because its grievances are real. The host asked whether that means the right has an effective marketing campaign. Kisin said the right has a legitimate grievance about what has happened to its society, and that will be effective at the polls.

Kisin also described the difference between the two sides of the Atlantic. America is a great place to be rich, a hard place to be middle class, and a very difficult place to be poor. Europe is the other way around. Keen agreed that Americans accept failure as a first step in a way Europeans do not.

Energy and the economy

The one point on which they agreed without argument is that a nation's output is energy transformed. Kisin said almost all wealth in human history has come from denser fuel, from hay to coal to oil to gas to nuclear, and any society that makes energy expensive gets poorer. Keen said the link between world output and world energy consumption is one to one. They disagreed on what follows. Kisin wants abundant cheap energy of every kind, including nuclear plants Britain has talked about for twenty years and never built. Keen thinks the climate will break the productive system within a decade and that the species would have to cut its energy use, which he admits no nation will do. Asked what can be done, he said it is too late. Kisin's reply was that this is the true face of the climate argument: world government, no elections, and everyone poorer, and that the only realistic path is energy that produces output without emissions.

Keen's example of what happens when public goods are sold is Britain's water. It was privatized about forty years ago. The country has one fewer dam than it had then, the rivers are polluted with sewage, and the beaches are unusable. He said resources that take a long time to build do not get built when they are privatized.

The war with Iran

The conversation took place during the war with Iran, with the Strait of Hormuz closed. Kisin said Trump walked into a trap coming off what he called a sugar high from Venezuela, that Iran can choke off the world's supply of oil, gas, helium, and fertilizer, and that the Iranians have no midterm elections and can wait. He quoted Senator Ted Cruz, a supporter of the war, telling him that if the conflict was still going at the midterms the party had failed. He said the war had helped Russia, since sanctions on Russian oil had been lifted to make up the supply. Keen's view was the same: Trump was sold a pup, and the country is paying the price.

Keen said American oil reserves are being drawn down and that at some point the physical shortage arrives: no oil, no fertilizer, no sulfuric acid. He has predicted a famine. Kisin said it depends how long the war runs, and that farmers he knows in Australia could not get fertilizer even at their existing quotas. Keen said about half of Australia's usual wheat crop had been planted because of the cost of fertilizer, and that a country which used to produce seven times the food it needs will produce about three times as much, with less for the rest of the world. Both said the only way out for the president is to lose and call it a victory.

What happens to people without capital

On artificial intelligence, Keen's point was about income. If the machines do the work and the vast majority of people, who own no capital, have no income, they cannot buy what the machines produce. Either the government provides an income for a basic standard of living or the result is what he called the Hunger Games. Kisin said that in the meantime nobody will be replaced by AI, they will be replaced by someone who uses it better, and that a young person's job is to use the tools well. He also said that a small number of young men in Silicon Valley are racing to build something smarter than themselves and will not stop, and that his honest conclusion after many conversations is that nobody can control it.

The two did not agree on China, on immigration, on welfare, or on climate. The host's summary was that these are difficult things to talk about and that he was glad they had. Kisin's answer to all of it was the same: nobody at the table can stop what is coming, and the only thing a person controls is what they do with the time they have.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (1)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

The Diary Of A CEO. An economist and a commentator with opposite politics on where the economy is headed.

Documented Records (3)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2026
Interview
Konstantin Kisin, who grew up in the Soviet Union, on why young people are turning against the system: they are shut out of the housing market, which is how ordinary people have historically built wealth, while asset prices rise.
“If you don't have access to capital at a time when asset prices are inflating, you're basically watching the possibility of capitalism run away from you.”
The political class. Violates: None in law. Listed for the effect on young people.. Source: Financial Crash Expert: He Predicted The 2008 Crash, Now He Says Capitalism Failed, It's Too Late! (Steve Keen and Konstantin Kisin), The Diary Of A CEO
Interview
Steve Keen, who predicted the 2008 crash, says civil unrest is certain and blames economic models that understate what is coming. Kisin says the political class has lost control and that economic stagnation combined with social instability has historically led to conflict. The two disagree on almost everything else.
“Anytime you have a combination of economic problems and social instability and cultural problems, you put all those things together, historically speaking, it's not a good time.”
The political class. Violates: The government's basic responsibility for public safety. Source: Financial Crash Expert: He Predicted The 2008 Crash, Now He Says Capitalism Failed, It's Too Late! (Steve Keen and Konstantin Kisin), The Diary Of A CEO
Interview
Kisin on the difference between the American and European economies: America is a good place to be rich, a hard place to be middle class, and a very difficult place to be poor.
“America is a great place to be rich, hard place to be kind of middle class and a very difficult place to be poor.”
The system as it stands. Violates: Equal standing under the Declaration. Source: Financial Crash Expert: He Predicted The 2008 Crash, Now He Says Capitalism Failed, It's Too Late! (Steve Keen and Konstantin Kisin), The Diary Of A CEO
Economist Steve Keen and Konstantin Kisin on Housing Costs, Debt, and Political Instability | Spirit of '76