1945 to 1974: Secret programs · Health, Food & Regulators

Tuskegee Syphilis Study, Human Radiation Injections, and US Army Bacteria Tests on American Cities

Period covered: 1932 to 1995 · 5 sources

Summary

For forty years the Public Health Service watched 399 Black men in Alabama die of syphilis it could have cured, so it could study the disease. Between 1944 and 1974 federal agencies sponsored nearly 4,000 radiation experiments on people, including plutonium injected into 18 hospital patients who were not told, and radioactive iron and calcium fed to boys at a state school in their breakfast. Between 1949 and 1969 the Army sprayed bacteria over American cities 239 times to see how far they would spread; one test over San Francisco put eleven people in the hospital with the same bacteria, and one of them died. Each program was secret until a reporter, a hearing, or a committee found it.

In 1932 the Public Health Service began a study in Macon County, Alabama of 600 Black men, 399 with syphilis and 201 without. The men were told they were being treated for bad blood. They were given free examinations, free meals, and burial insurance. They were not told they had syphilis, and they were not treated for it. By 1943, in the government's own account, penicillin was the treatment of choice for syphilis and was becoming widely available. The men in the study were not offered it. The study went on for another 29 years. It ended in 1972, when a former Public Health Service employee gave the story to the Associated Press. The government's own advisory panel found the study ethically unjustified. A class action was settled in 1974 for $10 million. The wives, widows, and children of the men were added to the government's medical program in 1975 because some had been infected. The president apologized in 1997, sixty five years after the study began. The last participant died in January 2004.

The radiation experiments

In 1994 the president appointed a committee to find out what the government had done with radiation and people during the Cold War. The Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments reported in October 1995. It identified nearly 4,000 human radiation experiments sponsored by the federal government between 1944 and 1974. It found that it was commonplace during the 1940s and 1950s for physicians to use patients as subjects of research without their awareness or consent, and that information about human experiments was kept secret out of concern for embarrassment to the government and potential legal liability.

The cases are on the record. Between 1945 and 1947, eighteen hospital patients in Rochester, Oak Ridge, Chicago, and San Francisco were injected with plutonium by doctors working for the Manhattan Project, to learn how the body handled it. Ebb Cade, a 53 year old cement mixer at Oak Ridge with a broken arm and leg from a car accident, was injected on April 10, 1945 with nearly five times the established limit, and his injuries were left untreated for five days so that his bones could be sampled. Albert Stevens, a 58 year old house painter in San Francisco who had been wrongly diagnosed with terminal stomach cancer, was injected on May 14, 1945 with a dose the doctors themselves considered carcinogenic; he lived twenty years. At the Fernald State School in Massachusetts, boys in the late 1940s and 1950s were fed radioactive iron and calcium in their oatmeal in a study run by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology for a cereal company; they had been enrolled in a science club to get them to eat it. At Massachusetts General Hospital eleven patients were injected with uranium between 1953 and 1957. At Vanderbilt, pregnant women were given radioactive iron. The committee recommended that the government apologize to the subjects individually and pay them when secrecy had kept them from seeking redress or the experiment had hurt them with no prospect of benefit.

The bacteria

From September 20 to 27, 1950 a Navy ship off San Francisco sprayed two kinds of bacteria, Serratia marcescens and Bacillus globigii, into the wind over the city. The Army's monitoring at 43 sites showed that nearly all of the city's 800,000 residents had inhaled at least 5,000 of the particles. On October 11 eleven people were admitted to Stanford Hospital with rare urinary tract infections caused by Serratia. Ten recovered. Edward Nevin, who had just had prostate surgery, died three weeks later of an infection of a heart valve. The Army did not tell the city. It disclosed the test in 1977, at a Senate hearing, along with the rest of the program: between 1949 and 1969, open air tests of biological agents were conducted 239 times in populated areas. In 1966 researchers dropped light bulbs filled with bacteria onto the tracks of the New York subway to measure the spread. Nevin's family sued in 1981 and lost, because the court held the family could not prove that the Army's bacteria, and not some other Serratia, had killed him. The Supreme Court declined the case.

The General Accounting Office, as the Government Accountability Office was then called, summed up all of this for the Senate on September 28, 1994. It had identified hundreds of experiments in radiological, chemical, and biological research programs in which hundreds of thousands of people were used as test subjects, and some tests and experiments were done in secret, and others involved the use of people without their knowledge or consent or their full knowledge of the risks involved.

← 1945 to 1974

Primary Sources (5)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Atomic Heritage Foundation, National Museum of Nuclear Science and History. The 18 plutonium injections, Ebb Cade and Albert Stevens, the Fernald school, the uranium injections at Massachusetts General, and the Vanderbilt women.
Wikipedia (with citations to the 1977 Senate hearings and the court records). September 20 to 27, 1950; 800,000 residents dosed; eleven hospital cases; Edward Nevin's death; 239 open air tests 1949 to 1969; the subway test; the family's lawsuit.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 600 men, 399 with syphilis; penicillin the treatment of choice by 1943 and not offered; the 1972 press report; the $10 million settlement; the 1997 apology.
1994
General Accounting Office. Hundreds of experiments in which hundreds of thousands of people were used as test subjects, some in secret, some without knowledge or consent.
1995
U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Human Radiation Experiments. Nearly 4,000 experiments 1944 to 1974; patients used without awareness or consent; secrecy kept out of concern for embarrassment and liability; apology and compensation recommended.

Documented Records (3)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

1950
September 20 to 27, 1950
The Navy sprayed Serratia marcescens and Bacillus globigii over San Francisco for a week in an Army test; nearly all 800,000 residents inhaled the particles; eleven were hospitalized with Serratia infections and one died. The Army disclosed it in 1977 and said it had run 239 open air tests in populated areas between 1949 and 1969. The dead man's family lost its suit for lack of proof that the Army's bacteria were the ones that killed him.
United States Army; United States Navy. Violates: Consent. None.. Source: Operation Sea-Spray, Wikipedia (with citations to the 1977 Senate hearings and the court records)
1972
1932 to 1972
The Public Health Service studied 399 Black men with syphilis in Macon County, Alabama for forty years without telling them what they had or treating them, after penicillin became the standard cure in the 1940s. The study ended when the Associated Press reported it in 1972. A $10 million settlement followed in 1974 and an apology in 1997.
United States Public Health Service. Violates: The right to life; the duty of a physician. Found ethically unjustified by the government's own panel.. Source: The Untreated Syphilis Study at Tuskegee Timeline, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
1995
1944 to 1974, reported 1995
The Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments identified nearly 4,000 federally sponsored radiation experiments on people, including 18 patients injected with plutonium in 1945 to 1947 without being told and boys fed radioactive iron and calcium at the Fernald school, and found that the secrecy was kept out of concern for embarrassment to the government and potential legal liability.
“Information about human experiments was kept secret out of concern for embarrassment to the government, potential legal liability.”
Atomic Energy Commission; Manhattan Project; the hospitals and universities under contract. Violates: Consent. Absent.. Source: Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments, Final Report, Executive Summary, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Human Radiation Experiments

Timeline Events (5)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

October 3, 1995
Radiation experiments committee: nearly 4,000 experiments, secrecy to avoid liability
Apology and compensation recommended.
July 25, 1972
Associated Press exposes the Tuskegee study
Settled for $10 million; apologized for in 1997.
September 20, 1950
Navy sprays bacteria over San Francisco for a week
Eleven hospitalized, one dead; 239 such tests by 1969.
April 10, 1945
First plutonium injection, Ebb Cade, Oak Ridge
Eighteen patients in all, none told.
1932
Public Health Service begins the Tuskegee study
399 men with syphilis, untreated for forty years.
Tuskegee Syphilis Study, Human Radiation Injections, and US Army Bacteria Tests on American Cities | Spirit of '76