1913 to 1944: Money and emergency powers · Taxes & Government Spending

How the 1913 Income Tax on the Richest 2% Became Paycheck Withholding for Every Worker

Period covered: 1876 to 1945 · 4 sources

Summary

The 16th Amendment was sold in 1913 as a tax on the richest 2 to 3 percent of Americans, at rates from 1 to 7 percent. Within five years the top rate was 77 percent. Within thirty years the tax was withheld from every worker's paycheck. The amendment put no limit on the rate, on who pays, or on what income counts.

For the first century and a quarter of the country's existence there was no permanent federal income tax. The federal government was funded by tariffs on imports, excise taxes on goods like alcohol, and customs duties. There was an income tax during the Civil War, from 1861 to 1872, to pay for the war, and it ended when the war debt was paid.

The Gilded Age

Between 1870 and about 1910 the country went through the largest industrial expansion the world had seen. Congress did not finance it directly. It gave more than 130 million acres of land to railroad companies, made low interest loans for infrastructure, and put tariffs of up to 50 percent on steel, textiles, and iron to keep foreign competition out. The economy grew, the cities were rebuilt with steel and electricity, and immigrants supplied the labor. The years 1876 to 1896 were also the lowest point in the country's history for federal spending as a share of the economy. Tariff revenue was so large that the government ran surpluses.

The same period put an unprecedented share of the economy in the hands of a few men, Rockefeller, Morgan, Carnegie, and Vanderbilt among them, whose fortunes were measured as a share of the national output. Factory wages were low, conditions were dangerous, and unions were broken up by force. Farmers were squeezed by debt, falling crop prices as new western land came under the plow, and rising railroad freight rates. Tariffs made the machinery and goods a farmer needed more expensive and let the railroads charge more. Excise taxes, a flat amount on each item, took a larger share of a poor family's income than a rich one's. In the late 1880s tariffs supplied 55 to 60 percent of federal revenue and excise taxes most of the rest.

A populist movement formed around replacing tariffs and excise taxes with an income tax on the wealthy. Democrats adopted it as a class tax on the rich, and Grover Cleveland and William Jennings Bryan argued that the tariff was the mother of the trusts and only an income tax could break the tie between big business and Congress. The panic of 1893, the worst downturn before the Great Depression, gave the movement its opening. In August 1894 Congress passed the first peacetime federal income tax: 2 percent on income above $4,000, about $90,000 in today's money, expected to reach about 2 percent of the population.

Pollock

The wealthy men the tax was aimed at challenged it in court, and the challenge turned on a distinction the Constitution draws. Article I gives Congress the power to lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts, and excises. It also says, in two places, that direct taxes must be apportioned among the states by population. A direct tax is a tax on people or on property. An indirect tax is a tax on an activity, a transaction, or a purchase. Apportionment means that if Congress wants to raise $10 million with a direct tax, each state must contribute according to its share of the population, regardless of how much property it has, which means a poor state pays a far higher rate than a rich one. The rule was written to make direct taxes politically hard, so that they would be used in emergencies and war and not otherwise.

The question in 1895 was whether a tax on income from property, rent or dividends, is a direct tax on the property. Charles Pollock owned ten shares of Farmers' Loan and Trust, a New York bank, and sued to stop the bank from paying the new tax on its shareholders' dividends. The Supreme Court held, 5 to 4, that taxes on the income of real estate and personal property are direct taxes and must be apportioned. Since the rich took most of their income from property, the ruling made an income tax aimed at the rich impossible without apportionment. Newspapers said the court had fastened the tariff on the country forever.

The amendment

The response was the 16th Amendment, ratified in February 1913. Its text is one sentence: Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration. It did not limit the rate. It did not limit who could be taxed. It did not limit which kinds of income counted. It removed the apportionment safeguard for income entirely. The film's description is that the country fixed a problem that needed a razor blade with a baseball bat.

In October 1913 Congress passed the first tax under the amendment: 1 percent on income over $3,000, rising to 7 percent on income over $500,000. The $3,000 threshold was about $90,000 for a single person in today's money, and the average industrial worker earned $800 a year, so the government estimated the tax would reach the richest 2 to 3 percent. The House Ways and Means Committee encouraged citizens to cheerfully support the fairest and cheapest of all taxes. The New York Herald reported young men overstating their income to be among those who had to pay it, and predicted that clerks would wave their income tax receipts at lunch counters to show their standing.

What happened next

The United States entered the First World War, and by 1918 the top rate was 77 percent. The larger change was that federal revenue now rested on the income tax instead of tariffs, and the government had a source of money with no ceiling. The Great Depression was answered with the New Deal, direct federal spending and relief programs, where the response to the Civil War had been to seed industry and let it grow. Social Security was created in 1935 with a new payroll tax, 2 percent combined on workers and employers. It is about 15 percent now, and the program is projected to run short of money within about eight years of the film.

The Second World War added millions of low and middle income Americans to the tax rolls. In 1943 the federal government began withholding tax from paychecks, taking the money before the worker sees it, using it through the year, and refunding any overpayment the following April without interest. By 1945, about thirty years after it was introduced as a tax on the rich, the income tax was paid by nearly every American worker, and federal revenue depended on it.

The film's point is not that the income tax is good or bad. It is that a power granted to the government to solve a narrow problem gets used to its full extent, and that broad, permanent language should not be used to fix specific, temporary problems. The film gives two later examples: the Patriot Act, passed to catch a man in a cave and still in force, and the current proposals for a wealth tax, which would be a direct tax on property of exactly the kind the Constitution requires to be apportioned.

← 1913 to 1944

Primary Sources (4)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

Jake the Lawyer. The 1894 tax, the Pollock decision, the Sixteenth Amendment, and withholding.
1787
National Archives. Article I, Sections 2, 8, and 9 on taxes and apportionment.
1895
Supreme Court of the United States. Struck down the 1894 income tax as an unapportioned direct tax.
1913
National Archives. Taxes on incomes from whatever source derived, without apportionment.

Documented Records (9)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

1886
1876 to 1896
The federal government was funded by tariffs and excise taxes, federal spending as a share of the economy was the lowest in the country's history, and the government ran surpluses.
“Somehow, perhaps as if by miracle, the federal government didn't actually need any additional revenue to operate.”
The federal government. Violates: None. Listed as the baseline.. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
1894
August 1894
Congress passed the first peacetime federal income tax, 2 percent on incomes over $4,000, about $90,000 in today's dollars. It was expected to apply to about 2 percent of Americans.
Congress. Violates: Apportionment of direct taxes, Article I. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
1895
April 1895
The Supreme Court struck down the income tax by a vote of 5 to 4 in Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust. The court held that a tax on income from property is a direct tax and must be apportioned among the states.
“Taxes on real estate are direct taxes, and taxes on rents or income of real estate are also direct taxes.”
Supreme Court. Violates: None. The court enforced the Constitution.. Source: Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 157 U.S. 429 (1895), Supreme Court of the United States
1913
February 1913
The Sixteenth Amendment was ratified. It allows Congress to tax income from any source without apportionment and without regard to the census, with no limit on the rate and no limit on who pays.
“Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.”
Congress and the state legislatures. Violates: Removed the apportionment protection in Article I. Source: 16th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (1913), National Archives
October 1913
Congress passed the first income tax under the new amendment, 1 percent on income over $3,000 rising to 7 percent on income over $500,000. The government estimated it would apply to the richest 2 to 3 percent of Americans.
“We encourage citizens to cheerfully support and sustain this, the fairest and cheapest of all taxes.”
Congress. Violates: None at the time. Listed to show what was promised.. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
1918
1918
Five years after the income tax was introduced at a top rate of 7 percent, the top rate was 77 percent.
Congress. Violates: The terms under which the tax was sold to the public. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
1935
1935
Social Security was created with a new payroll tax of 2 percent combined on workers and employers. The rate is now about 15 percent, and the program is projected to run short of money.
Congress, President Roosevelt. Violates: None. Listed to show how a small tax grew.. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
1943
1943
Federal withholding began. Tax is taken from each paycheck before the worker receives it, and any amount overpaid is refunded the following year without interest.
“In my opinion, ladies and gentlemen, that is highway robbery.”
Congress. Violates: Property taken before the owner receives it. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
1945
1945
Thirty years after it was introduced as a tax on the wealthy, the income tax was paid by nearly every American worker. Federal revenue now depended on it.
“Governments will do or eventually try to do everything and anything that is within the power they have been given.”
The federal government. Violates: The terms under which the tax was sold to the public. Source: How "Tax the Rich" Turned Into Taxes for Everyone, Jake the Lawyer
How the 1913 Income Tax on the Richest 2% Became Paycheck Withholding for Every Worker | Spirit of '76