2020 to today · Housing & Private Equity

How Private Equity Leveraged Buyouts Load Companies with Debt

Period covered: 2005 to 2021 · 1 source

Summary

A private equity firm buys a company with borrowed money and puts the debt on the company, not on itself. The workers, the customers, and the pension funds that supplied the money carry the cost. A finance professor who spent decades in the industry and the president of a teachers' union explain where the money goes.

Toys R Us, Baskin Robbins, J.Crew, Hertz, 24 Hour Fitness, and Dunkin' Donuts have all been through bankruptcy or closures in recent years. Each was acquired by a private equity firm through a leveraged buyout—a transaction that places the purchase debt onto the acquired company itself while extracting fees for the buyout firm.

The buyout

Private equity, taken literally, is investing in anything other than the public stock market. A firm like Blackstone, KKR, Carlyle, or Apollo runs a fund, a large pool of money from investors who trust the firm to place it. In a leveraged buyout the firm buys a company with a large loan, the way a person buys a house with a mortgage. The difference is who owes the money. When a person takes a mortgage, the person owes it. When a private equity firm buys a company with borrowed money, the company owes it. Companies bought this way carry up to 90 percent of their value in debt, and the firm stands to lose only the 10 percent it put in.

The film's comparison is the bust out in mob films: take over a business, run up debt in its name, strip it, and walk away when it fails. In the mob that is a crime. In finance it is called a leveraged buyout and it is legal. It is also common. In 2021 there were about 8,500 leveraged buyouts in the United States, worth $1.2 trillion. The number of people working for private equity owned companies grew from under 9 million in 2018 to almost 12 million in 2020.

What happens to the workers

The new owners are concerned with paying down the debt and raising profits. When private equity takes over a large company, about 13 percent of the jobs are cut on average. From 2009 to 2019 the industry eliminated 1.3 million retail jobs. Employees who keep their jobs pay more for health insurance, get smaller retirement contributions, and get fewer raises. The film points to its own earlier reporting on what happened to working conditions at the Cheesecake Factory after Roark Capital bought it.

Even with the cuts, about 20 percent of public companies taken private by private equity go bankrupt within ten years, compared with 2 percent of other companies. Toys R Us was bought in 2005 by a group of private equity and real estate firms and immediately carried more than $3 billion in debt. By 2007 it was spending 97 percent of its profits on interest, not even on the principal. It had no money to build an online business. Two thirds of the companies that filed for bankruptcy in 2016 and 2017 were private equity owned.

What happens to the customers

Private equity investment in nursing homes rose by $95 billion between 2000 and 2018, and about a tenth of American nursing homes are now private equity owned. The owners cut staff and nurse hours. Residents at those homes are 50 percent more likely to be on antipsychotic medication and 10 percent more likely to die, and one study put the toll at about a thousand deaths a year. Private equity investment in health care has more than tripled since 2015, and about a quarter of hospitals are private equity owned. The Journal of the American Medical Association found charges per inpatient day rose $47 after a private equity purchase. After BC Partners bought PetSmart in 2015, deaths of dogs during grooming doubled. In 2020 the firm Shamrock Holdings bought the rights to Taylor Swift's master recordings, album art, and music videos, leaving her with no ownership of what she made.

Where the money goes

The investors in these funds are mostly retirement and pension funds, the pools that teachers, nurses, and public and union workers pay into. Jeffrey Hooke, a finance professor at Johns Hopkins who worked in the industry for decades, said the marketing pitch is that private equity managers are geniuses beating the public markets by leaps and bounds, and that when you lift up the rocks the claim is untrue. The returns are flat with the public markets and in some cases below them. Ludovic Phalippou at Oxford found that once fees are counted, the funds do no better than the stock market. Research by the American Federation of Teachers found the average fund matched the market until the mid 2000s and has trailed it since. Warren Buffett said the returns in the proposals he has seen from private equity funds are not calculated in a way he would call honest, and that if he ran a pension fund he would be very careful.

The fees are the point. The standard structure is 2 and 20: 2 percent of all money invested, every year, plus 20 percent of profits above a threshold. Hooke put the total at about $30 billion a year drained from investors, for performance that is mediocre at best. The New Jersey state employees' fund paid 14 percent of its portfolio in fees over five years. Since 2006 about $230 billion has gone from investors to private equity firms in performance fees alone. There are also monitoring fees, which the firm charges the company it just bought for the advice of the firm's own people sitting on its board. Hooke's summary was that the managers put up very little money and collect a huge amount of fixed fees, and that we have created a new plutocracy. In 2005 there were three private equity multi-billionaires. By 2020 there were 22, worth $153 billion between them.

Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, said she does not begrudge anyone making money, but that the teachers, nurses, and health care workers who built the country and got it through the pandemic should not have their pensions taken by an industry that overpromises, underdelivers, and operates with no transparency.

Why nobody stops it

The industry reports its own returns to its investors and never has to disclose in full how much it makes in fees. In 38 states it is illegal to reveal the fees. Hooke called the arrangement a protective ecosystem. Out of thousands of employees at the Securities and Exchange Commission, a couple of dozen cover private equity, and the agency has offered no explanation. Many government officials come from private equity and many go there when they leave.

At the end of the Trump administration the Department of Labor changed its rules to allow private equity funds into 401(k) plans. One estimate said the change would move almost $14 billion from individual savers to fund managers. The Biden campaign criticized the rule, and in 2021 the Biden administration reinforced it with a supplemental letter. The Biden campaign had received nearly $4 million from private equity executives.

Two responses were pending when the film was made. SEC chairman Gary Gensler proposed rules that would require private equity firms to report their returns accurately and disclose their fees, which the industry's lobbying groups opposed. The Stop Wall Street Looting Act, introduced in Congress in 2021, would limit the debt used in buyouts, require transparency, and close the tax loopholes.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (1)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

More Perfect Union. Leveraged buyouts, nursing homes, hospitals, and the fee structure.

Documented Records (9)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2005
2005 to 2018
Toys R Us was bought in a leveraged buyout by a group of private equity and real estate firms and was immediately loaded with more than $3 billion in debt. By 2007 it was spending 97 percent of its profits on interest, and it did not have the money to compete with online retailers.
“By 2007, just two years of private equity ownership, Toys R Us was spending 97% of their profits on paying back interest.”
A group of private equity and real estate firms. Violates: None in law. Listed to show how the buyout worked.. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2015
2015
BC Partners acquired PetSmart. Deaths of dogs during grooming at PetSmart doubled afterward.
BC Partners. Violates: Duty of care. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2017
2016 to 2017
Two thirds of the companies that filed for bankruptcy in 2016 and 2017 were owned by private equity. About 20 percent of companies taken private go bankrupt within ten years, compared with 2 percent of other companies.
Private equity industry. Violates: None in law. Listed for the result.. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2018
2000 to 2018
Private equity investment in nursing homes rose by $95 billion, and about a tenth of American nursing homes are now private equity owned. Residents at those homes are 50 percent more likely to be given antipsychotic drugs and 10 percent more likely to die. One study estimated about a thousand additional deaths a year.
Private equity nursing home operators. Violates: Duty of care to residents. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2019
2009 to 2019
About 1.3 million retail jobs were lost at companies owned by private equity. When a private equity firm takes over a company, about 13 percent of jobs are cut on average, and remaining employees pay more for health insurance, receive less toward retirement, and get fewer raises.
Private equity industry. Violates: None in law. Listed for the result.. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2020
2020
Shamrock Holdings bought the rights to Taylor Swift's master recordings, album art, and music videos. The artist was left with no ownership of the recordings she made.
Shamrock Holdings. Violates: None in law. Listed as an example of who ends up owning what.. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2021
2021
There were about 8,500 leveraged buyouts in the United States in 2021, valued at $1.2 trillion. The number of people working for private equity owned companies grew from under 9 million in 2018 to almost 12 million in 2020.
Private equity industry. Violates: None in law. Listed for scale.. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2020 to 2021
The Department of Labor under President Trump allowed private equity funds into 401(k) plans, a change one estimate said would move almost $14 billion from individual savers to fund managers. The Biden campaign criticized the rule and received nearly $4 million from private equity executives, and in 2021 the Biden administration reaffirmed it.
“Senator, we're both part of the same hypocrisy.”
Department of Labor, both administrations. Violates: Government acting for the industry it regulates. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
2006 to 2021
Private equity firms charge 2 percent of everything invested plus 20 percent of profits, about $30 billion a year, for returns that match or trail an index fund. Since 2006 investors have paid about $230 billion in performance fees. The New Jersey state employees fund lost 14 percent of its portfolio to fees over five years. In 38 states it is illegal to disclose the fees.
“The marketing pitch is that these private equity investors are geniuses and are beating the public markets by leaps and bounds. When you lift up the rocks you find out that these kinds of claims are untrue.”
Private equity firms, pension boards, state legislatures. Violates: Duty to the workers whose pensions are invested. Source: How Private Equity Plundered The American Economy, ft. Adam Conover, More Perfect Union
How Private Equity Leveraged Buyouts Load Companies with Debt | Spirit of '76