2020 to today · Health, Food & Regulators

East Palestine, Ohio Train Derailment: The NTSB Found the Vinyl Chloride Chemical Burn Was Unnecessary

Period covered: February 3, 2023 to 2024 · 4 sources

Summary

On February 3, 2023 a Norfolk Southern train derailed in East Palestine, Ohio after a wheel bearing that the railroad's own trackside sensors had watched overheat for thirty miles finally failed. Three days later, on the railroad's advice, officials vented and burned five tank cars of vinyl chloride over the town. The National Transportation Safety Board found in June 2024 that the burn was not necessary, and that the railroad and its contractors had kept the chemical maker's dissent from the officials who made the decision. The railroad settled with the government for $310 million and with residents for $600 million, in exchange for the residents' right to sue over their health. No one was charged. The rail safety bill written after the wreck never passed.

East Palestine is a town of about 4,700 people on the Ohio side of the Pennsylvania line. The Norfolk Southern main line runs through it. On the night of February 3, 2023, a train of 149 cars, 38 of which left the tracks, derailed there. Eleven of the derailed cars carried hazardous materials, including five of vinyl chloride, a chemical used to make plastic that becomes hydrochloric acid and phosgene when it burns.

The bearing

The National Transportation Safety Board's investigation found the cause in the railroad's own data. A wheel bearing on one car had been running hot. The railroad's trackside detectors recorded it 38 degrees above the air temperature thirty miles before the town, 103 degrees above ten miles later, and 253 degrees above at the detector just before the derailment, where the reading finally crossed the railroad's threshold for stopping the train. The bearing failed before the train could stop. The board's chair said she had a real concern about using averages, because the industry's standard for spacing the detectors, which permitted the gaps the train had run through, had failed to prevent the wreck.

The burn

Some of the cars burned in the derailment. On February 6, with the fire under control, the railroad's contractors advised the incident commander that the vinyl chloride in the five tank cars was at risk of a runaway reaction that could burst the cars, and recommended venting the cars and setting the chemical alight. The governors of Ohio and Pennsylvania ordered about 2,000 people out of a one by two mile area, and the burn went ahead. A black plume rose over the town and drifted for miles.

On June 25, 2024 the board issued its findings. The scientific information and evidence suggested that the vinyl chloride had not undergone the reaction, and the vent and burn action therefore would not have been necessary. The company that made the chemical, whose experts were on the scene, had said so, and their view did not reach the officials deciding. In the board's words, no explanation or argument for Norfolk Southern Railway and its contractors' continued advocacy for the vent and burn procedure justifies failing to communicate relevant expertise and dissenting opinions to the incident commander. Five cars of vinyl chloride were burned over a town on the say so of the company that owned the train, and the people who ordered it had not been told that the chemical's manufacturer disagreed.

The settlements

On May 23, 2024 the Justice Department and the Environmental Protection Agency settled with the railroad for more than $310 million: a $15 million civil penalty, $235 million for cleanup costs, $25 million for a community health program lasting twenty years, $15 million each for ten years of groundwater and private well monitoring, and $6 million for the creeks. On September 25, 2024 a federal judge approved a $600 million class settlement for everyone within twenty miles of the site. Households within two miles could receive up to $70,000 for property and economic loss and $25,000 a person for injury; at four miles a household received about $45,000 and $15,000 a person; at the edge of the zone a few hundred dollars. Taking the personal injury payment releases the railroad from any future claim over what the burn did to that person's health. One resident's description of the choice was that unless you have a million dollars to fight it on your own, this is all the money you are ever going to get.

What did not happen

No one at the railroad or its contractors was charged with anything. Two senators from Ohio introduced a Railway Safety Act within weeks of the wreck, to require the detectors to be spaced closer, the crews to be larger, and the tank cars to be safer sooner. It cleared a committee. It has not received a vote in either chamber.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (4)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

2023
Congress.gov. Introduced March 1, 2023; reported by the Commerce Committee; no floor vote.
2024
Environmental Protection Agency. $15 million penalty, $235 million cleanup, $25 million health program, $30 million monitoring, $6 million for waterways.
2024
The Allegheny Front. The bearing temperatures; the vent and burn not necessary; the railroad's failure to pass on dissenting opinions to the incident commander; 2,000 evacuated.
2024
The Allegheny Front. Judge Pearson's approval; the twenty mile class; up to $70,000 and $25,000 within two miles; the release of injury claims.

Documented Records (1)

Chronological entries extracted from the primary sources above.

2024
February 3 to 6, 2023, findings June 25, 2024
A Norfolk Southern train derailed in East Palestine after its own detectors had tracked an overheating bearing for thirty miles. On the railroad's and its contractors' advice, five cars of vinyl chloride were vented and burned over the town. The NTSB found the burn was not necessary and that the railroad had not passed the chemical maker's dissent to the incident commander. The railroad settled with the government for $310 million, including a $15 million penalty, and with residents for $600 million in exchange for their injury claims. No one was charged. The rail safety bill did not get a vote.
“No explanation or argument for Norfolk Southern Railway and its contractors' continued advocacy for the vent and burn procedure justifies failing to communicate relevant expertise and dissenting opinions to the incident commander.”
Norfolk Southern; its contractors; the incident command. Violates: The duty to inform the officials deciding. No charge.. Source: 5 takeaways from the NTSB investigation of Ohio train derailment, The Allegheny Front

Timeline Events (3)

Dated events from this investigation in the site timeline.

September 25, 2024
$600 million East Palestine settlement approved
Injury payments release the railroad from future health claims.
June 25, 2024
NTSB: the East Palestine burn was not necessary
The chemical maker's dissent never reached the incident commander.
February 3, 2023
Norfolk Southern train derails in East Palestine
Five cars of vinyl chloride burned over the town three days later.
East Palestine, Ohio Train Derailment: The NTSB Found the Vinyl Chloride Chemical Burn Was Unnecessary | Spirit of '76