2020 to today · CIA, War & Covert Operations

Seven Government Conspiracy Claims Checked Against Declassified Records

Period covered: 1865 to 2026 · 1 source

Summary

Seven widely circulated claims about secret government operations—a Bulgarian army dig for an alien object, a CIA time-travel program, a treaty between President Eisenhower and aliens, a chamber in Chaco Canyon seized by the NSA, the 1947 Maury Island flying saucer incident, a physicist called by a computer from the future, and John Wilkes Booth's escape—checked against declassified archives and historical records.

The legend is that in December 1990 the Bulgarian army dug for an alien object under a village near Sofia, guided by psychics including Baba Vanga, broke into a chamber, lost eighteen men to something in it, and filled the hole with concrete. The record, as the program gives it, is that the dig was real and the rest is a book. The army began digging on December 6, 1990, three weeks after the communist government fell and before the new constitution, on the orders of a general who had been persuaded by psychics that Tsar Samuel's treasure lay under the village. It was officially called Operation Glory. It went on for almost two years, reached about 200 feet down, and on November 19, 1992 the army packed up and poured concrete into the hole. A state commission examined the site; its geologist testified that there were no materials of non natural origin, no radiation, no gas, and no danger to the population, and that the only odd thing about the project was that the military had hired psychics. Witnesses told the commission that a great deal of government money had disappeared into it, and the project's records were destroyed. The deaths, the chamber, and the creature come from a 1992 book by a man the program says was not there. Two people connected with the dig, a colonel who objected to it and his daughter, later died by suicide; the program records that and does not explain it.

Project Pegasus

The legend is Andrew Basiago's: that as a six year old in 1968 he was sent by a secret program through a device built from Nikola Tesla's stolen papers to Gettysburg in 1863, that he later went to Mars, and that a young Barack Obama was on his team. The program says that some of it is true, and lists what: the government did take custody of Tesla's papers when he died in 1943; the military and the CIA have experimented on children, including under MKUltra; and the government's Stargate program did test remote viewing, with one of its viewers claiming to have seen ancient life on Mars. It then says that is where the provable facts end. The physics does not work, the terms are invented, the man Basiago says ran the program was working on domestic policy at the time, the radio host's confirmation of a detail was in the host's own 1998 autobiography, Basiago's dates have changed over the years, and in 2008 he published a paper claiming to find life on Mars in NASA photographs without mentioning he had been there. The program's conclusion is that the story is not real and that its teller earns a living from it.

The Greada Treaty

The legend is that on February 20, 1954 President Eisenhower vanished from his Palm Springs vacation, met two kinds of aliens at Edwards Air Force Base, and signed a treaty trading human abductions for technology. What is documented is the disappearance. Eisenhower was unaccounted for one evening, the Associated Press sent out a bulletin that he had died and retracted it within minutes, and the White House said he had chipped a tooth and gone to a dentist, whom it named. The program says it could find no dental work in the library's records for that month. Everything about the meeting comes from a letter a writer named Gerald Light circulated in 1954 and from two men, William Cooper and Phil Schneider, who both said they would be killed and both died, Cooper in a shootout with deputies serving a warrant in 2001 and Schneider in his apartment in 1996, ruled a suicide. The program says plainly that there is no physical proof of any treaty. It adds that the 1960 Brookings report on space exploration, often cited as proof of a cover up, says only that the discovery of intelligent life would need careful handling, and that Eisenhower's 1961 warning about the military industrial complex was about contractors and generals, which was true, and not about aliens.

The chamber in Chaco Canyon

The legend is that hikers found a carved chamber in 1972, that the NSA seized it, that a shoebox sized artifact gave two students the same vision in 1996, and that a scientist named Neruda decoded a disc from people 750 years in the future and defected to tell a journalist. The program traces where it came from. New Mexico's archaeological register has no such site among more than 800 projects recorded near Chaco Canyon since 1952. No museum has an artifact. The NSA has never had a division called the ACIO. The story appeared on a website in November 1998, a company called WingMakers LLC was registered in Minnesota the next month, and the free story became a product line, with the discovery date, the number of chambers, and the scientist's name changed along the way, as the Wayback Machine shows. The man behind it, who calls himself James, has described the material as mythology. The program treats it as a modern myth and says so.

Maury Island and Dallas

The legend is that a harbor patrolman named Harold Dahl saw six flying saucers over Puget Sound on June 21, 1947, that the debris killed his dog, that a man in a black suit warned him, and that the people connected to it kept dying, ending with President Kennedy. The record is smaller. Two military intelligence officers, Captain William Davidson and Lieutenant Frank Brown, interviewed Dahl's associate Fred Crisman, took a box of debris, and died when their B-25 crashed near Kelso, Washington after taking off from McChord Field on August 1, 1947; the two enlisted men aboard parachuted. That crash is documented. The military said it had nothing to do with the investigation. The FBI investigated and its files show Dahl and Crisman calling the story a hoax, with an agent noting that Dahl said he would call it a hoax to avoid trouble. Crisman had published a letter in a pulp magazine two months earlier about fighting creatures in a cave, and skeptics identified the debris as slag from a smelter. The program's own summary is that the debris disappeared, that Dahl and Crisman may have been lying for money, that Crisman's connections to the Kennedy case are circumstantial, and that the photograph said to show him in Dealey Plaza is too grainy to be sure. It notes, correctly, that the House Select Committee on Assassinations concluded in 1979 that Kennedy was probably killed as a result of a conspiracy. The memo it cites in which Kennedy asked the CIA for its files on unidentified objects ten days before his death is a document whose origin has never been established; no independent archive has authenticated it.

The phone call

The legend is Jack Sarfatti's: that in 1953, at twelve, he took a phone call from a voice claiming to be a computer from the future, that it led him to physics and to a CIA funded group studying psychic phenomena, and that in 2019 a military source showed him a recovered craft that was alive. The program's list of what is documented is that Sarfatti is a real physicist with a Cornell degree and a doctorate, that a 1973 meeting at the Stanford Research Institute happened and was recorded, that the CIA did fund psychic research there, which became the Stargate program, and that his papers on metamaterials were published. What cannot be shown is the phone call, the gifted children's program he says he was in, the craft, or the footage, none of which has a named source. The program says it cannot decide whether he is a genius, a victim, or both, and raises the possibility that the whole thing was an intelligence operation to recruit him. That remains unverified speculation.

Booth

The legend is that John Wilkes Booth escaped, that the man shot in the Virginia barn was a Confederate named Boyd, that Booth lived on as a bartender in Texas whose mummified body toured the country, and that Secretary of War Stanton arranged it all. The program takes it apart. The body taken from Garrett's farm on April 26, 1865 was identified by the surgeon who had operated on Booth's neck and recognized the scar, by other witnesses, and by the broken leg. Booth's diary is missing pages; that is documented, and the program says nobody knows what was on them. Boyd was a real prisoner of war released on compassionate grounds because he had seven children and no wife. The Texas bartender story was published in 1907 by a lawyer who then toured with the mummy for money, and handwriting attributed to the bartender does not match Booth's. The descendants who claimed Booth as an ancestor had their DNA compared with the Booth family's and did not match. Most of the modern version comes from a 1977 book and film whose authors admitted inventing characters and dialogue. Stanton, the program says, wanted what Lincoln wanted for the freed slaves, and the man who did not was Andrew Johnson.

← 2020 to today

Primary Sources (1)

Documents, court filings, official reports, and broadcasts cited in this report.

The Why Files. An entertainment compilation of seven legends about secret government. Each segment ends with what the program could prove; only that part is recorded on this site.
Seven Government Conspiracy Claims Checked Against Declassified Records | Spirit of '76